Big Ten didn't look as bad as you think
By Pete Fiutak
January 11, 2008, 1:18 PM EST
Great, now I have to look like Mr. Big Ten again.
Has there ever been a backlash like the one against the Big Ten for having the temerity to lose a second straight national championship game? Columnists and radio talk show hosts across the country couldn't shovel dirt on the league and Ohio State fast enough after the bowls, like getting whacked by LSU is like losing to Appalachian State or Duke at home.
Well, the Big Ten did lose to Appalachian State (Michigan) and Duke (Northwestern) at home, but that doesn't mean the conference is somewhere between the MAC and Conference USA on a national perception scale, as a my-dog-just-died looking Kirk Herbstreit said.
Look, if a fully healthy, fully rested LSU wasn't the best team in America, it was a close No. 2, and you'd have been nuts not to think it'd probably beat any of the other 118 D-I/FBS teams on that Monday night in the Superdome. Georgia certainly would've given LSU a fight (and I sort of think Missouri would, too), but a 99 percent healthy USC is probably the one team that truly has a claim to being the best in the country.
Also, the Big Ten shouldn't be killed for getting blown out by a healed and fired-up Trojan team in Pasadena; Illinois just so happened to be the team that got in the way of the speeding bus.
Second, to compare this year's BCS Championship to last year's is simply moronic. The Buckeyes were completely and totally outclassed, outhustled, outcoached and outplayed by Florida in every way shape and form in the Glendale debacle. Against LSU, they had several chances to turn the game around, but in the end, they just lost to a better team after battling hard for a full 60 minutes. This game was nowhere near as bad as the embarrassment against the Gators.
Third, the Michigan win over Florida and the Wisconsin and Michigan State performances have somehow been swept under the rug. The Badgers played Tennessee right down to the wire in a dead-even battle that just so happened to come out on the wrong side for the Big Ten. If nothing else, the game showed how there really isn't a speed and athleticism disparity among the top teams. The Spartans, a lower-division Big Ten team, played ACC No. 2 Boston College to the final moments in a loss. And, of course, Michigan got Chad Henne and Mike Hart healthy, and voile, the offense worked against the Gators.
cont'd...