Dispatch
COLLEGE FOOTBALL
BCS policy leaves Wisconsin in lurch
Two-team limit per league hurts Badgers
Wednesday, December 13, 2006
Tim May
THE COLUMBUS DISPATCH
Quinn Pitcock gave an interesting answer when asked, if given a magic wand, what one thing he would change about the Bowl Championship Series.
The Ohio State senior defensive tackle didn?t mention anything about establishing a playoff system or giving Michigan another chance at the topranked Buckeyes instead of Florida in the national title game.
"I know one thing that I?d change is I feel like, with Wisconsin not being able to get in, you should be able to have more than two teams out of your conference go to a BCS game," Pitcock said. "They?re going to the Capital One Bowl ? but I feel like if you are ranked in the top 10 teams you should be able to play in a BCS game."
Make that the top seven in the case of Wisconsin (11-1). In the final BCS standings, the Badgers finished ahead of BCS bowl-bound teams Boise State (eighth), Oklahoma (10 th), Notre Dame (11 th) and Wake Forest (14 th).
But the BCS has a long-standing rule that no more than two teams from a conference can go to BCS bowls in a single season. In the case of the Big Ten, Ohio State (12-0) is headed for the national title game and Michigan (11-1), the only team to beat Wisconsin, is headed for the Rose Bowl.
That meant Wisconsin had to settle for a second straight trip to the Capital One Bowl to play Arkansas even though the Badgers posted their first 11-win regular season and were fifth in the USA Today coaches poll and sixth in the Harris Interactive poll, two of the three components of the BCS ratings formula.
"Even though it doesn?t have the name, ?BCS bowl,? I think it?s going to be a better bowl than most of the BCS bowls," Badgers tackle Joe Thomas told the Wisconsin State Journal. "That?s just the way I think."
The Big Ten can?t complain, either. This will mark the sixth time in the nine-year history of the BCS that the conference has gained the maximum two spots. The next-closest league is the Southeastern Conference with four times, including this year ? Florida plays Ohio State in the championship game and Louisiana State plays Notre Dame in the Sugar Bowl.
Not that those conferences get double the financial reward. In regards to the six major BCS conferences, the first team in gains a $17 million payout to the league, while the payout for a second team is $4.5 million.
Fiesta Bowl-bound Boise State, from a non-BCS conference, will see $9 million go to the Western Athletic Conference. That?s over and above its already guaranteed small slice of the $9 million the BCS sends down to be divvied up by the WAC, Mountain West, Mid-American, Sun Belt and Conference USA.
The BCS moved this year from four games to five, making the championship game separate but still administered by one of the four major bowls. One reason for the expansion was to double the amount of nonguaranteed spots to four, giving more opportunities to teams such as Boise State and deserving at-large teams from the stronger conferences.
But the rule wasn?t changed that limits a conference to two spots overall, though the Big Ten has lobbied for that.
"That takes four votes (from the eight-member BCS committee) and we don?t have four votes," Big Ten commissioner Jim Delany said yesterday.
As for the intent of the limit, "It?s a system that is attempting to take care of champions, take care of bowls, put the one-two game together, take care of Notre Dame, take care of second-place teams," Delany said.
And as he pointed out, while the Big Ten and Wisconsin might have reason to pout this year, the SEC has four teams in the top 12.
"What would you think about four SEC teams?" he said.