OSUBasketballJunkie
Never Forget 31-0
CPD
Reflecting on an off-kilter season
Sunday, October 08, 2006
Story by Paul Hoynes
Plain Dealer Reporter
The Indians never did get it right.
Their 6-1 start to this season allowed them to stay in first place in the American League Central through April 18 and their 8-1 finish prevented them from bookending their 93 victories in 2005 with 90 or more losses in 2006. In between, unfortunately, they were a bad baseball team.
Like a car with faulty alignment, they were never balanced.
"What I learned more than anything else this year is to be a consistent winner, you have to have all three things working at the same time - pitching, offense and defense," left-hander Cliff Lee said. "We never were able to get into that groove and stay there."
The Indians featured a lot of bells and whistles. They set a club record with 14 grand slams and scored nine or more runs in 27 games - the most in the big leagues. Grady Sizemore hit 53 doubles, 11 triples, 28 homers and scored an MLB-high 134 runs from the leadoff spot.
Travis Hafner, even though he missed the last month of the season with a broken bone in his right hand, hit 42 homers with 117 RBI.
Yet with all that offense, they were still only 18-26 in one-run games and 11-14 in two-run games. Pitching and defense hurt them.
For a while, the starters weren't getting deep enough into games. When C.C. Sabathia returned in May to stabilize the rotation, it became one of the most consistent in the big leagues, but the bullpen and defense still cost the Indians dearly.
The collapse of the Tribe's infield defense was unexpected. Third baseman Aaron Boone looked stiff and lost range. Shortstop Jhonny Peralta's lack of mobility became an even bigger issue when his offense didn't match his 2005 totals. Ben Broussard, considered an above average first baseman by the front office at the start of the season, made seven errors before he was traded on July 26.
Catcher Victor Martinez's throwing problems were not unexpected and the opposition took full advantage. Martinez threw out 18 percent (22-for-122) of opposing base-stealers this year. He improved after the Yankees stole six bases against him on July 7 - bad mechanics, a broken right toe and a tired right shoulder hurt Martinez - but the Tribe's inability to control the running game definitely destabilized an already shaky infield.
General Manager Mark Shapiro entered the year with veteran closer Bob Wickman, but couldn't get him a lead. Fernando Cabrera and Rafael Betancourt suffered from World Baseball Classic hangovers. Lefty Scott Sauerbeck was ineffective. Danny Graves didn't have much left and Matt Miller went down with a forearm injury in April.
By July, the Indians were so far out of the race they traded Wickman to Atlanta even though he was 15-for-18 in save situations.
Shapiro and manager Eric Wedge have been the golden boys of baseball for the past few years. In rebuilding the Indians, they've done nothing but improve since 2003. This year was a slap in the face. Not only did they drop anchor prematurely, but they reversed all engines as well.
They thought they'd put together a contender, but dismantled a big chunk of it by the end of August. Expectations might have gotten to their team. Playing in baseball's best division - the AL Central was the only division to boast three 90-game winners - didn't help.
Shapiro and Wedge, both entering the final years of their contracts in 2007, won't have to worry about expectations next year. Only reality.
To reach this Plain Dealer reporter: [email protected], 216-999-5158
Upvote
0