Sporting News
Can Illinois really snag a No. 2 receiver?
November 8, 2006
The college football world is bracing for one of the biggest recruiting upsets in recent history. The nation's No. 2 wide receiver and a national top 20 recruit, Washington (D.C.) Dunbar star Arrelious Benn, could commit to Illinois as soon as Thursday.
Already, the message boards are very active about this potential decision. It's hard to find a team with such a poor record and unimpressive recent history heading out of state and pulling in a top-20 player. It just doesn't happen without some in-state ties (i.e. offensive tackle Ryan Miller from Colorado to the Buffs this year) or some great football tradition (Derrick Williams to Penn State in 2004). So in recruiting circles, this would be a stunner.
Benn has offers from programs like Southern Cal, Ohio State, Michigan, Notre Dame and plenty of other current BCS powers. He also has a local offer from the surprising Maryland Terrapins and offers from tradition-laden programs like Florida State, Miami and others. If asked to "pick the team that doesn't fit," Illinois would be selected every time. That is, unless Benn is doing the choosing.
Benn still lists the Irish, Seminoles and Terps amongst his finalists, but the Illini have the edge heading into this week. Most fans just can't understand it.
However, if you look closer at what Benn has always said he wants in a program, you can see why he's interested in Ron Zook's 2-7 team. Benn wants to touch the ball a lot, and his recruiting coach happens to be offensive coordinator Mike Locksley. Benn wants to play with a young and talented quarterback. Juice Williams, despite struggling against the nation's No. 1 team last week, has shown excellent promise and a cannon arm. Benn wants to feel comfortable with the people around him. Save for the Terrapins, Illinois by far has the most Maryland and D.C. players on its roster. It doesn't hurt that Locksley hails from D.C., as well.
But still, couldn't Benn be the focal point of the Maryland offense? Couldn't he catch passes from uber-recruit Jimmy Clausen, the top quarterback prospect in a decade, at Notre Dame? Couldn't he comfortable in Tallahassee, Fla., with all those other four- and five-star recruits who have plenty in common with him? The answer to each question is certainly yes, but none of that matters to Benn.
You see, Benn has always been his own man. The more someone tells him what he should do, the more he wants to do the opposite. To him, being a difference-maker at a struggling program is more glorious than becoming another blue chip recruit in the land of blue chip recruits. Benn once told me how much he respected what Derrick Williams had done when he turned down Florida, Oklahoma, Texas, Southern Cal and all the big boys to commit to a struggling Penn State program. Williams wanted to make a difference, and he has become a big part of the Nittany Lions' turnaround.
Over the next few days or few weeks, Benn might have a change of heart and commit to Florida State or Notre Dame or stay home to play for Maryland. He might do what everyone expects of a big-time recruit. He could remain a local hero or head off to a program that can win the national title in the next few years.
But the more message board posts Benn reads about how crazy he is to pick Illinois, the more the locals point out how the Illini are 2-7 and near the bottom of the Big Ten. The more whispers he hears about how he'll never be heard of again if he heads to Champaign, the more likely he is to stun the world.