I can understand why he isn't universally loved but for me personally I don't care about all that. The majority of big time athletes aren't the most likeable critters that ever walked from primordial ooze. If we only rooted for the good guys we'd all be constrained to being Freddy Funk fans.
For me, golf tournaments are more compelling when Tiger is in the hunt, right wrong or indifferent.
I'd prefer he never catch Jack but even if he does it won't stop anyone from arguing Jacks case as the greatest ever so why worry about it?
Someone said today you have Tiger and Phil paired up. That's two world class players, two ego maniacal jerks, two guys that absolutely HATE each other going at it head to head. It's much more compelling to watch than the nameless rabble of teenage/male model/Australian/Euro types that have failed so miserably to fill the void of Tigers absence.