• New here? Register here now for access to all the forums, download game torrents, private messages, polls, Sportsbook, etc. Plus, stay connected and follow BP on Instagram @buckeyeplanet and Facebook.

LGHL Unpopular Opinions: Ohio Stadium is not a top-5 college football experience

Unpopular Opinions: Ohio Stadium is not a top-5 college football experience
Josh Dooley
via our friends at Land-Grant Holy Land
Visit their fantastic blog and read the full article (and so much more) here


1790166097.0.jpg

Photo by Ian Johnson/Icon Sportswire via Getty Images

Relax, relax. The Shoe is fantastic and a top-5 weekly venue. But for certain marquee matchups, big night games, and one-offs, there are a handful of better environments.

From now until preseason camp starts in August, Land-Grant Holy Land will be writing articles around a different theme every week. This week is all about what we would do if we were in charge of our favorite position group, team, conference, or sport. You can catch up on all of the Theme Week content here and all of our ”If I Was in Charge” articles here.



As sports fans – or I guess people in general – we all have opinions that stink. That’s why they say that opinions are like... Well, you know the rest. And it’s true, right? Even the most arrogant, stubborn individuals on the planet have opinions that are just plain bad. Or wrong.

So there is no sense in ignoring this undeniable truth. Or getting upset about it. Instead, we should just embrace and possibly even laugh about it. Which is what LGHL is doing this week. And being the company man that I am, I decided to really commit to the bit. I wanted to give you, the reader(s), an Unpopular Opinion the likes of which you’ve never seen or heard... Ok, that’s probably a bit much. But I did make an effort to go off-menu.

Without further ado, my unpopular opinion (realistically speaking, I have many) is that Ohio Stadium AKA The Horseshoe or simply The Shoe is not a top-5 college football stadium/venue.

At least not when it comes to hosting marquee matchups, night games, one-offs, and/or special occasions. In other words, attending a run-of-the-mill game in or at The Shoe is not a top-5 CFB experience.

Photo by Ben Jackson/Getty Images

Now, before I go any further, I’d like – nay, I need – to apologize to my Buckeye brethren and sistren (yes, it’s a real word): I am truly, truly sorry, and I ask for your forgiveness. I take no joy in writing this piece. But allow me to explain...

First of all, I love Ohio Stadium and do believe that it is a top-5 week-to-week venue. What I mean by that is that if you love college football and/or the Buckeyes, or you have season tickets, or you want to bring friends and family to a game, or you just want to guarantee yourself a great gameday experience, then The Shoe is always going to deliver. It’s big, it’s beautiful, it’s historic, it’s loud, it’s just an amazing place to be.

However, if one is looking for a CFB-related bucket list experience, then I would say that there are at least five venues better than the nearly 102-year-old stadium located at 411 Woody Hayes Drive in Columbus, Ohio. There just are. Although, I will sort of contradict myself here and say that The Shoe is really, really tough to beat when Ohio State hosts Michigan. But I still believe that there are (at least five) better experiences to be had elsewhere.

**I should point out that I have only attended a handful of non-OSU CFB games in a handful of stadiums, so take my unpopular opinion with a grain of salt. But I stand by it.

Here are my top five CFB venues (atmosphere/game-specific), in no particular order:


Any big game at the Rose Bowl (UCLA)


To be clear, I am fully aware that it is Rose Bowl Stadium. But I will always refer to it as just the Rose Bowl. For my money, the Rose Bowl is the most beautiful CFB setting in existence. Night games are great, but the sun setting during an afternoon marquee matchup is even better. Who cares if UCLA stinks, the Bruins’ home stadium is iconic.

Photo by Ric Tapia/Icon Sportswire via Getty Images

Night game at Tiger Stadium AKA “the real Death Valley” (LSU)


Night games at Tiger Stadium are pure electricity. But I can’t pinpoint one reason why; I think it’s just the combination of everything. Regardless, Death Valley at night seems louder, more rowdy, and more raucous than any other stadium in CFB, so that’s why it gets a spot in my top-5.


Night White Out game at Beaver Stadium (Penn State)


Begrudgingly, I had to put a different Big Ten venue in my top-5. But there is simply no denying that night White Out games go extremely hard in the paint.

Photo by Scott Taetsch/Getty Images

Any big game at Notre Dame Stadium (ND)


Sure, there are older, bigger, louder stadiums, but Notre Dame’s is (the most?) synonymous with college football. It is steeped in history and tradition, and every game at “The House that Rockne Built” seems like an event. In that way, Notre Dame Stadium is like Madison Square Garden... Iconic.


Night game at Lane Stadium (Virginia Tech)


Two words: Enter Sandman. The Hokies taking the field to Metallica’s “Enter Sandman” for a night game is absolutely, unequivocally, without a doubt the coolest freaking thing in CFB. I won’t hear anything to the contrary. VT might not be a good team, but I get chills just watching them run out of the tunnel. For now, I can only imagine what that’s like in person.


Goosebumps. Every. Single. Time. pic.twitter.com/6F5yRrduas

— ACC Network (@accnetwork) September 3, 2023


So there ya have it. That wasn’t so bad or unpopular, was it? I didn’t badmouth or eviscerate Ohio Stadium. And I certainly didn’t make a case for “The Big House” as a top-5 CFB venue. I just happen to think that there are at least a handful of other stadiums and/or sites that provide a better one-off experience than The Shoe.

Don’t shoot the messenger, folks. I think we all know that it’s true.

But still, Go Bucks!

Continue reading...

WNBA

Thought there might be a need for this one. Seems we are in a banner year to watch the women play basketball. Considering the quality of the WNBA draft, there are alot of players that are making a splash in this under-watched aspect of sports. Having Caitlyn on Iowa's team and the quality of tOSU's women's basketball over the past few years, my wife and I have watched more women's basketball (and seen in person several games at the Schott) over the years. Also appears that this draft class has sparked a new (?) aspect to the game, such as sell-out crowds for the pros, and more TV coverage than previous. Believe this is super. Certainly understand the attitude of the more established stars of the WNBA, as they were pioneers, but I believe they should be happy that this is an awakening to we viewers that they exist. And no one can argue that more TV exposure is a bad thing. With $72k as top pay per year, wow. What a bargain. Already, teams are flying charter, rather than commercial, which is a pretty neat first step towards upping the game. Gonna stay away from any controversy (for now), but believe this is a discussion for BPers. Your thoughts?

LGHL A busy June of recruiting visits continues for Ohio State

A busy June of recruiting visits continues for Ohio State
Caleb Houser
via our friends at Land-Grant Holy Land
Visit their fantastic blog and read the full article (and so much more) here


Syndication: The Columbus Dispatch

Adam Cairns/Columbus Dispatch / USA TODAY NETWORK

The Buckeyes are set for a loaded month of June, and it all starts this weekend.

It’s the end of May, and that means one thing for Ohio State football recruiting: Visit season. It all gets started this weekend as the coaching staff starts to bring in priority recruiting targets now that June is here, and these next several weeks could play a major role in the eventual outcome of the 2025 class and beyond.

Seeing new names added to the list of visitors scheduled to be in Columbus throughout this next month, Wednesday was another example of visit plans being shared by some of the top future prospects across the country.

2026 QB sets visit plans to see Ohio State


Ohio State has offered 10 quarterbacks in the 2026 class from various recruiting hotbeds. Seeing several players own Buckeye offers in California, Georgia and Florida, it’s clear to see where both Ryan Day and Chip Kelly are focusing the bulk of their attention when it comes to finding the signal caller in the next cycle.

In great shape in 2025 thanks to Tavien St. Clair, Ohio State has really been able to prioritize the future cycles, and that frees up a ton of time to work on the next big name. It’s up in the air still on who “the guy” is going to be, but with a very talented cycle at the quarterback position and plenty of elite depth already in Columbus, odds are the Buckeyes should fare pretty well.

That said, these offered players are going to start coming around more often this summer. On Wednesday, 2026 signal caller Brodie McWhorter revealed his plans for the coming months. A busy few weeks for the Georgia native, McWhorter will be at Ohio State on June 17, but has other trips planned to see the likes of Clemson, North Carolina, Auburn, Alabama, and Georgia all before Ohio State.

Fortunately, as of now it helps the Buckeyes that they get the last visit as things are currently slotted.

The No. 269 player nationally, McWhorter is the 17th-best QB in the class per the 247Sports Composite.


Top 10 2026 QB Brodie McWhorter will see a half-dozen programs to kick off his summer trips. A verbal commitment could come before the 2024 season begins, he tells @Rivals. https://t.co/Zw2Z0aKlpe pic.twitter.com/CVGo8Ksada

— John Garcia, Jr. (@JohnGarcia_Jr) May 29, 2024

Pair of Illinois tight ends eyeing the Buckeyes


Every position is a priority this June when it comes to visits, and Illinois is becoming a fairly fertile recruiting ground Ohio State is paying attention to over the last few cycles. In 2026, it boasts some of the more talented tight ends the class has to offer.

That starts with Mack Sutter, the top player in Illinois for 2026. Sutter is a 6-foot-5, 215 pound athlete with a frame that creates an advantage in the pass game already, but also has the potential to be a great in-line talent once weight is added.

The No. 102 player nationally and eighth best athlete in per the 247Sports Composite, Mack has plans to see the Buckeyes on June 6. A big-time visit for position coach Keenan Bailey, a chance to host the top player in Illinois is no small feat.

With offers from every major program in the country, for Sutter to make the trek to Columbus — even if it’s just a short day-trip — says a lot about how he feels towards Ohio State. The staff will take it every time, as they need at least one and potentially two tight ends in this cycle.


I will be at The Ohio State University on June 6th! @CoachKee @GregSmithRivals @EDGYTIM @LettermenRow @On3Recruits pic.twitter.com/YqrG8gyail

— Mack Sutter (@M4ckSutter) May 29, 2024

Switching gears to the other Illinois native tight end, the Buckeyes will also play host to JC Anderson on June 11. Another impressive prospect, Anderson is a bigger tight end at 6-foot-7, 230 pounds. Only a high school sophomore, it’s exciting to think about what he will look like at the end of his senior season, which will be two years more to grow and improve on an already skilled profile.

The No. 119 player nationally and sixth best tight-end in the 2026 cycle per the 247Sports Composite, Anderson holds offers from the likes of Florida, Florida State, LSU, Michigan, Notre Dame, Oregon, Tennessee and several others, but Ohio State has yet to pull the trigger.

Visiting in just a few short weeks, however, shows that very well could change in a hurry, especially with how well Bailey does with his recruiting relationships. Odds are JC will be another name worth paying attention to for the long haul considering all that he brings to the table.


JUST IN: 2026 Illinois four-star TE JC Anderson (@jcanderson34) will have a busy summer checking out schools. Some heavy hitters in that group pic.twitter.com/FetFYLttcp

— Greg Smith (@GregSmithRivals) May 29, 2024

Quick Hits

  • In-state 2026 receiver prospect Justen Hodge announced via X that he plans to camp at Ohio State on June 17. A 6-foot-1, 180 pound athlete out of Mentor, Hodge is not currently ranked on his 247Sports profile, but does hold early offers from the likes of Miami (OH), Bowling Green, and bigger schools such as Michigan State and West Virginia.

Thanks to all the coaches and programs that have reached out the last couple of months. Unfortunately, I can only make a few camp dates work this summer. I’m excited to learn from the coaching staff’s at the schools below! Thanks for the opportunity! pic.twitter.com/VkJWvzME34

— Justen Hodge (@JustenHodge) May 29, 2024

Continue reading...

LGHL Unpopular Opinion: There should be limitations on the transfer portal

Unpopular Opinion: There should be limitations on the transfer portal
Megan.Husslein
via our friends at Land-Grant Holy Land
Visit their fantastic blog and read the full article (and so much more) here


NCAA Football: Iowa at Penn State

Matthew O’Haren-USA TODAY Sports

Hear me out...

From now until preseason camp starts in August, Land-Grant Holy Land will be writing articles around a different theme every week. This week is all about unpopular opinions. You can catch up on all of the Theme Week content here and all our “Unpopular Opinion” articles here.



Ah, the transfer portal. So many good things have come from it (thank you for Justin Fields, Caleb Downs, Quinshon Judkins, etc.). However, I think we all can agree it’s getting a little out of control. Or, maybe just me? It’s certainly a controversial topic, so let’s get into it.

Let me just state right away that I love the transfer portal. I think it is a great tool for athletes to do what is best for them. Perhaps the school they chose when they were 17 or 18 years old no longer suits them. Whether it be a head coach departure, a rough culture or it turned out to simply not be the right fit, the transfer portal definitely comes in handy.

Yet, we must keep in mind that when an athlete commits to a school, they call it a “commitment” for a reason. This athlete pledges to give their everything to whichever program they choose. Do they promise four years? Not usually. But it’s a two-way street.

An athlete chooses a school because they think it is what is best for them individually. The school chooses them because it thinks they can help their program win. Maybe that doesn’t happen in the first year or two an athlete is there, so they jump ship to a different school.

I’m not saying they shouldn’t be allowed to do that. They should have the choice to leave. However, I do think they owe it to the program to at least finish out the season. So many athletes enter the transfer portal — that decision alone can disrupt a team’s chemistry — before the season ends. Or, they just fully transfer.

The most recent fall/winter window officially opened on Dec. 4, 2023, and closed on Jan. 2, 2024, giving athletes 30 days to enter the portal at the end of the regular season. Over 2,000 student-athletes entered the portal, setting a record.

So, many of these athletes skipped bowl games. You might think this isn’t a big deal. But personally, I believe that they shouldn’t be allowed to. Yes, a lot of players sit them out because they are going pro. But most of the time, they still stay with the team for the game.

For the majority of the players on a team, this could be their last game ever. They will not go pro. Therefore, a bowl game is most likely the biggest game of their career. I believe that they should have the best opportunity to win, which means having as much of their core roster as possible. I think an athlete can finish the season with their team before they choose to transfer.

Another piece of the puzzle is how many times should a player be allowed to transfer. The NCAA has no set limit on this amount, as long as the student-athlete remains in good academic standing.

Florida State Spring Football Garnet and Gold Spring Showcase Game
Photo by Don Juan Moore/Getty Images

The one-and-done tactic has moved into the college football world but in a different sense. Many players are playing one year for a school before they transfer to another and another. Take D.J. Uiagalelei for example. He started his career at Clemson, before transferring to Oregon State and now he is at Florida State.

This screws up college’s recruiting process and is also making collegiate athletics more like the pros. If a player doesn’t like the team he is on, he can request a trade. In college, they can just transfer. I think there need to be some more regulations, with some exceptions of course in specific situations and circumstances.

The transfer portal is as lenient as it has ever been. We have seen positive and negative effects from it. What do you think should happen in the future of the transfer portal?

Continue reading...

Filter

Back
Top