Amir Williams’ swat-but-not night — six blocked shots without a single rebound — pretty much sums up Ohio State’s season. The sophomore center is a mystery wrapped within the enigma of a team that tries its best to puzzle you.
Just as Williams can show glimpses of the McDonald’s high-school All-American he was — those career-high six blocks — then get devoured like a Big Mac on the boards, so the Buckeyes can look like an NCAA Tournament tiger — see the win over Michigan and near upset of Duke — but turn around and lose badly to Illinois.
Exhibit A of the perplexing up-and-down play arrived courtesy of Iowa last night at Value City Arena, where 14th-ranked Ohio State controlled the Hawkeyes — at one point leading by 24 points — then nearly squandered the lead before pulling out a 72-63 win.
Like Williams, the Buckeyes have so much talent, but at times show so little skill. Evan Ravenel is the only senior, so it is fair to say Ohio State is a victim of its own youth. The lack of staying power shows in Williams, Sam Thompson and LaQuinton Ross, three sophomores who one media member dubbed the Bermuda Triangle of Ohio State basketball:Their games are out there somewhere, sometimes visible, but then disappear in a blink.
But to pin the inconsistency only on those three players would not be accurate, because junior Lenzelle Smith Jr. also comes and goes like the wind. And against Iowa, junior point guard Aaron Craft was uncharacteristically hit-and-miss, scoring 12 points but committing six turnovers against five assists.
Coach Thad Matta said his players are exhausted because he has worked them harder in practice than any team in recent memory, but Matta also has eyes like the rest of us. He sees irregularities that are not yet alarming but concerning nonetheless.
“The biggest thing with this team we keep searching for is consistency,” Matta said. “I’ll take consistency over greatness. I don’t need a great play. I need consistent play.”
The good news for Ohio State is there remains time to find the consistency Matta seeks.
“On Jan. 22 (in the past), we’ve been this way before,” he said.
Last year comes to mind. The Buckeyes were stuck in neutral during stretches of the 2011-12 season but put things together late and made a run to the Final Four. I do not suggest this bunch is in for a similar route, but there remains room for intelligent tinkering. Ross, for one, will continue to collect playing time as his game develops. Shannon Scott already is smoother than he was two months ago.