• New here? Register here now for access to all the forums, download game torrents, private messages, polls, Sportsbook, etc. Plus, stay connected and follow BP on Instagram @buckeyeplanet and Facebook.

Game Thread Northwestern at tOSU, Sat. Nov. 14th, noon ET, FOX

Kerry Coombs, right? Day sees him in action all of 2020 including the humiliating end.

Then he gets all off season, spring ball, summer camp and the 2021 loss to Oregon is what makes you realize he can't throw anything but a fastball?

A head coach watches one of his assistants every day in practice, goes up against him every day in team sessions and it takes another loss the next year to get you to do something? The HC in question thinks what? that the assistant is just going to stop being a one pitch pitcher at some fucking point?

One of my most fundamental and concerning issues with Day and it isn't just this year. It's almost hard to wrap your head around that kind of rigidity in thinking.
You know those gentleman agreements that the coaches will stay for a minimum of two years. That cuts both ways .... Oh wait. :smash:
 
Upvote 0
You know those gentleman agreements that the coaches will stay for a minimum of two years. That cuts both ways .... Oh wait. :smash:

yeah right?

It's not a guaranteed employment contract for two years, its an agreement we will work together for 2 years

Like you help me and I help you.

Not "you suck at your fucking job but I promised you two years" kind of thing
 
Upvote 0

Football Power Index​

Ohio State​

  • FPI: 24.3 (Rank: 5)
  • Proj. W-L: 8.6-3.6
  • Win Out %: 50.4
  • Win Conf. %: 13.5
  • CFP %: 36.1
  • Make NC %: 5.9
  • Win NC %: 2.9

Northwestern​

  • FPI: 12.2 (Rank: 31)
  • Proj. W-L: 7.6-4.4
  • Win Out %: 8.0
  • Win Conf. %: 0
  • CFP %: 1.1
  • Make NC %: 0
  • Win NC %: 0

FPI Matchup Predictor: Ohio State 85.4%​


SP+​

Ohio State​

  • Rank: No. 4 (down 2 from last week)
  • Rating: 24.0
  • Offense: 37.6 (11th)
  • Defense: 13.9 (8th)
  • Special Teams: 0.3 (57th)

Northwestern​

  • Rank: No. 33 (down 10 from last week)
  • Rating: 12.4
  • Offense: 32.4 (34th)
  • Defense: 19.9 (31st)
  • Special Teams: -0.1 (74th)

Matchup​

Projected Winner: Ohio Sate​

  • Projected Margin: 14.2 points
  • Win Probability: 81%
  • Projected Score(rounded): 33-19
    • *These projections are not QB adjusted*

Computer Models​

Sagarin Rankings
  • Ohio State: 89.90 (7th)
  • Northwestern: 81.28 (30th)
The Power Rank
  • Was not updated for Week 11
Massey Ratings
  • Ohio State: 8.89 (7th)
    • Offense: 67.48 (5th)
    • Defense: 41.86 (3rd)
  • Northwestern: 8.24 (29th)
    • Offense: 58.84 (44th)
    • Defense: 35.02 (27th)
  • Matchup Prediction: Ohio State 31, Northwestern 16 (86% win probability)

Advanced Metrics​

Rank​

Metric​

Ohio State Offense vs. Northwestern Defense​

Metric​

Rank​

19th 0.24 EPA/Pass -0.03 39th
39th 0.09 EPA/Rush 0.10 102nd
14th 57.7% Available Yards % 45.8% 67th
58th Own 30 Starting Field Position Own 27 19th
13th 0.18 Early Downs EPA/Play 0.07 81st
38th 47.8% 3rd/4th Down Success 43.6% T-62nd
24th 6.39 Avg 3rd Down Distance 6.24 120th
Metrics via Game On Paper

Rank​

Metric​

Northwestern Offense vs. Ohio State Defense​

Metric​

Rank​

24th 0.20 EPA/Pass -0.05 35th
20th 0.13 EPA/Rush -0.10 15th
21st 56.3% Available Yards % 34.8% 14th
76th Own 29 Starting Field Position Own 30 81st
12th 0.19 Early Downs EPA/Play -0.07 15th
46th 46.4% 3rd/4th Down Success 38.9% 31st
60th 6.89 Avg 3rd Down Distance 7.38 36th
 
Upvote 0
Start with QB- how do either of those teams have lesser talent than us?

Defensive Line?

OL?

J Smith of course is the most talented individual player on the field but overall? I just don't buy this.

Timmons, CHJ and other WR's are better than almost any other team but in the trenches, TE, RB, LB...I don't see it.
Now don’t start that again :lol: .

We got pantsed by Temu Mahomes. We laughed at this guy, but yet now he’s the greatest thing since sliced bread? USC I will give you. Again though, Wiscy throttled them.

We have experienced DL and OL contributors. DL has highly rated guys. OL has played together for most of 3 seasons. Jackson and West are averaging 4.9 and 4.7 ypc respectively.

People fawned over our off-season acquisitions in the portal.

You can’t convince me that we don’t have the talent to win 90% of our games and compete at a high level.

This is coaching malfeasance
 
Upvote 0
Now don’t start that again :lol: .

We got pantsed by Temu Mahomes. We laughed at this guy, but yet now he’s the greatest thing since sliced bread? USC I will give you. Again though, Wiscy throttled them.
No lets not be hyperbolic or change what I said.

The USC QB and Raiola are better than Fahey. If you disagree then list why. Temu Mahomes jokes don't count.
We have experienced DL and OL contributors. DL has highly rated guys. OL has played together for most of 3 seasons. Jackson and West are averaging 4.9 and 4.7 ypc respectively.
Experienced wasn't the question. Are we clearly better than anyone along these two lines? I don't see any talent flash when I watch.

4.9 and 4.7 ypc is a very definite mid level kind of output. Not worthless but nothing special.
People fawned over our off-season acquisitions in the portal.

You can’t convince me that we don’t have the talent to win 90% of our games and compete at a high level.

This is coaching malfeasance
I don't care what people fawned over. It has nothing to do with evaluating the talent on this team.

Questioning the talent level isn't excusing the coaching, it's their fault that the talent level is down but it is down and poor coaching gets more exposed.

At some point though some accountability has to rest with the players. Look at that play that Kyle Jones and others called out from Hinzman, the experienced center. It was just awful. He went where the coach told him to go and the effort and results were sub standard to say the very least.

If there was real talent present anywhere outside the WR room, it would show up in some kind of performance metric. As it is, every facet of the team other than EPA per dropback was middle of the CFB pack (or worse) pre injury to Sayin.

Coaching is bad. Talent is down.

Both things can be true.
 
Upvote 0
No lets not be hyperbolic or change what I said.

The USC QB and Raiola are better than Fahey. If you disagree then list why. Temu Mahomes jokes don't count.

Experienced wasn't the question. Are we clearly better than anyone along these two lines? I don't see any talent flash when I watch.

4.9 and 4.7 ypc is a very definite mid level kind of output. Not worthless but nothing special.

I don't care what people fawned over. It has nothing to do with evaluating the talent on this team.

Questioning the talent level isn't excusing the coaching, it's their fault that the talent level is down but it is down and poor coaching gets more exposed.

At some point though some accountability has to rest with the players. Look at that play that Kyle Jones and others called out from Hinzman, the experienced center. It was just awful. He went where the coach told him to go and the effort and results were sub standard to say the very least.

If there was real talent present anywhere outside the WR room, it would show up in some kind of performance metric. As it is, every facet of the team other than EPA per dropback was middle of the CFB pack (or worse) pre injury to Sayin.

Coaching is bad. Talent is down.

Both things can be true

If the only the coaches geared the scheme to our talent, this is my argument. They haven’t. Lack of adjustments by the coaches throughout the games and season are mind boggling. Where’s the coaching staff accountability?

Anyone could have stood back there and thrown the ball against our D in both the USC and Oregon games. Patricia’s D scheme made these guys look like all pros. I agree USC’s QB is leaps and bounds above Fahey and Raiola absolutely should be. Both of these guys have tremendous game experience. Temu jokes aside I was never arguing that Fahey was better.

I refuse to blame Fahey for the position he has been put in by the coaches. He wasn’t prepared to play. TSC is apparently a whole other situation. It’s ridiculous that Day/Smith thought that we were not going to need a prepared backup. Did they really watch the team in training camp and think wow we’re good here?

Again, coaching is a huge problem.

When you say talent is down, then the last 5 years of composite recruiting rankings must be shit because the Buckeyes were never out of the top 5. So either staff didn’t evaluate the players correctly, haven’t developed them, haven’t adapted the schemes or some level of all. Talent is down, sure, as I said in another thread compared to generational talent we had for the last couple years.

Coaching is bad, absolutely.
 
Upvote 0
If the only the coaches geared the scheme to our talent, this is my argument. They haven’t. Lack of adjustments by the coaches throughout the games and season are mind boggling. Where’s the coaching staff accountability?

Anyone could have stood back there and thrown the ball against our D in both the USC and Oregon games. Patricia’s D scheme made these guys look like all pros. I agree USC’s QB is leaps and bounds above Fahey and Raiola absolutely should be. Both of these guys have tremendous game experience. Temu jokes aside I was never arguing that Fahey was better.

I refuse to blame Fahey for the position he has been put in by the coaches. He wasn’t prepared to play. TSC is apparently a whole other situation. It’s ridiculous that Day/Smith thought that we were not going to need a prepared backup. Did they really watch the team in training camp and think wow we’re good here?

Again, coaching is a huge problem.

When you say talent is down, then the last 5 years of composite recruiting rankings must be shit because the Buckeyes were never out of the top 5. So either staff didn’t evaluate the players correctly, haven’t developed them, haven’t adapted the schemes or some level of all. Talent is down, sure, as I said in another thread compared to generational talent we had for the last couple years.

Coaching is bad, absolutely.

Remember in 2019, Halfley did a complete 180 with the worst defense we've seen this century (with the exact same personnel)?

After that, Hafley left, promoted Coombs, and that was that. But I remember Day essentially deciding after 2019 that he HAD to stick with the single high safety look, despite not having the personnel to run it.

Now, Coombs wasn't gonna be the guy regardless, but this is a trend Ive notice with Day. He falls in love with a scheme/approach, and often tries to foist it on whoever his coordinator is. Not ideal. Even worse if the hire is bad in the first place. Were witnessing it on offense right now.
 
Upvote 0
When you say talent is down, then the last 5 years of composite recruiting rankings must be shit because the Buckeyes were never out of the top 5. So either staff didn’t evaluate the players correctly, haven’t developed them, haven’t adapted the schemes or some level of all. Talent is down, sure, as I said in another thread compared to generational talent we had for the last couple years.

Coaching is bad, absolutely.
II don't care about recruiting rankings.

To give some terms here my thesis is this: This years OSU team lacks the kind of talent that would even be considered All Big Ten let alone nationally elite.

I had Chat go take the most up to date, season long PFF scores and cross cut it with just the 17 big ten teams. I told it to sort by position groups and identify where an OSU player would be in the top 2-3 at his position, allowing for bigger groups like OL and DB.

I get that PFF isn't perfect but it's a hell of a lot more objective than sitting here saying-we have enough talent to compete with anyone- type of generalizations.

Ohio State's All-Big Ten talent, measured by PFF​

Cross-cutting the 2026 PFF grades against the other 17 Big Ten teams produces a significantly different picture from Ohio State's preseason reputation.

I agree with expanding the qualifying spots to reflect an actual lineup. I'd use three WRs, five offensive linemen, four defensive linemen, two or three linebackers, and five defensive backs. QB and RB would each get two spots for our broader talent test.

What the conference comparisons show​

Position OSU's highest-graded player PFF grade Big Ten standing Top-unit qualifier?
WR Jeremiah Smith 92.3 1st Yes
RB Ja'Kobi Jackson 85.1 4th No
QB Julian Sayin 84.1 At least 4th No
C Carson Hinzman 74.1 At least 5th Borderline
G Luke Montgomery 73.3 6th No
OT Austin Siereveld 68.9 Outside top tier No
LB TJ Alford 87.5 4th Borderline
S Jay Timmons 79.4 Outside top five safeties No
CB Jermaine Mathews Jr. 75.3 Outside top five corners No
Sources: PFF's 2026 national position tables, cross-referenced by Big Ten membership.


PFF+7


The rankings marked at least are lower bounds because of the available comparison data. This isn't yet a complete 18-team export, and I don't want to present an estimated placement as an exact one.

The clearest finding is Jeremiah Smith. He is No. 2 nationally and No. 1 in the Big Ten. Nobody else on this list has established that same level of conference dominance.

2. The players who are close​

TJ Alford — LB
87.5 PFF grade · 246 snaps
He's fourth among the Big Ten linebackers visible above him: Sammy Omosigho (UCLA), Mason Posa (Wisconsin) and Cam Buffington (Iowa). An excellent grade, but he misses a strict top-three cutoff. His snap count is also considerably lower than theirs.

Luke Montgomery — Guard
73.3 PFF grade · 586 snaps
Two Iowa guards, along with guards from Washington, UCLA and Michigan State, rank ahead of him. That makes him sixth among Big Ten guards. He is a good player, but not an obvious first-unit selection even if we allow two guards.

Ja'Kobi Jackson — RB
85.1 PFF grade · 137 snaps
Wayne Knight (UCLA), Turbo Richard (Indiana) and Dierre Hill Jr. (Oregon) are all higher. Jackson is fourth, but his relatively limited playing time introduces substantial uncertainty.

Carson Hinzman — Center
74.1 PFF grade · 601 snaps
Michigan State, Minnesota, Nebraska and UCLA have centers ahead of him. That puts him outside the top three, although his workload gives us a reasonable sample.

3. The defensive front is the biggest concern​

The PFF grades for Ohio State's established defensive linemen aren't especially impressive.

Player Grade National positional rank
John Walker, DT 73.0 208
Jason Moore, DT 72.8 217
Eddrick Houston, DT 70.6 305
Kenyatta Jackson Jr., EDGE 69.2 374
Qua Russaw, EDGE 68.5 402


PFF

I haven't established exact Big Ten ranks for these five players, but their national positions make them unlikely candidates for a conference-wide elite defensive front.

One exception worth investigating is Beau Atkinson, who has an 81.5 grade but only 109 snaps. That's precisely where a production-only analysis needs a playing-time qualifier.

4. What about Timmons?​

Timmons's PFF grade is strong at 79.4 on the latest position table, but Northwestern's Robert Fitzgerald, Washington's Alex McLaughlin, Wisconsin's Matthew Jung and several other Big Ten safeties grade higher.

He isn't currently a top-five Big Ten safety by PFF overall grade. That does not contradict the idea that he's a future NFL-caliber corner. It means his present PFF production hasn't yet established him among the conference's very best defensive backs.

5. What I think this tells us​

The initial evidence points to a surprising conclusion: Ohio State has remarkably few players who are demonstrably among the Big Ten's elite by current-season PFF grades.

That is a different proposition from saying the roster lacks talent.

There are three possible explanations:

  1. Recruiting and draft expectations have overstated the actual talent.
  2. The talent is there, but individual execution and development are lagging.
  3. The players have genuine upside, but PFF's grades, role differences and opponent strength are missing some of it.
The offensive line and defensive front particularly warrant attention. Those are exactly the areas where we have seen Ohio State struggle against USC and Oregon.

One qualification before treating this as a final answer: I have cross-checked the leading candidates against the public position tables, but not completed a full export of every Big Ten player's grades. Therefore, I would not yet claim a definitive count of Ohio State players in a conference-wide top 22 or top 25.

Still, the preliminary result is meaningful. If the hypothesis was that Ohio State possesses six, eight or ten players who rank among the best at their positions in the Big Ten,
the available PFF grades are not supporting it.
 
Upvote 0


"I'll be cheering for Northwestern. That is my family now, and I'm going to stand by that," RJ told Eleven Warriors following his final high school game last Friday. "I'm committed to them, and that's who I'll be rooting for, and that's who I'll be supporting. Not that I'm not supporting my dad or anything like that. I just have to go and follow through with my commitment to Northwestern."

No offense.....kid can do what he wants, blah blah blah. And it honestly doesn't bother me who he cheers for, I picked NW in the upset pool, so this isn't me being an irrational fan grumpy because somebody didn't say they want Ohio State to win. But that's dumb. Your ACTUAL family is in charge of Ohio State. Your "football" family NEXT YEAR is across from you. Not this year, NEXT YEAR.

The pedantic asshole in me can't see something dumb and not point it out. That's dumb.
 
Upvote 0
No lets not be hyperbolic or change what I said.

The USC QB and Raiola are better than Fahey. If you disagree then list why. Temu Mahomes jokes don't count.

Experienced wasn't the question. Are we clearly better than anyone along these two lines? I don't see any talent flash when I watch.

4.9 and 4.7 ypc is a very definite mid level kind of output. Not worthless but nothing special.

I don't care what people fawned over. It has nothing to do with evaluating the talent on this team.

Questioning the talent level isn't excusing the coaching, it's their fault that the talent level is down but it is down and poor coaching gets more exposed.

At some point though some accountability has to rest with the players. Look at that play that Kyle Jones and others called out from Hinzman, the experienced center. It was just awful. He went where the coach told him to go and the effort and results were sub standard to say the very least.

If there was real talent present anywhere outside the WR room, it would show up in some kind of performance metric. As it is, every facet of the team other than EPA per dropback was middle of the CFB pack (or worse) pre injury to Sayin.

Coaching is bad. Talent is down.

Both things can be true.
What would Cignetti and his staff do with the OSU roster ?
 
Upvote 0
Appreciate the stats @Jaxbuck!

I know this is my bent, but this truly tells me that staff has done a horrible job of developing highly rated players that they’ve recruited.

It’s surprising not to see guys like Little, Moore and Sanchez from the secondary mentioned.

I don’t even know what to say about the OL situation and the dropoff in play there this year.

Apparently, other schools are doing more with less rated talent across the board and competing at a higher level.
 
Upvote 0
What would Cignetti and his staff do with the OSU roster ?

Aside from Smith?

Where are they picking up a clearly better group? DL? OL? RB? LB, TE? Definitely not kicker.

I wont argue that Cignetti and his staff > Day and his staff so they would likely do much better at getting JS the ball here in this last bit but I don't think they be marching to an undefeated season and NC with this OSU team.

Once Sayin was gone (and more importantly the reliable delivery mechanism to #4) the the rest of this roster was laid bare. For a combination of factors, the talent level is just down this year. Leadership is lacking. There has been incredibly bad luck. The schedule was unforgiving. It's just not our fucking year.

Then to all that you add the coaching has been horrific and here we are.

Like a season long Monday.
 
Upvote 0
Aside from Smith?

Where are they picking up a clearly better group? DL? OL? RB? LB, TE? Definitely not kicker.

I wont argue that Cignetti and his staff > Day and his staff so they would likely do much better at getting JS the ball here in this last bit but I don't think they be marching to an undefeated season and NC with this OSU team.

Once Sayin was gone (and more importantly the reliable delivery mechanism to #4) the the rest of this roster was laid bare. For a combination of factors, the talent level is just down this year. Leadership is lacking. There has been incredibly bad luck. The schedule was unforgiving. It's just not our fucking year.

Then to all that you add the coaching has been horrific and here we are.

Like a season long Monday.
Agreed on the OSU talent being down. I'm just perplexed as to how our coaching can be so substandard.
 
Upvote 0
The adjustments thing bugs me. When I work with baseball players, one of the canned teaching points is: high school hitters adjust game-to-game, college hitters adjust at bat-to-at bat, and professional hitters adjust pitch-to-pitch.

You're telling me, some mouth breathing retard like myself can figure that out, but this staff requires a loss to make adjustments (or worse, an off-season?) ... I don't buy this shit. How are we not making adjustments series-to-series, quarter-to-quarter, half-to-half?

I don't buy all this "roster is bad" cope. I think development is lacking. Scheme is lacking. Talent, maybe so, but let's control what we can control and get shit going.
If they're making adjustments series-to-series because of the iPads on the sidelines, I'm not seeing it...
 
Upvote 0
Back
Top