Well I don't know about any of you but Malkin does not play like the dominant player that he can be when Sid comes into the lineup. Two years now when Crosby has been injured for extended periods of time Malkin has put up gaudy numbers only to be a shell of himself once Sidney came back.
Personally I've never understood why Crosby was a captain. Captains don't do what he did in game 3, and for the most part that is Crosby's game. I'm a HUGE pens fan but I can honestly say sometimes the way they play the game disguists me. Diving, acting, instigating, and throwing cheap shots.
Which is why I'd be MORE THAN HAPPY to trade Sidney (who has injury questions to begin with) for a Staple in the backend like Weber. I'm a strong believer in any aspect of essentially anything in life that balance is huge and having 16mil tied up between the top 2 players in the league is dumb. Especially when one or both will demand much more once their current contract is up.
I'd love to see Crosby for Weber+ 1st rounder. Then Trade Paul Martin for either a quality winger or just to clear up cap space to find another winger. Surround Malkin (or Crosby) with great linesman and make it the hardest line to stop and not to mention make the defense leaps and bounds better with Weber.