• Follow us on Twitter @buckeyeplanet and @bp_recruiting, like us on Facebook! Enjoy a post or article, recommend it to others! BP is only as strong as its community, and we only promote by word of mouth, so share away!
  • Consider registering! Fewer and higher quality ads, no emails you don't want, access to all the forums, download game torrents, private messages, polls, Sportsbook, etc. Even if you just want to lurk, there are a lot of good reasons to register!

2010 BP Mock Draft

Jump to latest Follow Reply
Sort by date Sort by votes
Scoring System:
I used the same formula I used a couple years ago. Each team is awarded points for each pick based on where they picked a player versus when the player was actually drafted. If someone picked a player 12th and he went 17th, they get -5 points. If someone picked a player 17th and he went 12th, they get 5 points. There is no weighting based on the round the pick was made. For picks that weren't made, the same point value is assigned as if a pick had been made, but the player went undrafted.

Exact picks:
Cleveland - 1.7 - Joe Haden
Tennessee - 1.16 - Derrick Morgan
Atlanta - 1.19 - Sean Weatherspoon
Cleveland - 5.29 - Larry Asante - That's damned impressive! :bow:

Best picks:
Arizona - Andre Roberts, Citadel - BP: 233, NFL: 88 (+145)
Oakland - Walter Thurmond, Oregon - BP: 251, NFL: 111 (+140)
Oakland - Armanti Edwards, Appalachian State - BP: 215, NFL: 89 (+126)
Minnesota - Torrell Troup, DT, UCF - BP: 161, NFL: 41 (+120)
Tennessee - Myron Lewis, CB, Vanderbilt - BP: 185, NFL: 67 (+118)
Green Bay - Zane Beadles, OG, Utah - BP: 154, NFL: 45 (+109)
Houston - Corey Peters, DT, Kentucky - BP: 187, NFL: 103 (+104)
Pittsburgh - Joshua Moore, CB, Kansas State - BP: 242, NFL: 141 (+101)
Players drafted in the 3rd round that went unpicked on BP:
#81 - Earl Mitchell, DT, Arizona
#82 - Emmanuel Sanders, WR, SMU

Worst picks:
San Francisco - AJ Jefferson, CB, Fresno State - BP: 79, NFL: UFA (-176)
Baltimore - Jamar Chaney, ILB, Mississippi St - BP: 57, NFL: 220 (-163)
Cleveland - Brandon Deaderick, DE, Alabama - BP: 92, NFL: 247 (-155)
Washington - Tony Washington, OT, Abilene Christian - BP: 103, NFL: UFA (-152)
New Orleans - Kurt Coleman, S, OSU - BP: 95, NFL: 244 (-149)
Seattle - Jonathan Dwyer, RB, GT - BP: 40, NFL: 188 (-148) :pimp:
Buffalo - Jevan Snead, QB, Ole Miss - BP: 107, NFL: UFA (:slappy:) (-148)
New England - Blair White, WR, Michigan State - BP: 119, NFL: UFA (-136)
Atlanta - Syd'Quan Thompson, CB, Cal - BP: 98, NFL: 225 (-127)
St. Louis - Donovan Warren, CB, Michigan - BP: 132, NFL: UFA (:rofl:) (-123)
Others picked at least 100 spots ahead of where they were actually drafted:
Brandon Lang, George Selvie, Charles Scott, Jarrett Brown, Adam Ulatoski, Eric Olsen, Jeremy Williams, Doug Worthington, Ciron Black, Brandon Carter, Ricky Sapp, Tony Pike


Winners:
Chicago - average of +24.2 per pick for 5 picks: 3 of 5 picks positive
Dexter McCluster +39, Kam Chancellor -24, Eric Decker +54, Shawn Lauvao +89, Jim Cordle -37
Pittsburgh - average of +19 per pick for 10 picks: 6 of 10 picks were positive
Mike Iupati +1, JD Walton -28, Nate Allen +45, Jason Worilds +64, Dorin Dickerson -76, James Starks -29, D'Anthony Smith +92, Walter McFadden +50, Andre Dixon -30, Joshua Moore +101
Houston - average of +9.75 per pick for 8 picks: 5 of 8 picks were positive
Earl Thomas +6, Toby Gerhart -1, Jerome Murphy +16, Marshall Newhouse -51, Mitch Petrus +3, Corey Peters +104, Jonathan Crompton +29, Vince Oghobaase -28
Arizona - average of +9.43 per pick for 7 picks: 2 of 7 picks were positive
Jimmy Claussen -22, Vladimir Ducasse -3, Dennis Pitta -26, Akwasi Owusu-Ansah - 37, Donald Butler +44, CJ Wilson -35, Andre Roberts +145
Oakland - average of +5.78 per pick for 9 picks: 4 of 9 picks were positive
Anthony Davis -3, Brandon Ghee -37, Jon Asamoah +1, Matt Tennant -68, Arthur Jones -51, Brandon Lang -117, Rennie Curran +61, Armanti Edwards +126, Walther Thurmond +140 -- OAK killed it in the late rounds

Losers:
Seattle (-86.38), Denver (-83), Buffalo (-49.33), Philadelphia (44.89) all missed several picks and end up with 4 of the bottom 5 positions
Kansas City - average of -71.63 per pick for 8 picks: 0 of 8 picks were positive
Russell Okung -1, Damian Williams -41, Roddrick Muckelroy -80, Joe McKnight -44, Sam Young -77, Doug Worthington -106, Jarrett Brown -113, Adam Ulatoski -111
St. Louis - average of -34.7 for 10 picks - 2 of 10 picks were positive
Ndamukong Suh -1, Ricky Sapp -101, Colt McCoy -20, Jordan Shipley +15, Donovan Warren (:lol:) -123, Garrett Graham +45, Joique Bell -85, Sergio Render -47, Freddie Barnes -29, Chris Marinelli -1
 
Upvote 0
BB73;1698176; said:
I might have had Minny among the winners if I'd let the Jets take Everson Griffen in round 1. :tongue2:
Click to expand...

Griffen was only your 4th worst. Stop blaming all of your problems on USC! :lol:

Everson Griffen -70
Dominique Franks -73
Javier Arenas +43
Kyle Calloway -88
Torrell Troup +120
Zac Robinson -83
Barry Church -56
Ted Larsen +32
TOTAL -175
Average -21.88
 
Upvote 0
Bucky Katt;1698179; said:
Griffen was only your 4th worst. Stop blaming all of your problems on USC! :lol:

Everson Griffen -70
Dominique Franks -73
Javier Arenas +43
Kyle Calloway -88
Torrell Troup +120
Zac Robinson -83
Barry Church -56
Ted Larsen +32
TOTAL -175
Average -21.88
Click to expand...

Pete told him he should have redshirted last year, and then planned for the 2011 draft.
 
Upvote 0
KingLeon;1698190; said:
I'm just going to choose to not go over my performance in this Mock draft. Yikes...
Click to expand...

It really wasn't all that bad. Seventh best by my metric.

Charles Brown -37
Jared Odrick +11
Taylor Price +35
Dekoda Watson -21
Aaron Pettrey -21
TOTAL -33
Average -6.6
 
Upvote 0
jwinslow;1698206; said:
Would you consider including any bonus points for correct (or close) picks? Or is that beyond your bean counting skillset?
Click to expand...

I would. I'm open to any proposals for a bonus system.

I've plugged in:
Exact pick +100
Off by 1 +75
Off by 2 +60
Off by 3 +45
Off by 4 +30
Off by 5 +20
Off by 6 +10

I can tweak any of those pretty easily, so if any one has another suggestion
 
Last edited:
Upvote 0
+03 Bradford
+19 Pouncey
-151 Washington
-040 Hardy
+052 Cooper
-----------------
-117 Total

Neither system works perfectly, though this one makes a little more sense. Bradford at 4 & Pouncey in the 2nd are two pretty huge steals.

I got killed by this:
Teams unwilling to give Tony Washington a chance | National Football Post

2nd round talent but undrafted. We'll see who has the last laugh :evil:
 
Upvote 0
Bucky Katt;1698209; said:
I would. I'm open to any proposals for a bonus system.

I've plugged in:
Exact pick +100
Off by 1 +75
Off by 2 +60
Off by 3 +45
Off by 4 +30
Off by 5 +20
Off by 6 +10

I can tweak any of those pretty easily, so if any one has another suggestion
Click to expand...

Using these numbers:

PIT +26.5
HOU +26
CHI +24.2
OAK +19.11
AZ +15.86
MIA +1.4

It's hard to come up with a fair system. It seems like being off by just a pick or two in later rounds should be worth more than being off by a pick or two in the first round. It's much easier for STL to be close on the 1st overall pick than it is for CLE to be close on a 5th round pick.

Maybe a multiplier for later rounds? 1st=1.0X bonus amount, 2nd=1.5x, 3rd=2.0x, 4th=2.5x, 5th=2.5x, 6th=3.0X, 7th=3.5X? Something like that?
 
Upvote 0
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top