I see it a bit differently. I see it kinda like Bonasera approaching Don Corleone. Yes, he's coming back to Cleveland because it's convenient from a career and legacy standpoint. Yes, he humbled himself in the SI essay. But the question I have as a fan is, what did we ever do to have him treat us so disrespectfully up until now? If he had treated us with respect before (and I'm not just talking about The Decision, but the way he flirted with free agency and held it over Cleveland's head for nearly three years) then even in leaving we would still have very little mistrust or reservations about his intentions.
I don't want to doubt the sincerity of his announcement and the essay. On the surface, it's as classy as previous free agent announcement was insulting. I just can't help but ask though, he was in Cleveland for many years, why did it take until now to stop holding the fans and the city, and the region at arm's length?