-
New here? Register here now for access to all the forums, download game torrents, private messages, polls, Sportsbook, etc. Plus, stay connected and follow BP on Instagram @buckeyeplanet and Facebook.
- Thread starter LordJeffBuck
- Start date
Pheasant
This space for rent.
DaddyBigBucks;2016728; said:
I thought it was obvious which of my 3 points didn't belong in a logical argument...it was a play on the inability (to this day) of any football announcer to ignore "what a great football name AJ Hawk is" during a broadcast. While not
funny, I think it would still qualify as a joke. I guess without a spreadsheet it might be confusing to some. Also, I have an applause sign for you. Ignore the part that says "Eat a bag of Dicks, DBB"...that was from an earlier sign that I painted over for the new one.
Upvote
0
Bill Lucas
Assistant Coach
I echo that Pepper Johnson should be on the list. I know he wouldn't garner many votes as Gradishar was clearly the best but he should be named on that list.
Upvote
0
Bill Lucas
Assistant Coach
Fact:
Marcus Marek set a screen on me playing a pick up game at South Rec that was so solid that I think I still feel it to this day. :)
Marcus Marek set a screen on me playing a pick up game at South Rec that was so solid that I think I still feel it to this day. :)
Upvote
0
NightmaresDad
Woody Rules!
This isn't all that hard for me.
Cousineau and Katzenmoyer and maybe Hawk were probably as physically gifted, and Spielman may have been a little smarter, but Gradishar was hands down the best.
His stats don't overwhelm you because they had so many 3 and outs, and then the offense would hold the ball forever. He probably didn't play much more than a third as many plays as Marek of Spielman, so he's not going to have a million tackles.
Cousineau and Katzenmoyer and maybe Hawk were probably as physically gifted, and Spielman may have been a little smarter, but Gradishar was hands down the best.
His stats don't overwhelm you because they had so many 3 and outs, and then the offense would hold the ball forever. He probably didn't play much more than a third as many plays as Marek of Spielman, so he's not going to have a million tackles.
Upvote
0
FritoBandito
Lover of salty snacks
LordJeffBuck;2015835; said:
Add another impressive 'award' for Spiels: Front of Wheaties Box - as a High School Senior!
Upvote
0
Pheasant
This space for rent.
DaddyBigBucks;2017602; said:
Hawk has more hardware and a title...you may well be right that Gradishar was a greater linebacker, but it's certainly debatable. If it's such a laugher why don't you rail LJB for making a poll out of such a ridiculous question? How dare he put Katzenmoyer, Laurinaitis and Hawk in the same realm as Randy Gradishar? GTFOOH.
:osu:
Last edited:
Upvote
0
calibuck
Too soon old, too late smart
Listen to us......arguing about who's the best, and using the argument that 'behind a great DL'....etc....Face it, OSU is the REAL LB U.....and having all of these choices is an embarassment of riches.
Have seen many of these guys in person. Dwight (Ike) Kelley was smallish for an LB, but you know the story, 'amount of fight in the dog'. He was a 60ish LB on some darn good OSU teams. And when you say, 'OSU' linebacker, that doesn't mean pro statistics included, or how many times on a Sunday they mention the name, and 'from OSU'.....
For my money, it's a tie between: Marek, Gradishar, Erik Kumerow (remember it's only in an OSU uni), AJ and Little Animal. The rest of those mentioned are ALL IA on the list....
:gobucks3::gobucks4:
Three cheers for the Real Linebacker U.
Have seen many of these guys in person. Dwight (Ike) Kelley was smallish for an LB, but you know the story, 'amount of fight in the dog'. He was a 60ish LB on some darn good OSU teams. And when you say, 'OSU' linebacker, that doesn't mean pro statistics included, or how many times on a Sunday they mention the name, and 'from OSU'.....
For my money, it's a tie between: Marek, Gradishar, Erik Kumerow (remember it's only in an OSU uni), AJ and Little Animal. The rest of those mentioned are ALL IA on the list....
:gobucks3::gobucks4:
Three cheers for the Real Linebacker U.
Upvote
0
ScriptOhio
Everybody is somebody else's weirdo.
If you could choose one former Buckeye LB to add to this year’s unit, who are you taking?
One of these three: Spielman - Gradishar - Cousineau
Upvote
0
AirForceBuck15
All-American
Shazier. He fits today’s LB mold needed for high octane offenses and was a missile.
Upvote
0
If it's specifically for this years team then the only clear need is a more athletic Mike.
I love Spiels but of those 3, give me Gradishar.
Gradishar, Browning and Werner is about as athletic a LB core as you could ever hope for.
Upvote
0
buckeyeintn
Legend
I had the privilege of watching Gradishar live for a couple years. He made plays then. He would make plays in today's system. He made everyone around him better then. He would make everyone around him better now.
Upvote
0