• Follow us on Twitter @buckeyeplanet and @bp_recruiting, like us on Facebook! Enjoy a post or article, recommend it to others! BP is only as strong as its community, and we only promote by word of mouth, so share away!
  • Consider registering! Fewer and higher quality ads, no emails you don't want, access to all the forums, download game torrents, private messages, polls, Sportsbook, etc. Even if you just want to lurk, there are a lot of good reasons to register!

ashlandbuck

Banned
If I missed any comments concerning this in any of the other threads I apologize. A few days ago in the Mansfield News Journal there was a article about the Buckeyes QB situation. Evidently during a press conference with Troy, a reporter ask him if he would be looking over his shoulder during the Iowa game. The report in the paper made it sound as if Troy had a near meltdown. Ts called it a bad question and later, unable to let it go came back to it and once again scolded the reporter for a stupid question and told the reporter what kind of questions he should be asking.
I understand that at times the media can be a pain in the ass. But the question, while not exactly a direct question concerning the upcoming game is legitimate in that TS didn't have a quality start and obviously JT hasn't forgotten about JZ because of the playing time he recieved at the end of Game #3.
I can understand the pressure TS feels but he cannot respond in this way in the media. He shows still too much immaturity and a lack of judgment. I begin to question his ability to handle pressure and worry about what he may say or do over the next two seasons when things do not go his way.
Even a twenty year old kid should've been able to take this question and handle it easily with a basic "canned" response, ie., "I never play the game with that mentality. I just go out and try to do my best on each play and hopefully that will be enough to keep me on the field for each series".
It's that simple. It was actually a simple question that required a simple answer.
I imagine that some of these reporters understand TS and realize they can get to him with certain approaches. He MUST handle this better. I would be surprised if JT or someone from the staff didn't speak to TS about his public statements and attitude.
Personally, if it were me and I were in JT's shoes, I'd be very worried about this kid over the next two seasons. He has a history dating back to high school and has still shown no signs of a normal maturation process.
I was in this kid's corner after the Michigan game and would argue with my friends about his status on this team. Many still wanted to see JZ starting this year. How could anyone think that after the game he had against scUM?
But even that game is still just one game. He has shown me no signs that he can play anywhere near that level on a consistant basis. That fact along with his spooky personality, I'd walk away from him and go with a kid I know can get the ball to the most talented group of WR's in this schools history.
 
This article?:

Is Smith the man or a mirage?<!--EZCODE BOLD END--><!--EZCODE FONT END-->

By Jon Spencer
News Journal
COLUMBUS -- It's not easy being at the controls of the nation's 81st-ranked offense. Just ask Ohio State quarterback Troy Smith.

But proceed with caution.

Smith snapped at reporters this week when asked if he'll be looking over his shoulder during Saturday's Big Ten opener with Iowa.

It seemed a fair question given the way Ohio State's offense coughed and wheezed Saturday in Smith's first start of the season. The fact it came against a winless San Diego State team that surrendered 85 points in two games before coming to Columbus didn't seem to help the Buckeyes. The OSU offense was so bad coach Jim Tressel didn't award an Offensive Player or Lineman of the Week after an uninspiring a 27-6 win.

Ohio State's longest touchdown drive was 32 yards, and that came against a defense decimated by UCLA (44 points) and Air Force (41 points). Smith rushed for 87 yards and scored two TDs, but he also threw an interception in Aztec territory, missed open receivers despite excellent protection and lucked out for the second week in a row when cornerback Donny Baker dropped a certain pick-six at the OSU 30.

That performance came on the heels of the 25-22 loss to Texas in which Smith came off the bench to engineer five scoring drives. Four of them, however, started inside the UT 40, produced just 39 yards and only field goals.

Given that Justin Zwick started against Texas and was the quarterback called upon in crunch time against the Longhorns, Smith's grip on the job he now holds would seem to be a relevant issue.

He didn't see it that way and sneeringly voiced his displeasure.

"I haven't thought about (job security) ... that's a terrible question," he said.

When the subject returned a few moments later, Smith became more agitated.

"I don't think that's a good question; I don't think that's a smart question simply because we're facing Iowa and that's what we need to worry about now," Smith said. "Questions should go toward how does the team look and how are we getting ready for Iowa."

Whether he likes it or not, Smith's performance in the two games he has played since coming off a two-game suspension have given observers reason to wonder if his breakout performance last Nov. 20 against Michigan was an epiphany or aberration.

Overall, his record as a starter looks impressive at 5-1. However, he's just 1-1 against teams with a winning record, again that one win was his spectacular performance in a 37-21 win against Michigan.

A deeper look shows Smith was barely adequate in his four starts before that game.


He completed only 12-of-24 passes against hapless Indiana.

The Buckeyes managed just one offensive TD, and that came on a 35-yard drive in a 21-10 win over a 4-7 Penn State team.

Ted Ginn Jr.'s three touchdowns almost single-handedly beat a 5-6 Michigan State club. The Spartans were playing a backup QB but still dominated the Buckeyes in yardage (407 to 307) and first downs (22 to 12).

Smith committed four turn- overs, all in the second half, in a 24-17 loss at Purdue, a team that lost four straight before OSU came to town.
Smith's punishment for taking money from a booster was sitting out the Zwick-led Alamo Bowl rout of Oklahoma State and the 34-14 season-opening win over Miami (Ohio). Smith realizes he can no longer use his layoff as a crutch.

"What is missing is continuity," he said. "I was missing for awhile and that is a big reason. But now I'm back and there is no excuses. We have to put it together now and get the ball rolling.

"Getting back to rare top form is hard. A lot of people are trying to rush things, but it's not that easy. The teams we play, they game plan all year, as do we."

The eighth-ranked Buckeyes (2-1) can't afford to be patient. A loss to No. 21 Iowa (2-1) would extinguish all hope of playing for a national championship and send OSU into a bye week on a bad note. Never mind the Buckeyes then head to Penn State for a prime-time showdown, having lost five of their last six Big Ten road games under Tressel.

Infatuated with Smith's athleticism and the added dimension his running ability gives the attack, Tressel concedes his quarterback must do a better job of considering his options on pass plays before pulling the ball down and relying on his feet.

"It's having that calm relaxation and taking what the defense gives you," Tressel said. "A lot of games I've watched over the years, the unnoticed thing is the third-and-seven play where (receivers are) tied up and the quarterback ran for a first down and changed the complexion of the game. We don't discount the importance of that, but you have to do things in progression. Troy needs to be a little better from a progression standpoint."

Interestingly, Tressel is looking for the offensive balance OSU struck in the opener behind Zwick. He completed passes to five different receivers on the opening drive alone, effectively setting the tone. Tailback Antonio Pittman rushed for 100 yards on 14 carries.

Granted, Miami is not in the same class as No. 2 Texas. But the RedHawks, across the board, were a stronger test than San Diego State.

Still, Tressel gave no indication he would turn things over to Zwick if Smith struggles against Iowa.

"I don't know that we've been consistent enough in the running game to take (defenses) out of guessing what we're going to be doing," Tressel said. "There was a point where Texas was running it well enough with both its running back and quarterback where we had to bring an extra (defender) in the box.

"All of a sudden that opens up (the passing game). You need that balance to be good and that's where we need to get."
 
Upvote 0
RE: Ashland's comments

That's certainly the way most people are looking at his comments. To be the Devil's advocate I think maybe this just demonstrates the balls this kid has.

"Hey, you wanna ask a question like that I'm gonna break my foot off in your ass!" How many kids 21 or so can talk to people older than them like that?

I'm not condemning or condoning. I won't judge him in interviews.

Imagine if the reporter would've piped in with a "I'll take that as a yes" to Troy's response.

Also, you don't play football, especially in Columbus if you can't take the heat. Let's just see if he produces in an hour and a half or so.
 
Upvote 0
It's like the old cliche about shitty journalisim;

Reporter: "Troy is their a QB controversy on this team?"

TS: "No"

headline reads: Troy Smith denies QB controversy.
 
Upvote 0
Thats what you gotta love about the kid, he takes no shit (as someone pointed out already). My personal favorite is when he spotted a reporter asking him questions and writing in an Iowa Hawkeye notepad, he asked him where he got it and was pissed for the remainder of the interview.
 
Upvote 0
I don't have a problem with the way he handled the media, (because I don't like the media as a whole). I do have a problem about the way he went about it last year complaining about playing time and being a ME ME ME type of player!
 
Upvote 0
I don't have a problem with the way he handled the media, (because I don't like the media as a whole). I do have a problem about the way he went about it last year complaining about playing time and being a ME ME ME type of player!

That's exactly why I do have a problem with his reaction to the question.
For once he should've show some class. He's shown very little of it up to now.
He got kicked out of one high school because of violence and his stay at tOSU has been quite rocky. Time to grow up a little.( or a lot in this case)
 
Upvote 0
I am not a big Smith fan, although he is playing fairly well today. And the reason I have not been a Smith fan, is that I see a total lack of character. On TV, he says all the right things, but I can see through that and question whether he is sincere or not. His actions off the field say otherwise. And when I see him respond to a simple question like that, it makes me wonder again. Zwick has been asked that question 100time since the bowl game and I haven't seen him get testy, just answers it calmy and moves on.
But anyway...really doesn't matter, Smith is Tressels man right now and I don't see that changing anytime soon. So we haev to support him so the Bucks can be successful.
cbf:osu:
 
Upvote 0
Guys, this discussion is fine right now but it is creeping close to getting personal. Let's not cross the bashing line here. Troy has made mistakes, but he is a Buckeye.

Let us not also forget that he led the Buckeyes to a marvelous victory today..

Want him to die by the sword??

I say, let him also live by it

Good game Troy :oh::io:
 
Upvote 0
Just another example of the media trying to make themselves the story. It gets tiring... I like the Parcells approach- tell the bonehead the question is stupid! (Okay, maybe a young football player should show a little more restraint than the Tuna!!)
 
Upvote 0
Back
Top