I kinda like NCAA - but they need to fix a few huge things;
Man coverage - all your QB has to do is drop back about 5 yards, and a receiver always seems to free himself across the middle. You know exactly what i'm talking about - even if you have two safties deep.
Blitz and rush scheme - QB's have far too much mobility; some justified, others not. All I know is, Boeckman isnt able to outrun the LB's from WVU.
On the other hand, its bullshit how DE's from tOSU can run step for step with Pat White. I cannot avoid sacks to save my soul.
Basically if they just took the Madden engine and skins, defensive and (to an extent) offensive gameplay; then just toss in the full NCAA rosters and of course some of the offensive systems - I would be more inclined to play NCAA as it would be a far better game then what it is now.
It just kinda reminds me of Techmo Superbowl - if I go to play against the pass, say cover 3; I usually get eaten alive by any type of running play, even with my LB's creeping close to home. I'm not talking 4-6 yards, I'm saying 9-15 yards on average. Then again, if I play against the run, maybe a little cover 2 or outside LB blitz, any type of pass just destroy's what I have.
I blitz next to never on NCAA, because its that ineffective - so I either play pass, or run. That simple -
Can't wait for Madden
/end rant