Thanks for the info......and presenting it in a way that wasn't arrogant as hell.Before the Dickinson system in 1926, there were no "active deciders" awarding titles at the end of the season. Any titles awarded before that year are retroactive. (Dickinson retroactively awarded the 1924 & 1925 title in 1926).
The Helms Athletic Foundation was founded by Paul Helms in 1936. In 1941, Bill Schroeder, the managing director, retroactively picked the champions from 1883 to 1940.
The National Championship Foundation was founded by Mike Riter in 1981. They retroactively awarded titles from 1869 to 1980.
Maybe I'm misinterpreting your post, but you seem to be implying that Helms and NCF were awarding those early titles as the seasons played out and that, depending on the time period, one or the other was considered the "real" title. The truth is that there were no "real" titles from that period as they were all retroactively awarded.
The list you provided above does not show who decided the "real" champion for those years. It simply shows which entities the website owner/s decided to recognize. College Football Data Warehouse has a similar list and the NCAA yet another.
I wasn't aware that they were retroactive....and yes, I'm going off the list saying which entities were the actual deciders based on what year is in question. CFBDW used to use the same list, but they decided to just count all of them at once.
I'll use 1994 as an example for obvious reasons:
Florida State: Dunkel
*Nebraska: Alderson, AP, Berryman, Billingsley, FACT, FB News, FW, National Championship Foundation, Sporting News, UPI, USA/CNN, USA/NFF
Penn State: DeVold, Eck, FACT, Matthews, National Championship Foundation, NY Times, Sagarin
All those fun "titles", but only the AP and USA/CNN ones actually count.
Interestingly enough, the NCF awarded their title to Penn State, yet the NCAA site doesn't list a title for Penn State. It's almost as if the NCF had a period of time when it really counted, and another when it didn't.
The site I found was the only one that explained what periods of time counted for each selector. Is there a better list out there (aside from just counting them all because I'm too lazy to do the work)?
Upvote
0