Bill Livingston: What happened to the LeBron James vs. Carmelo Anthony rivalry?
by Bill Livingston/Plain Dealer Columnist Wednesday November 12, 2008, 7:00 PM
Whatever happened to the NBA's Magic vs. Bird rivalry of this century?
Only five years ago, the Cavaliers' LeBron James and Denver's Carmelo Anthony were supposed to save the NBA, the way Larry Bird and Magic Johnson did until Michael Jordan came along.
Now the Cavs' big statement games are against the Celtics and Pistons. The individual matchups at the top of the marquee are James vs. the Lakers' Kobe Bryant or Miami's Dwayne Wade.
Mark Duncan/Associated PressThe LeBron James vs. Carmelo Anthony rivalry has not lived up to its Magic/Bird expectations. James has made it to the NBA Finals, but Anthony has a 4-20 record in the playoffs with the Nuggets.
The first five players taken in the great 2003 NBA Draft were, in order, James, Darko Milicic, Anthony, Chris Bosh and Wade. James has been to an NBA Finals, with a team nowhere near as good as this one. Milicic became the new Sam Bowie, the mega-bust taken instead of Michael Jordan by Portland. Wade won an NBA Championship, or at least accepted one when Dallas declined it. Bosh, behind only James and Wade, was a key player on the "Redeem Team," the 2008 Olympic gold medalists.
Anthony's Nuggets are 4-20 in the playoffs with five first-round exits. He might not have reached McGradyean depths, a term coined for Tracy McGrady, who, in Toronto, Orlando and now Houston, has never won a playoff series. But that is only because some of McGrady's futility occurred in the then-weaker East.
"Carmelo hasn't been playing the worst teams in the first round," James said. "He's had San Antonio, the Lakers."
And Minnesota and, ahem, the Los Angeles Clippers.
Cont...