Based on the votes for the BP Awards, I put together an All-American team comprised of the top vote recipients for each position. Of course, since we are the ultimate homer site, we have to have as many Buckeyes as possible on the team, so on offense, we'll run a four wide-out spread; and on defense, a 4-4 with AJ Hawk as the "rover" back. Here's how the team looks:
QB: Vince Young (Texas)
RB: Reggie Bush (Southern Cal)
WR: Jeff Samardzija (Notre Dame)
WR: Mike Hass (Oregon State)
WR: Dwayne Jarrett (Southern Cal)
WR: Santonio Holmes (Ohio State)
OL: Greg Eslinger (Minnesota)
OL: D'Brickashaw Ferguson (Virginia)
OL: Marcus McNeill (Auburn)
OL: Nick Mangold (Ohio State)
OL: Joe Thomas (Wisconsin)
PK: Alexis Serna (Oregon State)
DL: Elvis Dumervil (Louisville)
DL: Mathias Kiwanuka (Boston College)
DL: Haloti Ngata (Oregon)
DL: Rod Wright (Texas)
LB: A.J. Hawk (Ohio State)
LB: Paul Posluszny (Penn State)
LB: DeMeco Ryans (Alabama)
LB: Bobby Carpenter (Ohio State)
DB: Jimmy Williams (VPI)
DB: Michael Huff (Texas)
DB: Alan Zemaitis (Penn State)
P: Ryan Plackemeier (Wake Forest)
HC: Joe Paterno (Penn State)
AC: Mack Brown (Texas)
AC: Charlie Weis (Notre Dame)
AC: Pete Carroll (Southern Cal)
AC: George O'Leary (Central Florida)
AC: Jim Tressel (Ohio State)
AC: Steve Spurrier (South Carolina)
QB: Vince Young (Texas)
RB: Reggie Bush (Southern Cal)
WR: Jeff Samardzija (Notre Dame)
WR: Mike Hass (Oregon State)
WR: Dwayne Jarrett (Southern Cal)
WR: Santonio Holmes (Ohio State)
OL: Greg Eslinger (Minnesota)
OL: D'Brickashaw Ferguson (Virginia)
OL: Marcus McNeill (Auburn)
OL: Nick Mangold (Ohio State)
OL: Joe Thomas (Wisconsin)
PK: Alexis Serna (Oregon State)
DL: Elvis Dumervil (Louisville)
DL: Mathias Kiwanuka (Boston College)
DL: Haloti Ngata (Oregon)
DL: Rod Wright (Texas)
LB: A.J. Hawk (Ohio State)
LB: Paul Posluszny (Penn State)
LB: DeMeco Ryans (Alabama)
LB: Bobby Carpenter (Ohio State)
DB: Jimmy Williams (VPI)
DB: Michael Huff (Texas)
DB: Alan Zemaitis (Penn State)
P: Ryan Plackemeier (Wake Forest)
HC: Joe Paterno (Penn State)
AC: Mack Brown (Texas)
AC: Charlie Weis (Notre Dame)
AC: Pete Carroll (Southern Cal)
AC: George O'Leary (Central Florida)
AC: Jim Tressel (Ohio State)
AC: Steve Spurrier (South Carolina)

