OSUBasketballJunkie
Never Forget 31-0
ABJ
3/12/06
3/12/06
Indians spring training report
Berth still up for grabs
Four pitchers remain in running for final job in Tribe bullpen
By Sheldon Ocker
Beacon Journal sportswriter
<!-- begin body-content -->ST. PETERSBURG, FLA. - Just past the halfway point in spring training, no clear-cut favorite has emerged in the competition to secure the final berth in the Indians' bullpen.
Might as well list the candidates in alphabetical order: Andrew Brown, Jason Davis, Danny Graves and Steve Karsay.
``As far as making evaluations, we need to get to the middle of March,'' General Manager Mark Shapiro said late last week. ``After the split-squad day (Tuesday), there will be a significant cut. Right now, we have to temper our evaluations.''
None of the four pitchers vying for attention in the bullpen is likely to be sliced from the roster or sent to the minors Tuesday. By then, Shapiro and manager Eric Wedge might be ready to make preliminary (though probably unannounced) decisions on the vacant relief spot.
The man who wins the job won't be judged on his results in spring training but rather his stuff, his command of the strike zone, his demeanor on the mound and his confidence.
Nevertheless, performance in exhibition games means something. So far, Davis has pitched four times, giving up four earned runs (six total), eight hits and two walks in eight innings. He has also struck out five.
In four appearances, Graves has allowed two earned runs (three in all), five hits and two walks with two strikeouts in four innings.
Karsay has given up three earned runs, three hits and one walk with two strikeouts in four innings.
Brown also has pitched in four games, yielding two earned runs, four hits and two walks, striking out five, in four innings.
If Davis doesn't make the team, Wedge and Shapiro will determine whether to use him as a starter or reliever at Triple-A, another decision that has yet to be made.
Karsay is coming off a three-year ordeal after undergoing surgery on his shoulder. Graves was released by the Cincinnati Reds in mid-year, when his velocity dropped to the low 80s, and his effectiveness disappeared.
The Indians never have been able to decide whether Davis should start or relieve, which probably has contributed to his erratic development.
Brown, who came to the Tribe in the deal that sent Milton Bradley to the Los Angeles Dodgers last year, was converted from starter to reliever as soon as he got to Buffalo.
``Andrew has taken to the bullpen, but he's still pretty new at doing this,'' Wedge said Saturday.
Brown has been one of the more impressive players in camp. In his third outing, he was throwing 94-96 mph fastballs, dominating batters when he hit his spots, but that's the area of concern for Wedge and Shapiro.
``He needs to be more consistent and throw the ball downhill,'' Wedge said. ``He has the ability to work the ball down, but he needs to do that right away when he comes into a game.''
Whether Brown makes the team might depend on his ability to throw quality strikes rather than simply throw the ball over the plate.
``He's shown that he wants to aggressively compete for the job,'' Shapiro said. ``But ask me in three weeks if he's still doing that and if someone else has backed off.''
In Brown doesn't force his way onto the roster now, it's only a matter of time before he gets an opportunity.
``He's going to contribute to this team either from Day 1 or at some point this season,'' Shapiro said.
Consistency hasn't been Graves' problem this spring. Moreover, he has regained his normal velocity, throwing 86-89 mph and sometimes touching 90.
What went wrong for him last year?
``I think Danny was used quite a bit,'' Wedge said. ``He might have gotten worn down. Now, he looks strong, and his stuff is playing like that.''
Conventional wisdom concerning Graves holds that his decline began when the Reds decided to make him a starter after he saved 32 games in 2002.
The experiment lasted only one season, and Graves came back to save 41 games in 2004. Last year was a disaster, though, possibly because too many innings over the previous two seasons had been too much for his arm.
Karsay isn't throwing with the same velocity that he did when he was with the Tribe from 1998-2001, but his fastball has hummed toward the plate at 90 mph most of the spring.
Moreover, his velocity could increase by a couple of miles an hour once the season gets under way.
Davis' performance during spring games has been inconsistent, but he has the kind of live arm that can give him an edge if he settles in. He retired all six batters he faced Saturday, one on strikes.
``That definitely was Davis' best outing,'' Wedge said.
One reason, Davis did not try to throw too hard.
``His stuff is more electric when he doesn't give as much effort and overthow,'' Wedge said.
Three is enough
The Indians got all their hits in the sixth inning to take a 5-4 win over the Tampa Bay Devil Rays on Saturday at Al Lang Field.
Through five innings, Devil Rays pitchers were throwing a no-hitter, but in the fifth, the Tribe got three hits and benefited from three walks and an error to score all their runs and wipe out a 3-0 deficit.
The biggest hits for the Indians were Jhonny Peralta's two-run double and a two-run single by Franklin Gutierrez.
Flashy first baseman
Ryan Garko, playing first base, dug two throws out of the dirt and made a diving stop of a line drive.
``He made a hell of a play on that dive,'' Wedge said. ``The ball had left-handed topspin and was speeding up as it got to him.''
Garko is a converted catcher just learning how to play first.
What if?
If a player comes to Wedge and said that he's uncomfortable batting in a particular spot in the order, what does the manager do?
``I've had that happen multiple times,'' Wedge said. ``I had conversations with Omar Vizquel when I wanted him to lead off. After a while, I just knew it wasn't going to work.
``If a player is uncomfortable in a certain place in the order, you shouldn't do it unless your (offense) is going to be notably better. If there is a gray area, don't do it.''
Quick recovery
Brandon Phillips fouled a ball hard off his shin on Friday but was in the lineup against Tampa Bay. ``He went home and iced it four or five times,'' Wedge said. ``It's still sore, but he's back in there.''
Familiar face
Former Tribe slugger Russell Branyan is in the Devil Rays' camp. He is believed to have a chance to make the club, but it's far from a sure thing.
Branyan is batting .333 (4-for-12) with two doubles.
Marching onward
The Indians return to Chain O' Lakes Park today to face the Yankees at 1 p.m. It will be televised on some cable channels on a delayed basis (4:30 p.m.).
C.C. Sabathia will start against Shawn Chacon. Guillermo Mota, Steve Karsay and Danny Graves will work out of the Indians bullpen.
Upvote
0