General Thoughts
LordJeffBuck: Ohio State signed the #4 class in 2022 (21 signees, 300.51 total points, 94.05 points per recruit according to 247 Composite), which marks the sixth time in seven years that the Buckeyes have landed a top-5 recruiting class. All that talent coming to Columbus has resulted in exactly zero national championships during that time, from which we can infer that stars do matter but they don't tell the entire story - you also need coaching, player development, play calling, scheme, and quite bit of luck to get to the top of the CFB mountain. Will this newly-signed crew - along with the historically great class of 2021 (321.68 total points; 94.98 points per recruit) and key members of the class of 2020 (C.J. Stroud, Jaxon Smith-Njigba, Paris Johnson) - be enough to seize the brass ring in 2022? If not now, then when....?
RB07OSU: A top 5 recruiting class is certainly nothing to scoff at and prior to UFM we would be through the moon. We still should be by and large. We brought in yet another killer WR class, a stud QB to make up for the
Quinn Ewers exit, and restocked on the DL with serious talent. Plus our LB class brings in two of the best in
C.J. Hicks and
Gabe Powers, plus I am excited about
DeaMonte Trayanum coming home via transfer. But for all the star power at that position, OL and DB were major letdowns overall. We somewhat salvaged OL with
Carson Hinzman (absolute beast btw), but DB could be a huge problem when it looked on pace to be epic when Jaheim Singletary and Terrance Brooks were in the fold...and that is even if we have a stellar 2023 DB class. Overall though, great class with lots of potential stars.
Earliest Impact
LordJeffBuck:
C.J. Hicks is the highest-ranked signee in this class (.9949 rating; #7 overall prospect) and he plays the biggest position of current need (linebacker), so I will nominate him for my player to make the earliest impact. On offense, I don't see anyone making an early impact due to a stacked roster (including not one, not two, but three legitimate Heisman candidates), but if I had to choose one prospect l would probably select wide receiver
Kojo Antwi, who looks like he could be the next JSN (smooth, quick, excellent route runner).
RB07OSU: I was actually going to say
C.J. Hicks too like LJB, but that would be boring to replicate the answer and will say
Caden Curry. There is going to be PT available at DL and on top of being super athletic and aggressive, he has decent polish in his technique. I think Curry plays early and often. My runner up is
Sonny Styles if he doesn't outgrow safety this season...need help there and kid has the goods. So many talented guys at WR that are tempting despite our depth there...I would say
Kyion Grayes if a WR sticks out, but
Caleb Burton is another one that could force his way onto the field.
Most Star Potential
LordJeffBuck: Quarterbacks almost always have the most star potential, and
Devin Brown (.9808 rating; #43 overall prospect in the 247 Composite, but the #1 overall recruit in the new On3 rankings) has the actual talent to become the next starting quarterback at Ohio State after C.J. Stroud leaves for the NFL. With excellent mobility (but not a running QB), above-average arm talent (but not a rocket arm), adequate size (but not physically imposing), and a bit of a gunslinger mentality (12.9 yards per attempt, but also 14 INTs in 14 games), Brown reminds me of another former Buckeye QB, namely Joey Burrow (they even look like they could be brothers, or at least first cousins).
RB07OSU: Give me
C.J. Hicks, Captain Buckeye himself. Long, out of this world athletic, absolute wrecking ball and missile as a tackler, and extremely versatile and can cover. Probably a shock to some being at the LB position, but I think he ends up being a top 10 pick in the NFL draft one day if he puts in the work (and he will btw). His film is probably the best I have seen from any LB in Ohio ever and that is saying something. On the offensive side of the ball, give me
Caleb Burton. Crazy athletic, big catch radius, and flat out gets open...maybe it is the Texas thing, but he screams Garrett Wilson to me. Lots of guys could go here (like LJB said,
Devin Brown is a potential star...any of our WRs are an easy pick...the DL is just loaded).
Most Intriguing
LordJeffBuck: Alex "Sonny" Styles was one of the top prospects in the Class of 2023, then reclassified to the Class of 2022 and managed to retain his lofty 5-star status (.9938 rating; #12 overall prospect). Listed as a safety prospect by 247 Recruiting, Sonny has already outgrown that position (6-foot-4, 215 pounds). Only one question remains: Will Sonny eventually end up at linebacker or defensive end, or will he be stuck somewhere in between? Athletic tweeners have a high risk, high-reward profile, and I present two former Buckeye safety prospects as evidence: 2014 signee Sam Hubbard (6-foot-6, 223 pounds), who morphed into a star defensive end with a long future in the NFL; and 2019 signee Craig Young (6-foot-5, 200 pounds), who couldn't add weight, couldn't play in space, and barely saw the field at Ohio State before transferring to Kansas after last season. Styles certainly has the athleticism and talent, but he might need a year or three to grow into his body and find his best position on the field.
RB07OSU: Hero Kanu. Dude is a specimen that has barely played the game and has massive upside at a position that is wide open in the near future for PT. One of the most important gets in that class imo.
Tegra Tshabola is another one, kid has an amazing frame and size, and a lot of room to develop in his technique at yet another position that is pretty open in the upcoming years.
Kenyatta Jackson is another one I think just oozes with potential, kid has the frame and athleticism to be a nightmare on the edge. I know that is three guys but I can't help it on this category.
Biggest Reach
LordJeffBuck: Yeah, this one ain't too hard.... Three-star offensive tackle
Avery Henry (.8692 rating; #704 overall prospect) is the lowest-rated recruit in the class by nearly 300 spots, and that's
after he received a massive ratings boost as the result of landing his Buckeye offer. To make matters even more dicey, Henry played at a small school (Division IV St. Clairsville), so he doesn't have much (if any) experience going against FBS prospects. However, Henry is a chiseled 6-foot-6, 305 pounds, so at least he looks like Tarzan.
RB07OSU: Avery Henry. I mean, I like his frame and you always want to root for the Ohio OL with special powers and all. However, this one feels like Stud knew he missed on his targets not named
Tegra Tshabola and had to plug a hole. Plus he played against awful competition and I don't even know that we saw him in person at camp? Fingers crossed he proves me wrong.
Sleeper
LordJeffBuck: As I've said in the past, you don't have many sleepers in your class when your average recruit has a rating of 94.05 points. With that being said, I will go with defensive back
Kye Stokes, the Buckeyes' third-lowest ranked recruit (.8933 rating; #357 overall prospect), as my sleeper for the Class of 2022. At 6-foot-2, 185 pounds, Stokes is currently slotted to be a safety in the Ohio State defense, and he certainly has the ball-hawking skills to excel at that position. But with great length and legit 10.80 speed in the 100 meters, could Stokes possibly be a Jeff Okudah clone at cornerback? Now that would make Stokes an all-time sleeper success story.
RB07OSU:
Kye Stokes. Super long and athletic with big upside, could be the next Malik Hooker type for us at safety with some development from our staff.
Ryan Turner is another that I think could turn out like a Damon Arnette for us. I also would have said
Kyion Grayes but the cat got out of the bag how talented he is, and he is in the top 100 now.
Biggest Surprise
LordJeffBuck: The top overall prospect for the Class of 2022 according to the 247 Composite, QB
Quinn Ewers, committed to the Buckeyes in November of 2020, reclassified to the Class of 2021 a few days before the start of fall camp, enrolled at Ohio State, signed some huge NIL deals, played a few snaps against Michigan State, then transferred to Texas before the 2022 Early Signing Day - I don't think we'll every see such a surprisingly strange career path like his again. Ewers's quick departure left a noticeable hole in the 2022 recruiting class at quarterback, but Ryan Day & Company were able to snag a surprising eleventh hour commitment from former Southern Cal verbal
Devin Brown, who is the top overall prospect for the Class of 2022 according to On3. It will be interesting to see who ends up with the better end of that bargain, the Buckeyes or the Longhorns.
RB07OSU:
Omari Abor. I thought we would not ever get a verbal, let alone keep it. I don't care if Bama perhaps took a pass on him, there were many top-tier programs that wanted this kid and we landed him. Omari and
Kenyatta Jackson should wreck the edges for years to come.
Kojo Antwi is another that I thought was sure to stay in the south and he stayed solid the whole time.
Carson Hinzman was also a shock, when do we ever get a top OL from WI? The answer I believe is never and man did we absolutely need that commitment.
The Ones Who Got Away
LordJeffBuck: Jaheim Singletary and
Terrance Brooks are top-10 cornerback prospects (#5 and #10, respectively) who were both committed to Ohio State at one point in time. But Singletary just couldn't feel the vibe in Columbus, so he left for the greener pastures of Athens, Georgia; while Brooks was lured down to Austin, Texas, with visions of NIL deals dancing in his head. The defections left the Buckeyes dangerously thin at the cornerback position with two just signees, both of whom should probably be placed in the "suspect" category:
Jyaire Brown (.9203 rating; #201 overall prospect) and
Ryan Turner (.8939 rating; #347 overall prospect).
RB07OSU: Unfortunately there are many candidates on this list. But I would say
Jaheim Singletary because we really needed a top-flight CB and he was it. Throw
Terrance Brooks right up there while we are at it, but Singletary is going to be a top 10 draft pick and we really needed him. Perhaps it was never going to stick, but he "got away" imo.
Dasan McCullough was also unfortunate to lose but I don't think that one would have ever stuck given the circumstances. Also see my comments below for what the class lacks.
What This Class Lacks
LordJeffBuck: Someone with definite star power. Last year's class had at least four prospects who were surefire superstars (J.T. Tuimoloau; Jack Sawyer; Emeka Egbuka; and Treveyon Henderson) and they all showed flashes of brilliance (and in Henderson's case, much more than mere flashes); and of course there were massive contributions made by lower-ranked prospects such as Tyleik Williams, Denzel Burke, Marvin Harrison, Jr., and Jesse Mirco; and that's not even counting top overall prospect Quinn Ewers, who was one of the flashiest flashes in the pan. By comparison, the Class of 2022 seems very solid and very deep, but perhaps lacks early-impact superstar players like those that we enjoyed watching develop last season.
RB07OSU: Take a dart, close your eyes, and pick either DB or OL. DB has to be it for me...from losing Jaheim Singletary and Terrance Brooks, to losing a lead on Zion Branch and Xavier Nwankpa, I am truly concerned about our DBs unless we kill it in 2023 and get some developed transfer portal guys for next year. I know I identified Kye Stokes and Ryan Turner as potential sleepers, but those are sleepers you want in addition to the guys I just listed, not the only guys in your class. On OL we whiffed on about every major target except Tegra Tshabola and Carson Hinzman, many of which we probably had a legit shot at... Kiyaunta Goodwin, Tyler Booker, Jaylen Early, Addison Nichols, Aamil Wagner, Kam Dewberry, and Earnest Greene were all legit possibilities, and truly we probably just needed one of those to make this a good OL class.
Recruiting Impact of Coaching Changes
LordJeffBuck: In the NIL Era, all coaches will have less impact in recruiting, and recruiting will have less impact on football operations. At football factories like Ohio State, the "overall college experience" will be de-emphasized even further, and "seeing the field early" will become even more important. Recruiting will not end on Signing Day, but will be a 24/7/365 process to keep your own players happy and out of the transfer portal; conversely, much more recruiting capital (figurative and literal) will be spent in the portal looking for disgruntled free agents with lots of potential or proven players who are hoping for one final chance to boost their draft stock or compete for a title.
RB07OSU: Well, there are plenty this year. Biggest of which is new DC Jim Knowles and I think we are all excited about his coaching prowess. However, his recruiting prowess better be darned good because here is the reality on defense.... LJ Sr has to be getting close to retirement. DB Coach Tim Walton is intriguing but we will see how he recruits. OL Coach Justin Frye I think sounds like a better recruiter than Stud, but we will have to see on him as well. I think the machine will keep chugging with Ryan Day at the helm, but I think us fans should try to temper expectations on getting the early commits as recruits get to know the new staff better.
2023 Outlook
LordJeffBuck: At this time of year, we all have eight or ten 5-star prospects pencilled into the upcoming recruiting class; we'll be lucky if we end up signing two or three. The Class of 2023 will either be very good (like the Class of 2020) or excellent (like the Class of 2022) or ridiculous (like the Class of 2021); it is now far too early to predict the overall quality of this class in general, much less the prospects who will sign with this class in particular. Rest assured that the Buckeyes are chasing most of the top prospects from around the country, and that they will get their fair share (or their unfair share, if things break our way). As usual, watch what happens from the Spring Game through the end of the early official visit period - the prospects who appear in Columbus early and often will be on commitment watch.
RB07OSU: DB and OL are a major focus, we have to hit some big targets there. We cannot afford to come up short at either position this cycle. We stocked up the DL and obviously you want to swing for the fences and keep bringing in big guys there, but I am not concerned on that position except bringing in at least one elite DT. But we HAVE to hit some major safety and CB prospects in 2023. I think we won't see a ton of commits early on, but will start rolling in about April-May.