Name 50 QB's better than Ken Dorsey

[Ttown]

How many Qb's can you name you think are better than Dorsey.
Just to get a start;
Corny Green
John Unitas
Fran Tarkenton
Joe Montana
Rex Kern

 

[jlb1705]

Brady Quinn, Derek Anderson & Brett Ratliff?

 

[NFBuck]

Brady Quinn, Derek Anderson & Brett Ratliff?

 

[jwinslow]

Mallett, Threet, Newsome, Beaver, Forcier, Shoelace, Gardner, Munchie.

 

[buckeyemania11]

 

[Dryden]

Brady Quinn, Derek Anderson & Brett Ratliff?

Well, then you should probably add Jeff Garcia, Tim Rattay, and Alex Smith to that list too.

 

[jlb1705]

Pick of the Litter - that's an unfortunate pun. Makes me wanna cry too.

 

[buckeyesin07]

The guy in the middle just may be the best QB in that picture.

 

[BB73]

This thread performs fellatio on deceased amphibians.

Ken Dorsey won 34 straight games as a starting major college QB. I can only name 1 player with a better streak:

Chuck Ealey, with 35 from '69-'71 at Toledo.

 

[NextBuck]

This thread performs fellatio on deceased amphibians.

Ken Dorsey won 34 straight games as a starting major college QB. I can only name 1 player with a better streak:

Chuck Ealey, with 35 from '69-'71 at Toledo.

Ken Dorsey = Greatest College QB Ever

Ken Dorsey = Worst Professional QB Ever

 

[tundra1]

I'm assuming you're basing this on college productivity (based on pro ball, there are a lot more than 50):

I've listed 75, because I know that everyone will kick out some of the people on this list. However, I think most people, looking at this list, will find at least close to 50 names by their own rankings.

In no particular order:
1. Sammy Baugh
2. Davey O'Brien
3. Les Horvath
4. Paul Hornung
5. Steve Spurrier
6. Gary Beban
7. Jim Plunkett
8. Doug Flutie
9. Vinnie Testaverde
10. Andre Ware
11. Charlie Ward
12. Carson Palmer
13. Roger Staubach
14. Vince Young
15. Tommie Frazier
16. Tim Tebow
17. Art Schlicter
18. Danny Wuerffel
19. Michael Vick
20. Steve Walsh
21. Jamelle Hollieway
22. Major Harris
23. Archie Manning
24. Rex Kern
25. Joe Montana
26. Peyton Manning
27. Ryan Leaf
28. Tim Couch
29. Rick Mirer
30. Ty Detmer
31. John Elway
32. Jim McMahon
33. Tony Rice
34. Donovan McNabb
35. Randall Cunningham
36. Joe Hamilton
37. Timmy Chang
38. David Klingler
39. Drew Brees
40. Philip Rivers
41. Dan Marino
42. Troy Aikman
43. Steve Young
44. Turner Gill
45. Bernie Kosar
46. Troy Smith
47. Eli Manning
48. Byron Leftwich
49. Cade McNown
50. Jake Plummer
51. Kerry Collins
52. Steve McNair
53. Kordell Stewart
54. Drew Bledsoe
55. Jeff George
56. Jim Everett
57. Chuck Long
58. Todd Blackledge
59. Bert Jones
60. Dan Pastorini
61. Mike Phipps
62. Greg Landry
63. Bob Griese
64. Joe Namath
65. Roman Gabriel
66. Billy Kilmer
67. Fran Tarkenton
68. John Brodie
69. Len Dawson
70. Earl Morrall
71. Bobby Layne
72. Y.A. Tittle
73. Otto Graham
74. Sid Luckman
75. Tony Eason

 

[jlb1705]

This thread performs fellatio on deceased amphibians.

Ken Dorsey won 34 straight games as a starting major college QB. I can only name 1 player with a better streak:

Chuck Ealey, with 35 from '69-'71 at Toledo.

How many QBs can you name that had a better string of RBs to hand the ball to than Edgerrin James, Clinton Portis & Willis McGahee?

My post about Browns QBs was in jest. The wins stat was impressive, but that's not the end of the discussion. I think there were plenty of QBs in the history of college football who lost a game here or there who were better. However I think he belongs in the discussion with many of the guys one would name in a Top 50 or Top 75.

 

[Mike80]

Ken Dorsey = Greatest College QB Ever

Disagree - he was a good college QB on a GREAT team. He was, however, a great LEADER.

Ken Dorsey = Worst Professional QB Ever

Ryan Leaf?

Heath Shuler?

Ken Dorsey at least has hung around in the NFL for the better part of a decade.

 

[powerlifter]

Disagree - he was a good college QB on a GREAT team. He was, however, a great LEADER.






Ryan Leaf?

Heath Shuler?

Ken Dorsey at least has hung around in the NFL for the better part of a decade.

Definitely..There are a lot of talented teams,that just can't get it together. Dorsey was a great teammate and leader. He held the team together nicely.

 

[BB73]

How many QBs can you name that had a better string of RBs to hand the ball to than Edgerrin James, Clinton Portis & Willis McGahee?

My post about Browns QBs was in jest. The wins stat was impressive, but that's not the end of the discussion. I think there were plenty of QBs in the history of college football who lost a game here or there who were better. However I think he belongs in the discussion with many of the guys one would name in a Top 50 or Top 75.

My post was partially in jest (ttown is from Toledo, and so am I).

Winning is very important for a QB, but it's not the only criterion that matters. And being surrounded by talent makes it a helluva lot easier to win.

Glancing at the list of 75 posted earlier, I'd probably put Dorsey somewhere around #25, but I just don't care enough to rank everybody subjectively.