• New here? Register here now for access to all the forums, download game torrents, private messages, polls, Sportsbook, etc. Plus, stay connected and follow BP on Instagram @buckeyeplanet and Facebook.

Media guides must be smaller this season

BB73

Loves Buckeye History
Staff member
Bookie
'16 & '17 Upset Contest Winner
New limit of 208 pages for 2005 season. Anybody know how many pages tOSU's was last year? I'm not sure where they got that number, maybe they decided that half of scUM's 416-pager from last year was worthless. That means that the NCAA was half-right, as usual. :tongue2:

NCAA forces schools to slim down media guides

LANSING, Mich. (AP) -- Fans interested in how Michigan State teams got their Spartans nickname in 1926 can find the tale in the school's 300-page football media guide.

The University of Michigan's 416-page guide tells how "The Victors" got its start as the Wolverines' fight son in 1898.
But such interesting historical notes could be forced out by an NCAA edict that colleges trim their media guides to 208 pages for next school year.

The new rule has sports information directors across the country scrambling to decide what will make the cut when a hundred or more pages in some current guides must be scrapped. And many of them aren't happy.

"This has been a knee-jerk reaction, all under the guise of cost containment," said Michigan State associate athletic director John Lewandowski.

Bruce Madej, a Michigan assistant athletic director, said the university will follow the new NCAA rule.

"But does it make sense to me? No," Madej said.

Schools such as Texas, Nebraska and Georgia are faced with the prospect of cutting their football guides in half before the start of next season. Publications go to print this summer.

Men's basketball guides are the only other publication likely to be widely affected at most schools by the new rules, which were adopted last month.

Supporters of the NCAA rule say restricting the size of the guides would save universities money. It reduces the pressure for lower-income programs to keep up with college athletics' big spenders by producing glitzy guides.

"It's about leveling the playing field," NCAA spokeswoman Jennifer Kearns said.

The proposal also affects recruiting because the guides often are sent to prospective student athletes.

"From a recruiting standpoint, it's more impressive to drop a 20-pound book on the coffee table than a 6-ounce book," said Mike Nemeth, a Mississippi State associate athletic director. "This will put everybody in the same ballpark."

The Bulldogs produced a 296-page football media guide last year, at least in part to prevent being dwarfed by larger volumes published by Florida, Tennessee and other rivals. Many schools devote space in their media guides to alumni in the pros and draft pick histories, although it's not clear how much weight -- if any _ the books have with recruits.

"It's probably way down the list," Nemeth said.

Mississippi State expects to save a few thousand dollars on printing costs with the smaller guides, money the department will gladly spend on other projects, Nemeth said.

But the overall cost savings aren't much for a major program. Michigan State, for example, spent about $60,225 last year designing and printing its football media guide. A 208-page guide could cost about $18,000 less. The Spartans' overall athletics budget is about $55 million.

Smaller guides could result in shorter player profiles, abridged records sections or more selective lists of letter winners -- a slap to team members, Lewandowski said.

"It's their keepsake, the record of their careers," he said.

The NCAA will allow schools to distribute some extra information to media through the Internet or printed in black-and-white format. But including records and milestones in such a way could eliminate some of the cost savings realized through smaller media guides.

The Michigan State guide, like many others, lists letter winners from football teams throughout school history. Each season is listed with game-by-game results dating back to 1896.

The guide details every series the Spartans have ever played, from the 1904-08 matchups with the Michigan School for the Deaf to the century-old rivalry with the Wolverines.

And the book provides history, including the tale of how a Lansing sportswriter, upset with the schools' new nickname, "The Michigan Staters," started using Spartans instead. The moniker, another finalist from a recent contest to nickname the school, caught on.

Michigan's guide documents its string of home games attended by more than 100,000 fans -- a streak that began in 1975. In all, five pages are devoted exclusively to facts and highlights about Michigan Stadium.

There's also folklore, such as how the school fight song came to be. A Michigan fan was inspired to write the song after the school's first conference championship was clinched with a road win over Chicago in 1898.

Dissatisfied with how Michigan fans celebrated in the streets of Chicago, the young man decided the school needed a better celebratory anthem. He wrote "The Victors" over the next few days.

"Every school has it own traditions and the things that make it special," Lewandowski said. "Why try to limit that? Let's not make college sports a cookie cutter like pro sports."
 
"It's about leveling the playing field," NCAA spokeswoman Jennifer Kearns said.

Hell, while they're at it, why don't they make Ohio State, Michigan, Penn State, and Tennessee raze their stadiums and built 50,000-seat ones




The proposal also affects recruiting because the guides often are sent to prospective student athletes.

"From a recruiting standpoint, it's more impressive to drop a 20-pound book on the coffee table than a 6-ounce book," said Mike Nemeth, a Mississippi State associate athletic director. "This will put everybody in the same ballpark."

If we have to resort to putting extra pages in a media guide to get a recruit, then either we suck as a team or the recruit isn't worth going after...
 
Upvote 0
MililaniBuckeye said:
Quote:
<table border="0" cellpadding="6" cellspacing="0" width="100%"> <tbody><tr> <td class="alt2" style="border: 1px inset ;"> "It's about leveling the playing field," NCAA spokeswoman Jennifer Kearns said. </td> </tr> </tbody></table>

Hell, while they're at it, why don't they make Ohio State, Michigan, Penn State, and Tennessee raze their stadiums and built 50,000-seat ones


If we have to resort to putting extra pages in a media guide to get a recruit, then either we suck as a team or the recruit isn't worth going after...
Mili -- you are so right about this its not funny. The NCAA does many good things, I'm sure. Counting pages in a media guide is not one of them. Many schools sell their media guide to fans. Ohio State's was $35 last year I believe. Schools should have the freedom to make their guide as small or as large as their expectations demand or their budget will support. Personally, I'm looking for the Full Color 3-D Holographic media guide with clips of Ginn returning kicks for TDs -- with over 1,000 _moving_ pages I feel its a steal at $2,500.

The NCAA should remember that they are the National Collegiate Athletic Asociation, not the Normalized Communist Average Academy.
 
Upvote 0
I don't understand a lot of this "levelling the playing field" stuff they do. I can understand limiting the number of scholarships teams can give out, and maybe even limiting the number of players who are allowed to dress for games, but limiting the media guide? Come on.. Next, will there be a limit to the size and features of the animated scoreboards? How about limiting the time the band is allowed to play?
 
Upvote 0
This is yet another example of the NASCAR-ification of nearly every sport. Leagues and sanctioning bodies are seeking to create artificial parity to satisfy "mid-majors" (MINOR) teams and capture the interest (and dollars) of casual fans. There's more money to be made when more teams can be artificially kept in the hunt. Unfortunately, it compromises the integrity of competition and penalizes teams/clubs/franchises/schools that have worked hard at building a culture and tradition of success.

And you know what else is funny? With all this APR crap and "focus on the STUDENT-athlete," is the NCAA at least gonna make schools put the media guide surplus money toward improving academics? What a joke! All this means is that Phil Fulmer will be able to get extra Cheez Whiz on his fries, and Pete Carroll will be able to afford another round trip in his jet. The only good thing about this is that no matter how much money scUM saves by trimming their media guide, they still will not be able to buy dignity or another win against Jim Tressel!
 
Upvote 0
Well, thank goodness the NCAA is finally focusing on the IMPORTANT problems in college football :shake: .

Mili, I think we should also think about levelling the playing field as far as all these Ohio State speedsters are concerned as well. Come up with a system that makes them carry a bit of extra weight. I mean they do it with horses, don't they?

Gosh, just think of all the fun things that bureaucrats can think about to improve the game. When we get to the third quarter, the team behind should always get the kickoff. Just so we can get the scores more even. Then, someone like Rice, is in with more of a fighting chance against a REAL powerhouse team, such as Notre Dame. :blush:

Damn. Think about how much time is wasted complying with such crap. I can't wait for the first team to be hauled onto the carpet for a malicious media guide.

"Curt, what do you think about this scandal at Whatsamatta U?" "Well, this has been coming for some time. You know their media guide actually has been two to four pages over the limit the last two years, but no one reacted to NCAA concerns. So, you really can't complain when the NCAA comes to town with penalties." :sad:
 
Upvote 0
Revolt!!!

is there any way to take these fuckers down a rung or two? the NCAA is clearly out of control... where are the checks and balances? can't the University Presidents get together and tell the NCAA to go fuck itsself???

better yet, who is going to be brave to stand up and call bullshit?

is there a way to figuratively throw the tea in the harbor???
 
Upvote 0
lvbuckeye said:
is there any way to take these fuckers down a rung or two? the NCAA is clearly out of control... where are the checks and balances? can't the University Presidents get together and tell the NCAA to go fuck itsself???

better yet, who is going to be brave to stand up and call bullshit?

is there a way to figuratively throw the tea in the harbor???
That's the problem there is no way to stop them. this really doesn't suprise me that they made this new rule because every year they come up with some "great idea". It's always a good laugh every new football season to see what stupid petty rule they have came up with.
 
Upvote 0
Steve19 said:
Mili, I think we should also think about levelling the playing field as far as all these Ohio State speedsters are concerned as well. Come up with a system that makes them carry a bit of extra weight. I mean they do it with horses, don't they?
Why would they have to weigh your players down? Only a couple of them have Florida speed.
 
Upvote 0
If the NCAA wants to regulate media guides... Ok, we'll shorten it... then we'll publish the full length one anyway and call it a 'fan guide' or something. Unless, of course, they've already outlawed such things.
 
Upvote 0
Back
Top