Update for games played through 5/12
Holy shit. What just happened? 8 wins on the season coming into this past week and they win 5??
Let's look under the hood and see if we can figure out exactly what in the fuck is going on here.
I am officially renaming this section "hitting" instead of just "coming to plate with bats in hand". I spend a fair amount of time eviscerating these slappy bastards when they fail, might as well acknowledge when they have some modicum of success (even though we all know it won't last).
Run Creation-Hitting:
Once again, good at avoiding outs but limited power so how do they continue to improve in scoring runs? They aren't stealing a lot of bases (20th in MLB), it doesn't appear to be unsustainable luck (BABIP .293) and most of their hits are singles so WTF? Here are the things I found they are really good at
- OBP .322, T14th best in MLB
- K% 20.8%, 8th best in MLB
- ISO, .132, 2nd worst MLB
- SLG .376, 4th worst MLB
- HR's 35, 4th fewest in MLB
- Runs scored 163, 16th in MLB
LD% 25.1, 1st in MLB
Bunt hits 11, 1st in MLB (6 of which are from Peraza)
Swinging Strike% 8.9%, 1st in MLB
Contact %, 80.4%, 1st in MLB
They are making a ton of contact and spraying line drive singles all over the place. Jose Peraza is an elite bunter. That is all I can tell you right now.
Continuing the eye test theme, Winker is a ball player and Peraza is growing on me. Hamilton continues to suck the life out of me with his inability to get on base/learn how to bunt.
Pro Tip; watch Peraza you dumb fuck.
wRC+ by position (100 is average)
Run Prevention 1-Pitching:
- 3B Suarez 144
- 2B Gennett 142
- 1B Votto 134
- C Barnhardt 121
- OF Schebler 108
- RF Winker 100
- SS Peraza 80
- CF Hamilton 72
As god awful as those numbers are, they have improved in every category. Tip of the cap to trimming the team ERA under 5.
- k/9 7.87, 7th worst in MLB
- BB/9 3.69, 8th worst in MLB
- WHIP 1.40, 9th worst in MLB
- HR/9 1.49, worst in MLB
- ERA 4.78, 6th worst in MLB
- Runs Allowed 201, 6th worst in MLB
Run prevention 2-Defense:
I am just going to pick FanGraph's total defensive rating as a point of reference. You can go look at any others you choose, I am guessing they will all say about the same thing.
-7.1, 3rd worst in MLB
You see it every night, other than Hamilton in CF and Barnhart at C they are butchers at every other position (some mix of lack of range, weak arm, band hands or inability to judge fly balls).
Team record
My call last week was 10-29, they are now 13-27.
- 13 wins-27 losses, T-2nd worst in MLB
- -38 Run Diff, 7th worst in MLB
- FanGraphs is predicting 95 losses which would be 3rd worst in MLB behind Miami and CWS for overall #1 pick.
- Orioles may well have the inside track here considering they are likely going to trade Machado at some point. Already in 1st place for losses and run diff at -77. Going to be hard to outsuck them.
The week ahead:
Today @ Dodgers
Mon-Wed @ SF Giants
Thur off
Fri& Sat 3 home games with Cubs (Saturday double header)
I say they win 3 so call it 16-31 when next we meet.
Update for games played through 5/19
They come in at exactly 16-31 so they are predictable as death and taxes yet again. Depressing details to follow.
Run Creation-Hitting:
- OBP .319, T16th best in MLB
- K% 21.3%, 10th best in MLB
- ISO, .136, 3rd worst MLB
- SLG .377, 3rd worst MLB
- HR's 44, T7th fewest in MLB
- Runs scored 190, 20th in MLB
LD% 24.6, 1st in MLB
Bunt hits 12, 1st in MLB (6 of which are from Peraza)
Swinging Strike% 9.1%, 1st in MLB
Contact %, 80.1%, 2nd in MLB
wRC+ by position (100 is average)
- 3B Suarez 149
- 2B Gennett 137
- 1B Votto 131
- C Barnhardt 114
- OF Schebler 107
- OF Duvall 94, Winker 85
- CF Hamilton 70
- SS Peraza 63
Run Prevention 1-Pitching:
- k/9 7.98, 8th worst in MLB
- BB/9 3.8, 6th worst in MLB
- WHIP 1.45, 4th worst in MLB
- HR/9 1.42, 3rd worst in MLB
- ERA 4.94, 5th worst in MLB
- Runs Allowed 244, 4th worst in MLB
Here is your starting staff so far, posted with no further commentary:

Run prevention 2-Defense:
Continuing to use FanGraph's total defensive rating as a point of reference:
-5.6, T8th worst in MLB
To quote a famous manager; this is a simple game. You throw the ball, you hit the ball, you catch the ball. These guys are varying levels of MLB worst at all 3.
Team record
- 16 wins-31 losses, t-worst in MLB
- -54 Run Diff, 6th worst in MLB
- FanGraphs is predicting 96 losses which would be tied for 3rd worst in MLB behind Miami and CWS for overall #1 pick.
The week ahead
Today: Cubs
Mon: off
Tue,Wed,Thur: Pirates
Fri& Sat: @ Colorado Rockies
Feels like a 1 win week coming up. Call it 17-36 when next we meet.
Upvote
0