King Kaufman's Sports Daily
The sad spiral of Maurice Clarett is just that, not an argument against early entry.
Aug. 10, 2006 | We talked a lot around here about Maurice Clarett when the former Ohio State star was fighting to gain entry into the NFL in 2003 and 2004 following his dismissal from the Buckeyes team. I thought he should have been given a chance.
Now we have our postscript, and I still think the same way, even with Clarett sitting in jail and facing serious prison time on the robbery and new gun charges.
Clarett was arrested early Wednesday following a police chase in Columbus, Ohio. Clarett was wearing a bulletproof vest, and police say they found four loaded guns, including an assault rifle, and a half-full bottle of vodka in the front seat of his SUV.
Clarett, 22, was already facing a robbery charge, and a judge Thursday raised his bond from $50,000 to $1.1 million. He had agreed to play this season for the Mahoning Valley Hitmen of the Eastern Indoor Football League, a new league so minor it stretches the definition of even minor. Not quite the NFL, the league's salary cap is $5,000 a week. For all 20 players on a team, combined.
If given the chance, I don't think Clarett would have succeeded. When he did get his chance in 2005, the Denver Broncos making him a surprise third-round pick, he failed spectacularly, showing up to camp out of shape, getting injured, antagonizing teammates and bosses and getting cut before ever seeing the field.
It can be argued, I suppose, that if Clarett had stayed in school -- if he hadn't gotten into the legal mess in the summer of 2003 that started him on his spiral and led to his getting kicked off the team -- he might have gained the maturity he needed to succeed in life, or at least in the NFL.
But then, he wouldn't have been Maurice Clarett. He did get into that trouble. He did get kicked off the team. He would have to have been more mature in the first place not to find himself locked out of both the NCAA and the NFL in 2003. And by the way I still don't understand why he didn't go to the Canadian Football League while the getting was good.
What I'm saying is the guy's just a screw-up. He's got serious problems that weren't going to be solved by putting in another two years at Ohio State, skating through classes and being a pro football player in every sense except legal salary.
Maurice Clarett is not the counterargument to letting teenagers turn pro, though he's going to be used that way. I acknowledge that there are some good and reasonable arguments against letting 18- and 19-year-olds play in the NFL or the NBA. But Clarett's failure isn't one of them. He was a time bomb. It's looking like he was going to screw up whenever he got his chance.
Screwed-up kids grow up, a lot of the time, to become screwed-up adults. That doesn't mean other kids are going to grow up the same way.
http://www.salon.com/sports/col/kaufman/2006/08/10/thursday/