OSUBasketballJunkie
Never Forget 31-0
ABJ
8/20/06
ABJ
8/20/06
8/20/06
Ocker on the Indians
Expect bullpen makeover
Tribe's entire corps of relievers could change before start of next season
By Sheldon Ocker
<!-- begin body-content -->ST. PETERSURG, FLA. - For the Indians' sake, let's hope it's a buyer's market for relievers over the winter.
Seldom does a team replace its entire bullpen, but that is the task General Manager Mark Shapiro might be facing once the season ends. It's conceivable that no reliever who began the 2006 schedule will be on the Tribe's roster in 2007.
I don't know the last time a team was forced to replace all seven members of its bullpen, but it's indicative of the Indians' disappointing year, in that bad judgment (as well as bad luck) was an important part of the equation.
At the outset of the season, the Indians' bullpen looked like this: closer Bob Wickman; setup man Guillermo Mota; middle relievers Rafael Betancourt, Matt Miller, Fernando Cabrera and Danny Graves; left-hander Scott Sauerbeck.
Mota, Graves and Sauerbeck failed to keep their jobs because of poor performance.
Graves remains at Triple-A Buffalo and could enter the picture as a spring-training hopeful, but it's doubtful you will see him pitch for the Indians again.
Sauerbeck struggled on the mound and was busted by police, when he and a woman companion were infamously found hiding in the bushes behind a stranger's house long after midnight in a far west-side suburb of Cleveland.
Mota's malfunctions were particularly distressing, because he was anointed setup man the moment he was traded from the Boston Red Sox. It's still not clear why he was awarded such lofty status only two days after Shapiro canceled the deal based on the results of Mota's physical exam.
At any rate, Mota struggled almost from his first pitch and was relegated to far less demanding roles and finally to warming up in the bullpen, which became his only duty. His stock sunk so low, he was impossible to trade, forcing Shapiro to designate him for assignment Aug. 11.
Miller hurt his elbow in April, underwent surgery and might return to the roster for what amounts to a September tryout.
Wickman was traded to the Atlanta Braves in July, as the Indians implicitly surrendered to reality, and Shapiro tried to obtain promising youngsters for players who were not going to be part of the future.
For no apparent reason, Cabrera has struggled with his control the whole season. Last year at this time, he deservedly was touted as a future setup man or closer. You will not hear those words in connection with his name now, yet his stuff remains far above average.
Betancourt has been wildly inconsistent. Just when you think he has conquered the demons, he plunges back into the abyss.
During the five seasons Shapiro has been GM, he has repeatedly said that assembling a bullpen is a tricky enterprise fraught with danger, and that is true. Finding relievers who can retire batters consistently from season to season is no easy job.
Obviously, skill plays a part in picking the right pitchers but so does good fortune. It's clear that Shapiro made some bad choices (Graves, Mota), but he didn't have much luck either (Miller, Sauerbeck, Betancourt, Cabrera). Wickman, as usual, did his job. He was the only member of the original 2006 bullpen who did.
The current corps of relievers is mostly a group of young wannabes, which has no chance of returning intact next year. There is no designated closer or setup man, no left-hander, no pitcher assigned to work the seventh inning.
Betancourt and Cabrera are still around, but their futures are clouded. However, Cabrera is out of options, and his arm is too good to risk a visit to the waiver wire next spring.
Despite his early blowups, Fausto Carmona remains a candidate to close in 2007, but don't bet that it will happen. He might return to being a starter or even take up residence as a setup man.
In his brief time with the club, Brian Sikorski has displayed a live arm and a tendency to give up home runs that keep him from pitching at the back end of the bullpen. However, he has a chance to stick next year.
Andrew Brown and Tom Mastny are only beginning their auditions, so it's impossible to predict their chances for 2007.
Jason Davis will be out of options next season. Shapiro and manager Eric Wedge must find out now if and where he fits into the bullpen (apparently starting is no longer an option), before he turns into the next Brandon Phillips.
My guess is that Betancourt won't be back. Everyone else in the current bullpen will be given a shot. But that begins Shapiro's chores.
Undoubtedly, the GM will begin a worldwide search for a closer. But this time, he will not have Wickman to fall back on, if he is unable to make a trade or sign a free agent.
The pickings for veteran free-agent closers will be slim, unless Shapiro wants to take a chance on a pitcher who has suffered a major injury in the recent past: Eric Gagne, Keith Foulke, Troy Percival and Dustin Hermanson. OK, so none of these guys get your adrenaline flowing.
How about the relievers who probably are far over the hill: Jose Mesa and Eddie Guardado. Hey, I said they were over the hill.
There has been some talk about obtaining Octavio Dotel, who has had success as a setup man but was a bust as a closer. Mike Timlin might be adequate for a year, but he's 40 years old.
Below the closer level, prospects are better. For a change, there are qualified left-handers on the market: Steve Kline, Dennys Reyes and Jamie Walker. J.C. Romero has struggled this year but had success earlier.
Available right-handers with credible resumes include Francisco Cordero, Scott Williamson and possibly Cliff Politte, who was recently released by the Chicago White Sox. But Politte has had a nightmarish season and might be nursing a shoulder injury.
Then there's former Tribesman David Riske, who has pitched relatively well.
Don't like these options? Maybe Shapiro doesn't either, at least as it applies to a closer. He might opt for a trade. If so, a deal probably will be costly in salary paid and talent lost.
Growing one's own closer usually is a good idea. But for the Indians, if it's not Carmona, then who?
<!-- end body-content --><!-- begin body-end --><HR class=tagline color=#cccccc SIZE=1>
ABJ
8/20/06
New reliever saves game
Tom Mastny holds Devil Rays scoreless in eighth and ninth innings
By Sheldon Ocker
Beacon Journal sportswriter
<!-- begin body-content -->ST. PETERSBURG, FLA. - Who does Tom Mastny think he is?
He's lucky to be a household name in his own house. Most diehard Indians fans probably have never heard of him.
Even now that he has thrown 6 1/3 innings in the big leagues, he is not exactly on SportsCenter's radar screen. Then again, after pitching the eighth and ninth innings Saturday night, maybe he is about to receive at least a little attention.
That's because he preserved a win -- 5-3 over the Tampa Bay Devil Rays -- something the relief corps has failed to do repeatedly since the trade of Bob Wickman to the Atlanta Braves a month ago.
Fausto Carmona, Jason Davis, Fernando Cabrera, Rafael Betancourt and Brian Sikorski all have struggled to finish games. So this Mastny fellow comes out of nowhere to do the job.
Is he for real? Obviously, it's far to early to tell.
Indians manager Eric Wedge was asked if he felt better about the situation now that someone, anyone, has earned a save.
``I feel better about it today,'' he said. ``I feel better about the way Tom got it done today. So we'll see what happens tomorrow.''
Mastny retired the side in order in the eighth. In the ninth, he gave up a one-out single to Tomas Perez then struck out the final two batters, giving him three strikeouts in all.
Of course, he will get another chance, though Wedge wasn't sure he would use Mastny today after he threw two innings Saturday night.
Having to sit in the bullpen while chaos raged probably made it more difficult when Mastny got his chance, though he said, ``It's not harder. Maybe that's in the back of your mind, but you don't think about it. You try not to think about it.''
When Mastny walked out of the dugout for the ninth, he was intercepted by his catcher, Victor Martinez.
``Victor did a good job calming me down,'' Mastny said. ``He said, `Stick with me,' and I had confidence in him.''
Did Mastny need to be calmed down?
``My heart was beating a little faster,'' he said. ``But it's still baseball. I've done it for 20 years.
``The ninth inning is a different entity, though. The crowd is louder; you've got a little more adrenaline going. So you just have to try and relax.''
Jeremy Sowers (5-3, 3.48 ERA), who pitched six innings and earned the win, was Mastny's teammate at Kinston, Akron and Buffalo.
``Tom's composure and mound presence are extremely good,'' he said. ``And he throws strikes. Every time he's had a chance, he's been successful, and he puts the ball in the bottom of the zone.''
Considering Sowers' aversion to walks, he probably stayed up all night trying to figure out exactly why he issued four free passes in six innings.
In the first nine starts of his big-league career, Sowers averaged only 1.53 walks per nine innings, an achievement of high order for a veteran, let alone a rookie.
Saturday night, Sowers had good reason to be upset with himself, beyond the abstract notion that walks are bad for pitchers.
In the first inning, the only inning in which Sowers was vulnerable, he walked leadoff batter Rocco Baldelli, then two outs later, walked Johnny Gomes. Both runners scored when Dioner Navarro doubled.
Two walks, two runs. If Sowers had been in kindergarten, the teacher might have made him stand in the corner. But Sowers is a grownup and understands about living with the consequences of his own actions.
``That was a very good lesson I learned by walking two guys in the first inning, with both of them scoring,'' Sowers said. ``The way I pitch, especially -- I'm not going to strike guys out -- the more base runners, the more trouble I'm going to be in.''
Walks made life a little more difficult for Sowers, but they were downright lethal to Devil Rays starter Tim Corcoran (4-5, 4.13 ERA), who was forced to abandon the mound after only four innings, because he had thrown 85 pitches.
Surely, Corcoran could have thrown more. But he walked five batters, and even though the Tribe did not capitalize on any of the walks, Rays manager Joe Maddon didn't want to press his luck.
The Indians scored in only one inning against Corcoran, the fourth, when Jhonny Peralta drove in two runs with a two-out double, and Joe Inglett followed with an RBI single.
Travis Hafner homered for the fourth run in the seventh, and Andy Marte doubled home the final Tribe run in the eighth.
<!-- end body-content --><!-- begin body-end -->
Upvote
0