• Follow us on Twitter @buckeyeplanet and @bp_recruiting, like us on Facebook! Enjoy a post or article, recommend it to others! BP is only as strong as its community, and we only promote by word of mouth, so share away!
  • Consider registering! Fewer and higher quality ads, no emails you don't want, access to all the forums, download game torrents, private messages, polls, Sportsbook, etc. Even if you just want to lurk, there are a lot of good reasons to register!

QB Cardale '12 Gauge' Jones (B1G Champion, National Champion)

If he starts, which is far from a guarantee.
If he doesn't get hurt. Not a wise bet in this offense.
If he doesn't expose weaknesses or other flaws by coming back with more film on him (and time for defenses to adjust).
If teams would feel that much better next year about a system QB with a killer team around him and 1-2 adjustments made for him before every snap.
If he doesn't feel that a few million is life changing by itself.
If he doesn't want to give himself another year of earning power.
If he doesn't want to play for free with all of the above uncertainty when he came here to make it to the NFL (like almost everyone else, he was just too vocal about it).

Bolded is the biggest thing to me. He performed extremely well, especially given his inexperience, but he also got away with some pretty poor decisions. Bailing backwards out of the pocket -- especially at the goalline, throwing off the wrong foot, holding onto the ball too long.

Also, every game was in a dome in perfect conditions. No wind, or cold, or snow. He was also fresh and uninjured. He didn't have the 200+ hits on his body that Barrett took. The nagging bumps and bruises and mild sprains and strains that we never hear about. Those things add up over the course of a season.

Regardless of what happens, there is no "wrong" decision for Cardale. Whatever choice he makes, I am pleased as fucking punch for him and hopes he excels at it.

(And I am not even a little bit worried about next year at Ohio State. We have Urban F. Meyer -- I think we'll be okay.)
 
Upvote 0
I am not a scheme expert but wasn't the zone read element of our offense scaled way back with 12 gauge in the game? I know Mili says most "experts" say he would win the starting job next year but I disagree. I haven't forgotten JT's Heismanesque season. Cardale has been an absolute stud and didn't screw up in the limelight. He made many huge plays, but I just don't think we would have made the playoff if he was starting instead of JT for the regular season. In coaches words, the offense would stall at times with him in there. Obviously it didn't stall in the last 3 games of course.
 
Upvote 0
Which pro team do you think could let him hold a clipboard for 1-2 years and let him learn their (and his) style of offense before starting him?

San Fran? Philly?

I think Cleveland, Arizona, Houston, Denver, Jacksonville are the teams to watch for Jones.
Cleveland, Houston and Jacksonville really need a QB
Arizona and Denver need a QB to sit for a year or 2 and take over for Palmer/Manning
 
Upvote 0
Neither Brax or JTB could ever get us out of 3rd and 9 like this guy. Thanks for the championship 12G. Wish you nothing but the best.
That is a good point to think about, next time i re-watch the game. After JT went down in the SCUM game, we noticed alot of plays involving Ezekiel going off the guard and tackle positions more so than before. Have to give credit to Warriner and Herman for those moves. But yeah you make a good statement about CJ, getting us out of harms way on 3rd and 9 plays.
 
Upvote 0
For a guy with a small child, who is not promised a starting spot, and is a "hot pick" right now...this is not a bad decision to me.
His agent, when he gets one, really needs to capitalize on this. Maybe work a deal with Nike for a rise-up commercial of how he came from the tough streets of Cleveland to national champ in an out-of-nowhere fashion.
 
Upvote 0
Not "far" from a guarantee by a long shot. Many, if not most, expect him now to be in the driver's seat for the starting job.
That's nice. It's still far from a safe thing, no matter how many opinions lean that direction.
Which is why they have insurance policies, which are paid only if a insure goes uninjured and gets drafted. Safe bet.
And if he gets dinged up a little but still gets drafted in the 6th round, that policy does him no good.
If he didn't display other "weaknesses" or "flaws" in those three games under those circumstances, chances are he either doesn't have them or they're insignificant.
He showed weaknesses in those three games. There also wasn't much (or any) film on him heading into these contests, and Bama and Oregon are not particularly strong in the secondary.

Most important of all, he has well documented red flags when it comes to maturity and focus off the field. To his credit, he reinvented himself in remarkable fashion and completed the greatest QB debut in history. That said, getting ready for the 3 biggest games of his life is a different animal from going through the mundane offseason or facing snoozers in september. Then there's the incredible uptick in distractions that will arrive with being worshiped by an entire state, leeches trying to attach themselves to him from all directions, even family and friends who used to ignore or distance themselves from him, etc. There are a lot more complications heading his way that he has not had to deal with yet. Then imagine if he is dealing with all of this while struggling to secure the starting spot over a rehabbing player with little NFL potential.
Not sure what you're trying to say here.
I'm saying that at some point, the system has to be accounted for with all of this success, especially when his tailback and line are outplaying everyone else in america as well. Combine that with a system that does not translate well to the NFL and there will be concerns there that will not go away next year.
Again, a few million, before cuts and spread over 3-4 years, is nowhere near a few million.
Semantics. That same sentence can be said about any amount of money. I agree that it would be wise to learn just how little money you have after paying taxes, agents and everyone in your circle, but that's true for the guys making tens of millions as well.
That's the risk: leaving early without giving himself to solidify or improve his stock.
No, that's one of the risks. He has as much to lose by returning as he does to gain. I don't envy his solution nor blame him either way.
He's not playing "for free"...he's getting a paid-for education at a highly-respected institution.
That's n ice, but we all know why 99% of players are here, and it's not for a free major they can fit around their primary career path. Cardale made that pretty clear on the Twitters.
He can still get to the NFL, likely at a much higher draft pick, by staying another year.
Or he can suffer one of a multitude of consequences that cause him to slip in the draft. That's a big gamble for a guy who had so little growing up and had virtually no chance at making the NFL on Thanksgiving day.
 
Upvote 0
I haven't read through the last 20 pages, so I apologize if this has been said:

A year or two ago, the NFL moved up the deadline where you had to declare yourself for the draft. They also moved the draft back to May. It's an absolute travesty that Cardale has 3 days to make such an enormous decision when they actually moved the draft back a couple weeks as well.
The only fair system would be one in which the player could return to school if his draft spot weren't to his liking. I can see where his scholarship slot might be taken away, but under that scenario the player should be able to sign at another school without sitting out.

But then, the NCAA has never been about benefiting the student-athlete.
 
Upvote 0
Back
Top