It was the flawed Byers argument: give it to the guy who's not coming back; Smith will get it in time. It was wrong in 1984, and it's been wrong the last two years.
I asked ChatGPT. Here's the link followed by a cut-and-paste of the prompt and response.
Here's a chat someone thought you'd want to see.
chatgpt.com
Me: Who SHOULD HAVE won the 1984 Heisman Trophy?
ChatGPT:
Keith Byars of Ohio State.
And I don't think it's particularly close.
Doug Flutie's Hail Mary against Miami was one of the most memorable plays in college football history. But the Heisman is supposed to recognize the best player over an entire season, not the most memorable moment.
Byars had an extraordinary 1984 season, and there's a very strong argument that he was the better football player that year.
Look at the comparison:
| Rushing yards |
1,655 |
379 |
| Rushing TDs |
22 |
3 |
| Passing yards |
— |
3,454 |
| Passing TDs |
— |
27 |
| Total offensive yards |
— |
3,782 |
Byars also contributed as a receiver. His production was remarkable.
College Football at Sports-Reference.com+1
One qualification: Flutie's season was genuinely outstanding. He threw for 3,454 yards and 27 touchdowns, and his Hail Mary wasn't actually responsible for winning the Heisman—the ballots had already been mailed.
Heisman+1
But here's what really bothers me about the voting:
- Flutie received 678 first-place votes.
- Byars received only 87.
- Byars received 427 second-place votes.
That suggests voters overwhelmingly agreed Byars was an outstanding player, but the national narrative surrounding Flutie was simply overwhelming.
My vote: Keith Byars. Flutie had the more spectacular passing season, but Byars was an extraordinarily productive, versatile offensive weapon. I think he deserved the trophy.
And I'm not saying that just because Byars wore scarlet and gray.