• New here? Register here now for access to all the forums, download game torrents, private messages, polls, Sportsbook, etc. Plus, stay connected and follow BP on Instagram @buckeyeplanet and Facebook.

Biggest Games in the History of the 'Shoe

BB73

Loves Buckeye History
Staff member
Bookie
'16 & '17 Upset Contest Winner
This week's game against TSUN is, quite simply and without hyperoble, the Biggest Game in the 85-year history of the venerable stadium.

What have been the most anticipated and most important games in the history of the 'Shoe, which saw it's first game in 1922? Here are 20 of those games.

Note: All rankings in this post are from the AP poll only.

On November 2, 1935, the year before the AP poll started, a 4-0 tOSU team met a 5-0 Notre Dame team. After tOSU recovered a late onside kick by ND, they fumbled near midfield, allowing William Shakespeare to throw a last minute game-winning TD, probably costing tOSU a national championship (NC). Although sometimes called an early 'Game of the Century' due to ND winning in dramatic fashion, it probably wasn't the most anticipated game that year, since 10-0 TCU visited 10-0 (and eventual NC) SMU 4 weeks later.

On November 21, 1942, #5 tOSU defeated #4 TSUN 21-7, keeping alive NC aspirations.

On November 28, 1942, (a week later, in the only non-TSUN season finale since 1935), #3 tOSU defeated Iowa Pre-Flight 41-12, which resulted in the school's first NC; as on that same day #1 Boston College lost to Holy Cross and #2 Georgia Tech lost to Georgia.

On November 25, 1944, #3, 8-0 tOSU defeated #6, 8-1 TSUN 18-14 to complete an undefeated season. The team didn't go to a bowl game and finished AP #2 behind Army.

On November 20, 1948, #1, 8-0 TSUN defeated a #18, 6-2 tOSU team 13-3 to complete their NC season.

The November 25, 1950 Snow Bowl was not one of the most anticipated games in the history of the 'Shoe, but definitely was one of the most memorable. In a game with 45 punts, TSUN won 9-3 despite not getting a single first down; scoring a TD and a safety on blocked punts.

On October 6, 1951, in the second game under Woody Hayes, a #7, 1-0 tOSU team lost to #1 Michigan State 24-20. The Spartans finished the year 9-0, but ended up AP #2 behind Tennessee.

On October 11, 1952, a 1-1 tOSU squad coached by embattled Woody Hayes (and his then 5-4-2 career record) defeated #1 Wisconsin 23-14, which gave the young coach some credibility and time to build his program.

On November 20, 1954, #1 tOSU needed a win over #12, 6-2 TSUN in order to keep alive it's NC bid, which was successful with a 21-7 win in The Game and a 20-7 Rose Bowl win over USC.

On October 15, 1966, a 1-2 tOSU team lost to #1 Michigan State 11-8.

On October 12, 1968, a young #4 tOSU team ("Super Sophs") defeated #1 Purdue 13-0, and moved up to the #2 spot in the polls on the way to the NC.

On November 23, 1968, #2 tOSU needed a win over 1-loss, #4 TSUN in order to get a chance at the NC against USC in the Rose Bowl. tOSU won 50-14, failing on a 2-point conversion attempt after the last TD in Woody's 'Because I couldn't go for three' game. The win caused tOSU to jump USC for the #1 AP ranking, which was prophetic since tOSU then beat the #2, O. J. Simpson led squad 27-16 to win another NC.

On November 21, 1970, #4, 8-0 tOSU downed #5, 9-0 TSUN 20-9. A Rose Bowl loss to Stanford cost the team the NC in the major polls.

On November 25, 1972, a #9, 8-1 tOSU team defeated #3, 10-0 TSUN 14-11, in a game which featured tOSU stopping TSUN with goal-line stands on fourth-and-1 in two different possessions.

On November 23, 1974, #4, 9-1 tOSU downed #3, 10-0 TSUN 12-10 on four FG's by Tom Klaban, and a late missed FG by Mike Lantry. For the last time, TSUN didn't go to a bowl game, and tOSU lost a classic Rose Bowl to USC 18-17, on a late TD and 2-point conversion.

On September 24, 1977, #4 tOSU lost to #3 Oklahoma 29-28, when the Sooners got a last-minute FG after recovering an onsides kick. Oklahoma was voted #1 in the next AP poll.

On November 2, 1985, #8, 6-1 tOSU defeated #1, 7-0 Iowa 22-13 as Chris Spielman intercepted two passes in the rain.

On September 20, 1995, #7, 3-0 tOSU defeated #15, 3-1 Notre Dame 45-26 in their first visit in 60 years.

On November 23, 2002, #2, 12-0 tOSU defeated #12, 9-2 TSUN 14-9 with Will Allen securing the game by intercepting a ball on the goal line as time ran out; thus earning a berth in the 2003 Fiesta Bowl, where they won the NC over Miami.

On September 10, 2005, #4 tOSU dropped a 25-22 decision to #2 Texas, who would go on to win the NC with a Rose Bowl win over USC.
 
2002 was bigger than this. When you factor in the years of Cooper choking, the fact that nobody was yet 100%certain that JT was "The Man", the fact that the team was staggering to the stretch with close wins over Purdue and Illinois, and that we had gone 30+ without a national championship, I don't think it's even close.

If we lose Saturday, it will suck.

Losing in 2002 would have sucked X 100.
 
Upvote 0
Something that is being lost in the hype for this game -- the winner will be the outright Big Ten champion, something we have not been able to claim in 22 years, I believe.

Personally, I think that's as big as a slot in the national title game.
 
Upvote 0
tibor75;660652; said:
2002 was bigger than this. When you factor in the years of Cooper choking, the fact that nobody was yet 100%certain that JT was "The Man", the fact that the team was staggering to the stretch with close wins over Purdue and Illinois, and that we had gone 30+ without a national championship, I don't think it's even close.

If we lose Saturday, it will suck.

Losing in 2002 would have sucked X 100.

Agree and disagree.

I would say that 2002 was more important to the program overall but 2006 is obviously the biggest The Game has ever been on a national level.

On a side note, I'm amazed how the attitude of the entire Buckeye nation has been changed by Tress in the past 4 years. I was a nervous wreck in 2002 and honestly was just hoping we'd win. 2006 and I'm calm as can be and fully expect to win if we play hard and smart enough to earn it. Have I been 'vested or what?
 
Upvote 0
Buckeyeskickbuttocks;660654; said:
Disagree, Tibs. I agree that 02 was huge as you describe, but never in my adult life has The Game been 1 v. 2. That added bit takes it over the top, far as I'm concerned.

I'm not sure how it being 1 versus 2 makes it bigger. It makes it bigger for the entire country as a whole, but for scUM and OSU fans it really shouldn't watter. To me, this is just as big as every other game where the NC was on the line.
 
Upvote 0
tibor75;660660; said:
I'm not sure how it being 1 versus 2 makes it bigger. It makes it bigger for the entire country as a whole, but for scUM and OSU fans it really shouldn't watter. To me, this is just as big as every other game where the NC was on the line.
Yeah, I would have to agree that every game against the Vulvarines is a biggie. Still, because both are undefeated and because a trip to the show is on the line, it just stands out to me as bigger than it usually is.... as if that was even possible.

Actually, truth is I'm just posting now in case you try and re-spell matter. :biggrin:

Edit: Although, turning the M upside down is a nice touch. :biggrin:
 
Upvote 0
tibor75;660661; said:
BB73,

what about Springs slips?


What game is this you refer to? Sorry but my memory fails me.

My last memory, they carried a victorious Earl Bruce off tsun's field, then I go blank and come back to at a BBall game when I hear the 310 day speech from Tress.

Did I miss someone in between?
 
Upvote 0
The #1 vs. #2 in the biggest rivalry in CFB obviously makes this the biggest game in the history of the series because what's at stake, for BOTH teams.

From purely an Ohio State perspective, I'd have to agree that 2002 was bigger. Our program has now transformed under Tressel to one that will be a recognized power year in and year out. Plus, the NC has been ours to lose since day one this year. In 2002, we worked our way all the way up from #13 I believe, and at times it seemed like it was done with smoke and mirrors as opposed to pretty much blowing everybody out like we've done this year. And, as Tibor mentioned, 'the drought" was also a huge factor there.

From a personal standpoint, as the 2002 GAME approached, my feelings were how much I wanted to WIN that game. As saturday approaches, I'm finding myself hoping that we don't LOSE that game. Guess it's one of those "riches-spoils" deals. Peace.
 
Upvote 0
tibor75;660661; said:
BB73,

what about Springs slips?

The '96 and '98 games against TSUN just missed the cut.

In 1996, tOSU was #2 and TSUN was 7-3 and #21. If tOSU had been #1, or would have earned the right to play the #1 team with a win (not possible in 1996 pre-BCS days), or if TSUN was in the top-10, it would have been included.

In 1998, although tOSU ended up #2, the AP ranking was only #7 going into The Game, and TSUN was #11.
 
Last edited:
Upvote 0
I'm not sure how it being 1 versus 2 makes it bigger. It makes it bigger for the entire country as a whole, but for scUM and OSU fans it really shouldn't watter. To me, this is just as big as every other game where the NC was on the line.

As I tried to convince my wife on our honeymoon, it depends on your definition of bigger.

What makes this so big from a National perspective is the anticipation. These have been "The Teams" since USC lost the end of October. And the schedules laid it out that they would probably meet undefeated since even eariler.

OSU/Michigan games are huge for OSU and Michigan fans anytime either team has a lot on the line. You go back to 1968 through 1975 or so and almost every season one or the other was in the NC hunt. And with it being "Rose Bowl or sit" all of those games were huge.

I think it tops 2002 because:

1) For OSU it is validation of the entire season. We have been #1 all year. If we don't finish that is all hot air. In 2002 we dodged bullets all season, but while losing in The Game would have derailed that run the championship was never an 'expectation'. It was more of a dream. It would have been a shame to lose the prize at the end of that magic season, but we would not have 'lost face' so to speak.

2) For Michigan it is a chance to prove they are still Michigan. They are 2-8 in the last two games of the year over the past 5 years. Lose this and it becomes the same old story.

Of course, there is also the unwarranted assumption that the winner will simply take a victory lap in Glendale.


On the other hand, the lobbying in advance of this game for a potential rematch is beginning to take a shade off of the luster. I would almost prefer both coaches step forward now like Rocky and Apollo and say "I don't want a rematch." Let's make it clear that this is for all the marbles.
 
Upvote 0
Back
Top