INDIANA COACHING JOB
Many successful coaches are ‘outsiders’
Tuesday, February 21, 2006
Tim May
THE COLUMBUS DISPATCH
If Indiana University officials have paid attention to college basketball history, they probably should pay little heed to what outgoing coach Mike Davis recommended about his successor.
Before Davis announced his resignation, effective at season’s end, the native of Alabama said he thought Hoosiers fans would be happier "with one of their own." But the records suggest that a coach’s alma mater has little to do with his success.
In Indiana’s case, the most obvious example is Bob Knight, who at his core is a Buckeye — an Orrville native who played at Ohio State. His firing six years ago opened the door for Davis, who had been a Hoosiers assistant for three years.
Consider the following:
• North Carolina’s Dean Smith, the winningest men’s coach, was born in Emporia, Kan., and played at Kansas.
• Kentucky’s Adolph Rupp was born in Halstead, Kan., and played at Kansas.
• UCLA’s John Wooden was an early star for Purdue.
• Mount St. Mary’s Jim Phelan was from Philadelphia and played at LaSalle.
• Hank Iba, primarily of Oklahoma State fame, went to Westminster and Maryville Teachers College, both in Missouri.
• Duke’s Mike Krzyzewski was a native of Chicago who played for Knight at Army.
• Connecticut’s Jim Calhoun graduated from American International College.
• Purdue’s Gene Keady was born in Larned, Kan., and played at Kansas State.
• Rick Pitino, known for his Kentucky and Louisville achievements, is from New York City and graduated from Massachusetts.
• Jerry Tarkanian, best known for his exploits at UNLV, was from Euclid, Ohio, and graduated from Fresno State.
Of course, there are exceptions to the outside rule, among them: Phog Allen, who played at Kansas and went on to become its image-building coach; Jim Boeheim, who was a walk-on who made good at Syracuse before returning as its coach; Fred Taylor, who played at and then coached Ohio State to the heights; and Roy Williams, who returned to North Carolina to lead the Tar Heels to the national championship last year.
But consider that among the current 11 coaches in the Big Ten, only two are at their alma mater, Penn State’s Ed DeChellis and Purdue’s Matt Painter.
Otherwise, the Big Ten is not a league of "their own," as Davis, Thad Matta (Butler) and Iowa’s Steve Alford (Indiana) show. Illinois’ Bruce Weber went to Wisconsin-Milwaukee; Michigan State’s Tom Izzo went to Northern Michigan; Wisconsin’s Bo Ryan went to Wilkes University in Pennsylvania; Michigan’s Tommy Amaker went to Duke; Minnesota’s Dan Monson went to Idaho; and Northwestern’s Bill Carmody went to Union College.
The lesson might be twofold: One, a fresh man brings fresh ideas. Two, it’s much easier to pull the plug on an outsider when expectations aren’t met.
[email protected]