BuckeyeMac, I'm going to give you a little electricity lesson. First of all, your neutral is seldom hooked to the switch. It is either wire nutted to all the other neutrals in the switch box or is connected at the light. You should have one hot and one "switchleg" on each switch. The switchleg carries the hot to the light when you flip the switch on, and breaks the circuit when you flip the switch off. Also, on older houses, the neutral was used as the ground (as the neutral is your grounded conductor, and the hot is ungrounded). So, if you hook up a neutral on one side of the switch and a hot on the other side of a switch, when you turn the switch on, you will immediately have a dead short. Not good. I would suggest going to Home Depot and getting a no touch voltage detector, around 15 bucks. Turn your breaker on and find out which wire(s) are hot, and hook your hot up to one side of your switch. From there, it should be easy to trace out which of the other wires are your switchleg. Also, count how many screws there are on the switch, not counting the ground screw. If there are only 2 screws, then you have a single pole switch, which works in only one location. If you have 3 screws, then you have a 3 way switch, which is connected to another 3 way switch somewhere in the room. Hopefully, you only have 2 screws, and it will be easy to trace out your switchlegs. If not, and you have a three way switch, get back to me and I'll try to walk you through how they work. Good luck, and BE CAREFUL. Make sure to turn your breaker off and keep it off until you need it on to find your hot wire. Once your hot wire is found, turn the breaker back off! Hope I haven't confused you. It really is pretty simple.