Game Thread Game Eleven: Ohio state 25, Michigan 21 (final)

[BuckeyeKid789]

Here's a clip of Carr arguing that Gonzalez wasn't pushed out of bounds.

On OSU's WR going out of bounds:
After seeing the film, he thinks Gonzalez' catch should have come back. • Click here to listen (1:30)

 

[osugrad21]

I don't see where he was classless...that is exactly what happened. Would you be as upset if the roles were reversed? Boone vs. Woodley?

 

[Buckeye513]

I don't really know what you expect from them. One's a scUM fan and the other is a scUM coach.

 

[BuckeyeKid789]

I don;t see where he was classless...that is exactly what happened. Would you be as upset if the roles were reversed? Boone vs. Woodley?

Glorifying an injury is classless and I don't know what happend between Boone and Woodley but if it was the same thing I wouldn't like it.

 

[osugrad21]

Glorifying an injury is classless and I don't know what happend between Boone and Woodley but if it was the same thing I wouldn't like it.

Where did he glorify it?

 

[BuckeyeKid789]

Where did he glorify it?

Crushing Carpenter into the turf, ending his game before it even began. Carpenter was seriously injured and all the writer mentions is what a great play it was by Long. Maybe I'm overreacting. The way he put it annoyed me and I thought it was a tasteless comment on the play.

 

[osugrad21]

Well, to each his own, but I personally don't see anything wrong with it. Bobby got pancaked and an injury occurred. That is football. I really don't think the guy is celebrating the injury...but that is just my opinion.

 

[BuckeyeKid789]

I think it's the way he phrased it that ticked me off. It wasn't all that bad.

 

[808 Buck]

Hey, here's a crazy idea. Enjoy the win. No overanalysis, no second guessing anything, maybe even ignore the fans and media from up north for a little while. Just kick back and really enjoy one of the greatest wins in the history of the rivalry.

 

[BuckeyeKid789]

Hey, here's a crazy idea. Enjoy the win. No overanalysis, no second guessing anything, maybe even ignore the fans and media from up north for a little while. Just kick back and really enjoy one of the greatest wins in the history of the rivalry.

Gotcha'.

 

[Bucklion]

Here's a clip of Carr arguing that Gonzalez wasn't pushed out of bounds.

On OSU's WR going out of bounds:
After seeing the film, he thinks Gonzalez' catch should have come back. • Click here to listen (1:30)

He's just pissed that the refs can't be entirely in his pocket anymore...only on penalties and quick whistles and deciding which plays to review.

 

[lvbuckeye]

Lastly, what to make of Lloyd Carr's comments (audio) on Gonzo's catch?

This is from BuckeyeCommentary.com

thanks for the link... i listened to pretty much all of it... check out Holmes' comments about Troy... then listen to him talk about The Catch... he described it as "magnificent." Tone is very well spoken...

 

[buckeyeboy]

Bittorrent thread

YOu can find it there.

Thanks. However, I don't have an internet connection at home. So can someone help me out with a DVD copy of the Game?

 

[LightningRod]

CRYBABY CARR!!! The "NEW" excuse for Michigan Man. Is this the most obnoxious coach in all of college sports? I thought it was going to be the dogs. I guess we will hear about this during Michigan week 2006.

COLLEGE FOOTBALL
Carr say Gonzalez’s catch shouldn’t have counted
Tuesday, November 22, 2005
Ken Gordon
THE COLUMBUS DISPATCH
NEAL C . LAURON | DISPATCH
Michigan coach Lloyd Carr has found something to complain about after two straight losses to Ohio State.

This year’s Lloyd Carr moment comes with a disclaimer:

While disputing the catch Ohio State receiver Anthony Gonzalez made to set up the winning touchdown in OSU’s 25-21 victory Saturday, the Michigan coach is not — repeat, not — saying his team would have won if the call went his way.

Carr is, however, upset that Gonzalez went out of bounds and came back in to make the 26-yard grab. He doesn’t buy the explanation that Gonzalez was forced out of bounds by Wolverines defensive back Grant Mason.

"The rule says the receiver must be blocked out of bounds," in order for the catch to be allowed, Carr said yesterday. "Grant Mason was playing man-to-man and turned back to the ball. He did not block (Gonzalez) out, that’s clear."

Last season, Carr was mad about being stopped and subjected to a security screening with bomb-sniffing dogs outside Ohio Stadium. In his Monday press conference after a 37-21 loss, he made an issue of it.

His gripe yesterday didn’t rise to that level, but it did consume several minutes.

"I thought we got a terrible break there when the receiver ran out of bounds, because I thought that ball should come back," Carr said.

Gonzalez’s catch took the ball from the Michigan 30 to the 4. After the play, he said he ran to the official and told him he was pushed out of bounds, and the official assured him, "You’re OK. You’re OK. Don’t worry about it."

Two plays later, Antonio Pittman ran in for a touchdown and the win.

If the Gonzalez call had gone Carr’s way, "That’s not to say they’re not going to kick a field goal or hit their next pass," he said. "I’m just saying that was a big play. That’s all I’m saying."

Until next year?

[email protected]

 

[buckeyeboy]

What a whiner. . Lllloyd's one of those people who will never admit that he lost, will never admit that his opponent deserved to win, and will never admit that he's got "Property of Jim Tressel and The Ohio State University" stamped on his forehead.