I just dont like his approach to hitting. Its widely known around the league now according to some scouts through MLB.com that E5 cannot handle a pitch on the outer portion of the plate. The HR against Lyons was a fluke and a mistake on Lyons part. After the game he said that it just left his hand wrong as he was working the outside of the plate and it rode in where E5 got it.
If Edwin made more contact even on his outs I would be more inclined to say that he is in a slump, such as Dunn currently is. Edwin rarely makes great contact on the ball which is not a good sign to me. I wish he would pull it together and put up the numbers that the Reds need him to but I dont see it happening. I know Adam Dunn wishes he'd get it together so that he could see some decent pitches once in a while as well.