To answer this question, a few truisms about football must come into play.
1. Those who run the ball successfully usually win.
2. You must score when you run the ball---touchdowns are better.
3. Must be competent defensively.
4. If you have a great defense, never do something on offense to leave them on the short field.
5. Use the talent you have and use them to the best of THEIR abilities.
6. You win with people. I think I heard that somewhere.
7. Win the surest way.
All of that being said, I want an OC who can make the offense score every time, throw the ball without any interceptions and with big plays. Have over 300 yards passing and over 200 yards running. No turnovers. Score every two minute drill. Win the time of possession with a t 70-30 percent ratio. Have 4 first team All Americans and a Heisman trophy winner every 3 years.