CHANGING HIS STARS. Recruiting rankings absolutely do matter and also I would take A.J. Hawk over any five-star linebacker the Buckeyes have ever signed, in hindsight. Both of those statements can be – and very much are – true.
Hawk was a three star, but there was never really much doubt how good he was even as a freshman. Thankfully for the local team, there was never really much doubt where he was going to school, either.
From Marcus Hartman of the
Dayton Daily News:
“When Ohio State offered it was a no-brainer for me,” Hawk said. “Coach (Jim) Tressel offered me and I tried to commit right on the spot. He wanted me to go home and talk to my parents and OK it, but I said trust me they know. They know it’s where I want to be.
“For me it was no question — growing up in Centerville I knew if I had a chance to play at Ohio State I was not going to turn it down. I didn’t give it much thought however many stars you get in high school and what kind of recruit you may be. I was just happy to be there.”
The lowest-rated of four linebackers Ohio State signed in 2002
(Note: D'Andrea - 5 stars, Carpenter - 4 stars, White - 4 stars, and Hawk - 3 stars), Hawk ended up with as many All-Big Ten seasons as recruiting stars (three).
A lot of folks like to make Hawk the poster child of their "stars don't matter!" tirade, but let's not pretend like the top-10 outside linebacker the Buckeyes also signed in that class wasn't a first-round pick, as well.
(note: that would have been Bobby Carpenter)
What Hawk really shows is how important it is to identify can't-miss Ohio talent early. Under Urban Meyer, there's a solid chance Hawk would have ended up at Wisconsin, Iowa or Michigan State. The Buckeyes would have survived, for sure, but I like this version of history better.
Entire article:
https://www.elevenwarriors.com/skul...-hall-of-fame-best-tradition-college-football
Some of the other 3 star guys in the 2002 class became major contributors (and played in the NFL) too: Nick Mangold, Santonio Holmes, Rob Sims, and Jay Richardson.
https://247sports.com/college/ohio-state/Season/2002-Football/Commits/
Just sayin': Check it out, that was one hell of a recruiting class.