• New here? Register here now for access to all the forums, download game torrents, private messages, polls, Sportsbook, etc. Plus, stay connected and follow BP on Instagram @buckeyeplanet and Facebook.

Hurricane Victim Arrested for Panhandling

Wingate1217

Bring on the next opponent!!
Site Supporter
  • If this is true and the man was from the affected region this could have been handled better with several different options and outcomes available to the officer in question. The decision making of some people........


    <TABLE width="100%" border=0><TBODY><TR><TD>Evacuee Arrested for Panhandling in Ga.
    Sep 07 11:24 PM US/Eastern
    </TD><TD align=right>
    ap.gif
    </TD></TR></TBODY></TABLE>
    ATLANTA

    A man who fled Louisiana with his family to escape Hurricane Katrina was arrested for asking motorists for money in this city where banning panhandling has been a hotly debated issue.
    James Scott says he had slept in a car for days with his brother, sister and her two young children before they decided to ask for help.
    Nearly broke, the family drove to Buckhead, an affluent north Atlanta neighborhood Thursday and got out near a shopping mall, hoping for the charity of others.
    "It's the most expensive mall in Atlanta," Scott said. "I thought I could get some help."
    After a half hour of asking passing motorists for help, Scott was approached by a policeman on a bicycle. Scott showed the officer his Louisiana driver's license, his car tag and his car registration _ proof that he was not a local homeless person, but an evacuee down on his luck in an unfamiliar city. He was arrested for soliciting.
    "I asked the cop, 'You can't feel my pain?'" said Scott, who added that another officer gave him $7 as he was taken to jail.
    Atlanta Police Department spokesman John Quigley said soliciting on a public sidewalk is allowed, but not in traffic. He said he was not aware of any increase in panhandling arrests in Atlanta since the hurricane. Last month, Mayor Shirley Franklin signed into law a panhandling ban around tourist destinations in parts of downtown Atlanta, not the area where Scott was arrested. The ordinance drew noisy protests from opponents who declared the ban was a mean-spirited way to hide the city's homeless population.
     
    Tough situation...I understand where both sides are coming from...but the law is the law...as bad as I feel for the man and his family I'm not sure you can just make an exception for him while it is illegal for others.
     
    Upvote 0
    Golferdow01 said:
    Tough situation...I understand where both sides are coming from...but the law is the law...as bad as I feel for the man and his family I'm not sure you can just make an exception for him while it is illegal for others.
    Ummm..Yea the douche of a cop should of.
     
    Upvote 0
    Until you read that, were you aware that it was illegal to panhandle on the streets, but is ok on the sidewalks? I sure wasn't.

    If the cop was a reasonable person, he would've informed the guy how the law reads, advised him to stay on the sidewalks, wished him well and gave him $20.
     
    Upvote 0
    This guy and his family are gong through one of the toughest times in their life right now. A week ago they had a home food on the table and jobs(I assume) Now they are stuck on the streets trying to make it and some bicycle cop instead of offering to help them arrests his ass for asking other people for help. Yea exactly what I call protecting and serving.
     
    Upvote 0
    Golferdow01 said:
    Ok so the cop should have given him a warning and let him on his way and dropped him $10...but he did break the law and you shouldn't make exceptions so I can't argue with his decision

    Some laws give the officer a certain amount of discretion in enforcement action. Take speeding for example, some of us on this board have probably been stopped for exceeding the speed limit but have been given "just a warning", rather than an actual ticket. In order to make the determination (whether to give a ticket or not), the prior driving history of the person stopped is sometimes examined as well as the reasonableness and courtesy shown to the officer by the person who was stopped. Other items such as were there circumstances whereas the person maybe "felt justified" in speeding such as "travelling to the hospital because my wife is going to give birth," and other aspects are considered as well. As long as another person is harmed and they do not want to press charges and the offense is not a felony one could argue that an exception could have been made.

    However, I do not know how the person charged in this case acted and whether he had "priors." There are always two sides to every story and unfortunately we may never know the officers.
     
    Upvote 0
    Wingate1217 said:
    Some laws give the officer a certain amount of discretion in enforcement action. Take speeding for example, some of us on this board have probably been stopped for exceeding the speed limit but have been given "just a warning", rather than an actual ticket. In order to make the determination (whether to give a ticket or not), the prior driving history of the person stopped is sometimes examined as well as the reasonableness and courtesy shown to the officer by the person who was stopped. Other items such as were there circumstances whereas the person maybe "felt justified" in speeding such as "travelling to the hospital because my wife is going to give birth," and other aspects are considered as well. As long as another person is harmed and they do not want to press charges and the offense is not a felony one could argue that an exception could have been made.

    However, I do not know how the person charged in this case acted and whether he had "priors." There are always two sides to every story and unfortunately we may never know the officers.
    Thank you for a very cool-headed response and I totally agree with you. We don't know if the guy was being a jerk or what his behavior was. As I stated earlier, the guy was breaking the law. As sad as his situation was I can't sit here and say the cop did the wrong thing...at least with the information provided.

    AkronBuckeye said:
    WOW Golfer.....

    I guess you dont live in America....Its the country where we make new laws....
    instead of enforcing the ones we have...

    Have a Little compassion....
    DICKHEAD
    Last time I checked I do live in America. I'm glad to see you have the mentality of "Laws were meant to be broken". That's very commendable and there are plenty of others with that mentality, and I don't care for them. Laws are made for the safety and protection of the GENERAL PUBLIC, and unfortunately they sometimes slight an individual. As I stated above we do not have the whole story so before you go around flaming and acting like a ten-year-old, try and see both sides of the story. I do want to thank you for signing that ding though cause a lot of people here leave it blank...I hope you appreciate my returning the favor with a sig.
     
    Last edited:
    Upvote 0
    Golferdow01 said:
    I do want to thank you for singing that ding though cause a lot of people here leave it blank...I hope you appreciate my returning the favor with a sig.

    I couldn't agree with you more! It drives me nuts when an individual doesn't have the "balls" to sign their name after they ding you. Chicken Shits!
     
    Upvote 0
    Back
    Top