A Pac
All-American
What drives me crazy with the Phili trade is how we bargained. We got Carrasco, who to be fair, never had injury problems beofre and was the least prominant guy, Donald who was supposed to be a great utility infielder, Lou Marson (catcher of the future!) who is great defensively but can't hit a fastball from my sister, and (don't underestimate how pissed off this makes me to this day) Knapp, a freaking guy coming off of Tommy-John surgery and will never be healthy. The most coveted guy in that trade was coming off of a possible career ending injury!!! What the hell Mark? We had the reigning Cy Young winner and didn't even get any one of the Phillies top four prospects. I would have taken Lee off of the table at that point. Phili didn't want to offer any of their top four prospects but still wanted Lee... AND WE GAVE THEM TO HIM! This is why I cannot stand Mark Shapiro and why he needs to go. I understand that he is handcuffed by Dolan's cheap ass, but it was up to him to get the best value possible. He didn't get anywhere near that. Shame on you Mark.NFBuck;2140218; said:Yeah, I mean, we got our #1 starter in that one...and Boston got Victor for 1.5 years and lost him in FA. If anything, we won that trade...
As for the other two, the trade market just wasn't there. I think they did the best they could. Sure the guys haven't panned out, and maybe some of that can be blamed on poor development, but I don't recall any better offers at the time. It sucks that those two trades netted very little, but I can't blame the FO for that. Hell, LaBusta was a top-10 prospect in all of baseball, IIRC. Getting Santana for Blake takes some of the sting away from the C.C. trade...for me, at least. Sure, they could have held on to Lee for another year, but it's not like they had the horses to make a run with him on the roster, anyway. Trading vets at the deadline is a buyers market now. Teams typically just aren't willing to part with their top prospects for rentals anymore.
Upvote
0