Both sides of this argument are correct, and that's all there is to it. Nobody here can say that Pittman and Smith played any better than Ross or Zwick could have against IU. Hell, look at Ross's career numbers vs. IU, compared with his overall career numbers. The offense looked good. Smith looked good to me - better than Zwick has all year. He missed some open receivers, but he also had some excellent throws that weren't caught. One other thing here, that TD toss to Ginn was NOT a bad throw. Several people here have said that could have/should have been a pick...not so. Ginn misplayed the ball, and got lucky. The throw was exactly where it should have been. The CB made a great play on the ball, the WR made a bad play on the ball, and it was still a reception. My point is, it was a well thrown ball by Smith.
Having said all that, it doesn't matter whether it was IU or scUM. The fact remains that Smith and Pittman were the starters, and tOSU did win. The offense is now playing with some confidence. A lot of it had to do with the O line, as well. Again, none of that matters. What does matter is that the offense now is playing with confidence. Any changes that are made this week could well shatter that confidence, and this O could well degenerate to 3 weeks ago. I want the best QB to win, but if Zwick comes back to start, or (less importantly) Ross comes back to start, it could well shatter the newfound confidence of this offense before they even see the field against Penn State. I just hope and pray that Tress leaves well enough alone...and that the offense can continue to gain confidence and momentum.