zincfinger;919690; said:Yes, but nobody here is arguing that students or fans of other Ohio schools must be fans of OSU. The argument here is simply that there's nothing wrong with students and fans of other Ohio schools also being fans of OSU. That's in contrast to what some on the Zipsnation board would argue.
As far as there being multiple D-1A football schools in Ohio, that is certainly true, but the fact still remains that if you want to follow a D1-A football school from Ohio that is competitive at a national level, there's only one option to choose from. I personally don't think it's an insult to the other Ohio schools, nor a mark of arrogance, to acknowledge the fact that their football programs, and OSU's, are not on the same level. That doesn't mean that they're not good, and it doesn't mean that they could never have any hope of the possibility of winning a game against OSU, but there clearly is a difference in the caliber of the programs.
This is a poor analogy. Your analogy would apply to all Akron fans becoming Toledo fans, if Toledo won the MAC several years in a row. That sort of fair-weather fanship is very different from Akron fans being also OSU fans. Because there is a difference between OSU football and Akron football: OSU competes at a national level, whereas Akron competes only at a regional level. This is a difference that doesn't exist between OSU football and USC football, any more than it exists between Akron football and Toledo football. If you want to construct a hypothetical situation in which your USC-as-national-team analogy would apply, it would be that universities from every country across the globe play American football, and Ohio State isn't really capable of competing with the best international teams, but USC is. In such a scenario, a lot of OSU fans would be USC fans when it came to international competition, because USC would be the team that most effectively represented the nation.
Thank You. Very well said.
I personally have zero malice toward the other Ohio schools and root for them whenever I see them playing a non-Ohio school. I used to get so pissed off watching the old California Bowl between the MAC and ??(some west coast conference equivilant) it wasn't even funny.
As far as the minor league comment goes, I stand by it. They aren't in our class and its no big deal, again to use baseball....I am as die hard a Reds fan as they come but I know damn good and well they aren't in the same class as the good MLB teams. When they playoffs start I always have to adopt a team for the post season. I don't buy hats or anything like that but I care how they do(somewhat). Its not being disloyal or bandwagon, its just two completely different leagues to me.
Upvote
0