Started one of these in the basketball area too.
I have a tie: Steve Bartkowski, Falcons, and Tommy Kramer, Vikings.
I have a tie: Steve Bartkowski, Falcons, and Tommy Kramer, Vikings.
-
New here? Register here now for access to all the forums, download game torrents, private messages, polls, Sportsbook, etc. Plus, stay connected and follow BP on Instagram @buckeyeplanet and Facebook.
- Thread starter Bucklion
- Start date
gregorylee
I'd rather be napping!!
Doug williams with Tampa, for that matter anyone who was decent for tampa you had to feel sorry for.
Upvote
0
GL: Yeah, I'd add James Wilder to that mix. Was there a less appreciated back that gained 1400 yards a season?
Upvote
0
Barry Sanders, hands down. Talk about a class player who stuck it out for a sorry-ass franchise for his entire career. I was fortunate enough to watch him play at the Silverdome once. Man, that guy was quick.
Upvote
0
ashlandbuck
Banned
Gaylord Perry.
Those were some lean years for the Tribe and yet Perry made it very interesting. Especially when they played the Yankees and Billy Martin would be out at least once every game to have the Umps check Perry for a substance.
Perry was outstanding and although later admitted to throwing the spitter, Martin was never able to bust him with anything.
Those were some lean years for the Tribe and yet Perry made it very interesting. Especially when they played the Yankees and Billy Martin would be out at least once every game to have the Umps check Perry for a substance.
Perry was outstanding and although later admitted to throwing the spitter, Martin was never able to bust him with anything.
Upvote
0
Archie Manning, hands down.
This guy is watching his sons making mega-millions and the sad thing is that neither one of them could have carried the old man's "Jock."
Withn any type of decent talent around him, Manning would have been the equal to, if not better than, Unitas, Montana, Graham, etc. etc.
This guy is watching his sons making mega-millions and the sad thing is that neither one of them could have carried the old man's "Jock."
Withn any type of decent talent around him, Manning would have been the equal to, if not better than, Unitas, Montana, Graham, etc. etc.
Upvote
0
Sanders is also a good choice. I'm going to Canton for his induction, which, considering the team he played on, is a testament to his career.
Upvote
0
BrutusBobcat
Icon and Entertainer
WoodyWorshiper said:
Amen to that. As a kid, he was my favorite player, and I think in today's NFL he would have been able to get out of NO and on to a decent team.
Another guy who labored away on a sorry team for too many years was Walter Payton. How do you NOT give him the ball for a score when he finally got to the Super Bowl, but give it to fat ass "Fridge" Perry??? Complete travesty.
Upvote
0
3yardsandacloud
Administrator Emeritus
Earl Campbell, I don't know if you can classify the Houston Oilers as REALLY bad, but for the most part they were poor/weak. Earl was a Man amoungst Boys even in the NFL.
Upvote
0
LouisHMartinez
All-American
Everybody who played alongside Bellisari from 1999-2001
What a waste of talent.
What a waste of talent.
Upvote
0