McNabb or Vick?

[ScarletBlood31]

anyone with the power to make Vbookie how about one for the Philly vs. Atlanta game??

 

[Ratboy18]

dirrrrrty south

According to Reno 911, it's durty (something about Nelly and proper country grammar).

 

[11bravoBuck]

McNabb. No brainer. I'd take him over any QB in the league except Manning and the Meatweasel in Beantown.

 

[crazybuckfan40]

Looks like Vick beat him tonite. Neither had good games, but Vick was good enough to win the game.

 

[Golferdow01]

Looks like Vick beat him tonite. Neither had good games, but Vick was good enough to win the game.

Yeah, I don't really think we can pick one from tonight's performance. You can say Vick, but he had plenty of turnovers and how many damn times did he overthrow his target?? I honestly can't remember

 

[jimotis4heisman]

I remember McNabb avoiding so many tackles last year, many of which I wondered how the hell he managed to escape. He's slippery, and a damn good QB.

My top 3 QBs are Big Ben, Peyton, and Brady (ick, scUM). I think McNabb is a close 4th, though.

epic fail...

 

[Jake]

epic fail...

Well, she posted that prior to the 2005 season. McNabb had a helluva year in 2004, and Vick wasn't close. Then there was the prison thing in between.

But right now, yeah, it looks funny.

 

[BuckeyeNation27]

I wonder if the homer who started this thread has had a change of opinion