Nation: "so who are these magic schools who should automatically get a top 10 spot without even evaluating their performance?"
Gee, what schools could they be? Maybe one called Ohio State (ever heard of them?), Florida State, Miami, Oklahoma, Texas, USC, scUM, Florida, Tennessee, and (traditionally) Notre Dame, Penn State, Alabama, Nebraska, etc.
Have those schools ever done anything previously to deserve a Top 10 ranking? Or should we rank McNeese St. above them because some moron named BuckeyeNation (who's too stupid to come up with a creative name, and too pathetic to do anything else besides obsess about other Internet board posters) says that we shouldn't assume that schools like Ohio State will do good this year?
Remember, being # 10 in the Nation is not a big deal. Even saying a bad Texas team is # 10 is not that big a stretch.
"if a team is ranked top 10 for no good reason and barely gets by a cake schedule...do they deserve to be #1 or #2 (which is where they would be by the end of the season)."
Hey dummy, all of those big schools I mentioned annually (as the sun will rise in the East tomorrow) play AT LEAST two games that can knock them off from an undefeated season. scUM plays Ohio State, Oklahoma plays Texas, K-State, Nebraska, and the Big XII Title game, Florida plays Florida State, etc. If any of the traditional powers goes unbeaten, THEY DESERVE THE NATIONAL TITLE GAME! because chances are, they've earned it and beaten other big time programs. By your same rationale, the schools that can squeak by to that # 1 or # 2 spot is a team like WVU, who, by my rationale, wouldn't sniff a preseason Top 10. So, like always, your argument runs around in circles with no point like a dog chasing its tail (or like you would do if I taped a Derek Jeter picture to your ass).
"then they become world beaters but cant make it back into the top 2. yeah that seams about fair."
How many 1-loss teams aren't in the Top 5 at the end of the season? How many? Last season, the 2 loss started being ranked at # 3 at the end of the season. Open your eyes, and do some research before you write pointless drivel just because you're on the Sloop Doctor's nuts.