Dryden;931298; said:
A shade? USC, LSU, Florida, and Oklahoma are playing at a completely different level than everyone else in all three phases of the game, from what I've seen. The gap between #4 and #5 appears bigger right now than at any other time I can think of.
I mean, who is #5? According to the GameDay wrap-up last night, Herbie is sticking to PSU, Fowler has WVU, and Corso had (I think) Cal. Who else deserves consideration at #5? Oregon? Texas? Wisconsin? Ohio State? Rutgers? Clemson? Boston College?
There's a HUGE drop there, right now. At least ten different teams are playing to be the fifth best team in the country, and I don't think any of them could hang with the Top 4 if they had to play each other next week. Not right now, anyhow.
Well let's call it deep shade - perhaps the kind found at the bottom of a deep gulf.
In any event, we both agree that those four are playing better than all the other teams right now. That makes the interesting question who, if anybody, will separate themselves from the rest of the pack.
The Buckeyes could do it - but frankly I think that is still a long shot - but one that could get easier as the team gels and plays clean football on the Offensive side of the ball. That match-up with Purdue looms as the next great litmus test. Wonder if the Boilermakers can crack the top 25 by that time.
Of the ranked Big Ten teams Wisconsin is currently winning uglier, or at least with less effective defense. If they get to October 13th unscathed the meeting with Penn State is a great match-up and day of decision.
The Big East just got a dose of salts from Kentucky so Louisville's bid for BCS primacy is thoroughly tainted. That would leave West Va. from that league untouched and playing at a higher level than their cohort. Oh, and in passing, Cincinnati deserves those votes in
this weeks polls.
The ACC is full of casualty cases from whom Clemson and BC are pace setters - but strictly middle of the pack material. As things stand now the November 17th match-up between these two will be a key game. BC presently has the inside track as all their games have been in conference.
SEC will be dog eat dog, so it boils down to who best survives - will Florida be ready for the challenge of playing LSU in Baton Rouge? Will LSU be able to run clean through the table and that SEC championship game toward which they seem pointed.
Outside of the already mentioned Oklahoma - who is there from the Big 12? Red River shoot-out looms as the primary test for the Sooners.
Not a lot of answers offered in this response, but there are certainly a lot of questions.