Originally Published: June 7, 2011
Terrelle Pryor faces a big decision
Terrelle Pryor is a gifted athlete but has much to prove as a quarterback prospect
By Mel Kiper Jr.
ESPN Insider
Getty Images
It's all up in the air now for Pryor, his future partly dictated by the decision of what he wants to be.
With Terrelle Pryor now certain not to return to Ohio State for a final season, the conversation about his future obviously will turn at least in part to what he can achieve at the next level. And let's face it: While he'll obviously face questions from evaluators about the decisions that have led him to this stage, his abilities as an athlete won't be dismissed because of the tangled legacy that's been left behind. And the first question he'll need to answer for himself is this:
Do I really want to be a quarterback?
That's crucial, because as my colleague Todd McShay accurately noted in this breakdown, there are major technical flaws Pryor must overcome to convince any NFL general manager that he's worth a roster spot in a development role at the quarterback position.
I'm sure you'll hear the easy comparisons of Pryor as a quarterback to recent No. 1 overall pick Cam Newton. Both are tall, strong, athletic players who have been able to use elite running skills to augment their passing repetoires. But Pryor is far behind Newton in terms of how he grades out as a quarterback. He has mechanical issues, he has accuracy issues and he has decision-making questions he needs to answer. Newton grades out well ahead in those areas. On the other hand, as an athlete, Pryor is a guy who will impress scouts. He has length at nearly 6-foot-6, he's strong at 230-plus pounds and we've even seen him make catches at the college level. If he decides to commit himself to that route, perhaps a guy such as Matt Jones of Arkansas could be brought up as a comparison. Far more an athlete than a natural quarterback -- and with a solid hoops background similar to that of Pryor -- Jones was taken in Round 1 by Jacksonville in 2005, and when focused on football, he's had his moments.
I think that's a route Pryor could pursue, and based on his quarterbacking skills, it might make the most sense at this point.
Cont..