My take on last year's mock draft:
Undrafted Misses
- WR Greg Jennings GB, LT Marcus McNeill SD, OG Jahri Evans NO, Dawan Landry BAL, TE Daniels HOU 98,
Missed Sleepers
- RB Leon Washington NYJ 116, FB Ahmard Hall TEN (undrafted),
*****Great
Dallas (Buckeye513) - Whitner, Fasano, Hagan
- Whitner all-rook great value, predicted the real 2nd pick which worked out well.
NY Giants (harrydangler) - Demeco Ryans, O'Callaghan, Harper, (4th not used)
- Ryans NFL def Rook of year, O'Callaghan started before injury, Harper promising starter before inj
****Above Average
San Francisco (stxbuck) - Ngata, Wimbley, Demario Minter, Demetrius Williams (3), Antonio Smith
- Ngata many all-rookie, Wimbley NFL All R, Williams (scout all-rook backup),
Carolina (scarletngray77) - Lawson, Pat Watkins, Jones-Drew, (4th not used)
- Lawson has strong potential, Jones-Drew PFW All-Rookie
Indianapolis (stowfan) - Maroney, Brandon Guillory, Barry Cofield
- Maroney, Cofield (all-rookie)
Jacksonville (smitty03) - Greenway, Klopfenstein, Norwood, (4th not used)
- Greenway (IR early), Klopf (Scout All R), Norwood extremely promising
Arizona (starBUCKS) - Vince Young, M Kiwanuka, Jon Scott, (4th not used)
- Rookie of Year lower in draft, Kiwanuka promising young DE (and his VY miss now doesn't exist).
Atlanta (cbf40, The Man) - Richard Marshall, Rod Wright, Devin Hester (3), (4th not used)
- Marshall PFW All-rookie, Hester many All-rookie
Buffalo (korchiki) - Justice, Wroten, Jon Alston, Mark Anderson, Colston
- Oustanding steals in Anderson & Colston
New York Jets (buckeye247) - Mario Williams, Mangold, Kelly Jennings, Calhoun, Aromashodu, Clemens
- Mario Williams mild reach but good upside, Mangold all-rook, Jennings 07 starter (high potential)
Cleveland (Smooth Olaf) - Jimmy Williams, D'Qwell Jackson, Dumervil
- Jackson big upside (and Clev's actual pick), Dumervil highly productive (8.5 sacks)
Denver (buckeyesforever) - Chad Jackson, Tamba Hali, Dominique Byrd, (4th not used)
- Hali all-rookie (great value)
Miami (Ahiatician) - Sims, Whitehurst (3), (4th not used)
- Sims All-rookie selection
*** Average
Green Bay (JonathanXC) - Hawk, Charles Spencer, Orien Harris
- Hawk (all-rook) but no brainer pick
Houston (BCSBust) - Bush, Winston, Bullocks, Wilkinson (3 also), Blackmon
- Bush (stud) but no brainer pick (unless you're the real texans)
Cincinnati (Mothra, BUMBUCK) - Watson, Addai, Greg Blue, (4th not used)
- Watson reach, Addai NFL All-Rook
Tennessee (Savante) - Leinart, Sinorice Moss, David Pittman
- Leinart showed flashes, avg class overall
Tampa Bay (Lazlo) - Carpenter, Colledge, (4th not used)
- College all rookie Pro Football Weekly and the Pro Football Writers of America.
New Orleans (BuckWrestler141) - Ferguson, Howard, Spencer, McClover
- Ferguson All Rookie
Kansas City (tuna) - Tye Hill, Omar Jacobs, Daryll Tapp,
- Hill all-rookie selection
Philadelphia (ScarletBlood31) - Holmes, McIntosh, McCargo
- Holmes (Scout All rook) promising, McCargo (snagged 2 rounds late, unproductive tho)
Oakland (BuckeyeNation27) - Huff, J Joseph, Nande, Oshinowo
- Joseph (Scout All-R), Huff = reach
Baltimore (osubartender23) - Cutler, Pope, (4th not used)
- Cutler shows promise, leaves Balt in good shape when McNair retires
** Below Average
St Louis (NFBuck) - Davis, Jason Allen, (4th not used)
- Davis has upside but mostly injured this year, Allen mild impact (big reach in real draft)
San Diego (Piney) - Cromartie, Davin Joseph, Andrew Whitworth, Tim McGarigle (3), (4th not used)
- Cromartie special teamer so far, average class imo
New England (sears3820) - White, Bing, Danieal Manning, Stovall (3), (4th not used)
- Manning excellent value... a strong draft on paper didn't pan out
Detroit (i hunt manatees) - Bunkley, Ko Simpson, Ray Edwards
- Bunkley struggled a lot, Simpson showed promise
Seattle (Bucky Katt) - Max-Jean Gilles (1), Cedric Griffin (2), (4th not used)
- No intel on Gilles, Griffin starter
Minnesota (BB73) - Deangelo Williams, Lutui, Croyle (2), Zemaitis, Havner (3), (4th not used)
- Williams showed flashes, Lutui has upside but struggled as premature starter
* Awful
Chicago (Bucklion) - Youboty, Marcedes Lewis, Mike Haas, (4th not used)
- Youboty & Lewis flopped, Haas big reach
Pittsburgh (sandgk, 7 45 33 48) - Martin Nance, Eslinger, Dusty Dvoracek, (three 4th's not used)
- Nance huge reach (undrafted, unproductive), Eslinger reach (6th round), Dvoracek (IR)
Washington (jwinslow) - Hodge
- Snyder was restrained from drafting Hester. At least they didn't trade away a 2nd for a reach like the real skins.