• New here? Register here now for access to all the forums, download game torrents, private messages, polls, Sportsbook, etc. Plus, stay connected and follow BP on Instagram @buckeyeplanet and Facebook.

Umpire bans Spanish on the field

LoKyBuckeye

I give up. This board is too hard to understand.
Protest filed after ump bans Spanish on field

Associated Press
Posted: 1 hour ago

http://msn.foxsports.com/other/story/3838490

METHUEN, Massachusetts (AP) - Coaches on a Little League team filed a protest with the league after an umpire ordered the players to stop speaking Spanish during a state tournament game this week.

Coaches said the order demoralized the Methuen players and cost the team the game.

"This never should have happened," coach Chris Mosher told the Eagle-Tribune newspaper. "These are 14-year-old kids who should not have to deal with any of this, especially in Little League baseball."

National Little League spokesman Lance Van Auken said there's no rule against players speaking Spanish or any other language on the field. But he said it's too late to reverse the decision or the outcome of the game.

"It appears the umpire was concerned that the coach or manager may have been using a language other than English ... to communicate potentially 'illegal' instructions to his players," Van Auken said in an e-mail to The Associated Press Friday. "The umpire simply overstepped his authority, and there was no malicious intent."

Mosher said the incident happened Tuesday night during a Junior Little League game against Seekonk in Lakeville.

Methuen was winning 3-1 when assistant coach Domingo Infante instructed the pitcher in Spanish to try to pick off a runner at second base. After the unsuccessful attempt, the umpire called time-out and spoke with a Little League official who was at the game. The unidentified umpire then decreed that only English could be spoken.

"All I could hear was, 'We cannot allow this,'" Mosher said. "At this point I was baffled why we could only speak English."

Mosher said he challenged the ruling, but the Little League official said it would stand. Infante then left the game in protest, which Mosher said demoralized his pitcher and catcher, who speak little English. Methuen lost the game 10-6, though the team remains alive in the tournament.

Van Auken said the loss can't be reversed because a formal protest must be filed during the game. He told the Eagle-Tribune the umpire won't be punished.

"You're talking about human beings," Auken said. "Human beings do make mistakes."
 
I still don't understand why the umpire did this. If they are communicating "illegal" instructions, to commit an illegal act, then no matter what language they speak, you are going to see the illegal act. I guess you should tell the coachs that they can't give their pitchers and batters signals, becuase the umpire doesn't know the signals and they may be illegal.

The only time I'd ASK somebody to speak english, is if they are speaking to me. If somebody is yelling at me in Spanish, they better quit it, speak english, or they'll get ejected...especially if their body language is really aggressive.
 
Upvote 0
JonathanXC said:
I still don't understand why the umpire did this. If they are communicating "illegal" instructions, to commit an illegal act, then no matter what language they speak, you are going to see the illegal act. I guess you should tell the coachs that they can't give their pitchers and batters signals, becuase the umpire doesn't know the signals and they may be illegal.

The only time I'd ASK somebody to speak english, is if they are speaking to me. If somebody is yelling at me in Spanish, they better quit it, speak english, or they'll get ejected...especially if their body language is really aggressive.
How do you as an English speaking Umpire know if the instructions were legal or illegal? (Say English is your only language for the sake of discussion).
 
Upvote 0
Since English is not an official language of the United States, ordering them to speak English is clearly overstepping his authority.

Some of us may not like it, But I believe West Virginia is the only current state to have English as an official language. And that passed this July hidden in another bill.

Maybe the umpire should learn Spanish if he is so concerned.
 
Upvote 0
scooter1369 said:
Since English is not an official language of the United States, ordering them to speak English is clearly overstepping his authority.

Some of us may not like it, But I believe West Virginia is the only current state to have English as an official language. And that passed this July hidden in another bill.

Maybe the umpire should learn Spanish if he is so concerned.
Now that is ironic -- the state where reedin, rightin and route 23 are core curricula makes English its offeeshul patois. Guess they got tired of speaking hick.
 
Upvote 0
Back
Top