QB --All 21st Century Team

[BuckeyeKid789]

83 people have voted so I'd say most of them have only voted for one.

Still pretty amazing that it's a dead heat.

Since it was so close I thought people might be choosing the top 2 quarterbacks.

 

[BuckeyeKid789]

Are people voting for two? You're supposed to only pick one.

Lol, someone negged me for reminding them of the rule.

 

[7 45 33 48]

I will take Troy Smith even with Krenzel's NC. Yes Krenzel made some clutch plays but so has Troy Smith. The 2002 team won because of Clarett, the defense, and special teams. The 2005 team at the end of the year won in large part because of Troy Smith.

 

[Jaxbuck]

I'll make it easy on myself and go with CK simply because TS hasn't finished his career yet and we don't have his entire body of work to judge.

Do this thread again in a couple of years and it will be very tough indeed.

In the meantime its CK vs Bellisari and Scotty Mac.....I think I'll take CK.

 

[tedginn05]

Are people voting for two? You're supposed to only pick one.

I would say so

As I started typing this post...

92 People have voted

And there has been a total of 104 votes

So 12 people voted for 2 people or some voted for more than 2.

 

[Muck]

Lol, someone negged me for reminding them of the rule.

Well that's just silly. I'll throw some luv your way to counter it.

So 12 people voted for 2 people or some voted for more than 2.

That's a low enough percentage that I can live with it. Well within the margin of error I was expecting. :)

 

[tedginn05]

That's a low enough percentage that I can live with it. Well within the margin of error I was expecting. :)

Well I think it was people confused. The first couple of your pools you asked people to choose 2.

You could've totally avoided that by not making this pool or others that you only asked for 1 choice a multiple choice pool.

 

[Kueller]

Are people voting for two? You're supposed to only pick one.

When the poll was first posted it said to vote for two (it was both bold and underlined at the time). It has since been editted. This is why the first reply was about voting for CK and TS.

 

[BGriffBuckeye]

Easy.. I picked Craig as my vote. He won us a National Championship and Troy's antics before the season arguably lost us a chance at one in 2005. But Troy is w/o a doubt the #2.

 

[AJHawkfan]

Tough choice between Smith and Krenzel. I ended up going with Smith. Yup, I'm now officially on the bandwagon.......

 

[BuckeyeKid789]

When the poll was first posted it said to vote for two (it was both bold and underlined at the time). It has since been editted. This is why the first reply was about voting for CK and TS.

I assumed so when I saw that the post was edited. The race between CK and TS was so close I thought people were choosing their top 2 instead of 1.

 

[BuckeyeKid789]

Tough choice between Smith and Krenzel. I ended up going with Smith. Yup, I'm now officially on the bandwagon.......

Welcome aboard.

 

[osugrad21]

and has had the most impressive individual performances in the history of this fine school.

Wow, bold statement. That is certainly debatable.

 

[BuckeyeKid789]

Wow, bold statement. That is certainly debatable.

Against Michigan not any game, though, if you do have a great game against scUM it means more than having a great game against Indiana or a San Diego St. Eddie George against Illinois is a candidate also. I was just talking about Troy's career against Michigan.

 

[Zurp]

I almost voted for Bellisari, just because I didn't think anyone else would. But now I see that 2 people already did. I'm surprised he has more votes than McMullen does.