Most overrated NFL player?

[crazybuckfan40]

Ill go blow by blow with what you had to say.

1. saying that Vick has gotten to the playoffs isnt exactly a career defining moment. The NFC as a whole is pretty bad and if you arent one of the 6 teams that can make it, youre even worse.

2. he hasnt gotten close to winning, he beat who, st. louis in the playoffs? No the only other good team in the NFC, the Eagles, he got rocked by. And even if he managed to win that game, he still had to face another good team (oh my god you gotta play good teams in the playoffs???? )

3. Virginia Tech is still good without him, its called coaching. 3 words: Defense. Frank Beamer.

4. He didnt have to play directly against Brett Favre in the playoffs. He played their joke of a defense and ill give him credit, made some plays, but still, their defense.

5. Ok, hes been playing football for probably 15 years and by now i think everyone should accept hes an average passer. To the guy who said he did good in the Pro Bowl, give me a break. Anyone can do sweet with a roll call of the best in the business blocking and receiving for him, and playing against a defense that is just concentrated on not getting hurt.

1. Ok the dude has been in the league for 3 years. What do you want him to do. He made the playoffs 2 out of the 3 and played in 2 games the other year. His playoff record is 2-2. Not bad for a 4th year qb. Can you give me Peyton through 3 years if you want to compare him to Peyton.

2. I agree the NFC is not as strong as the AFC, but St. Louis and Green Bay in the playoffs are no slouch.

3. Take him off the team and they don't play for the NC. PERIOD.

4. It is called head to head qb to qb. He did too play against Brett Farve. He beat him in Lambeau plain and simple.

5. I agree he is not a great passer, but he has never had anything around him. That is what the guy with the pro bowl argument is trying to say.

 

[Brutus1]

Stop this stupid poll right here. Hands down, no comparison it's Charles Woodson.

The Raiders are stupid for paying that p.o.s 9 million bucks. He gets burnt regularly, misses tackles and makes stupid penalties.


What the hell is Freddie Mitchell doing on the list? don't you have to be percieved as being good to be overrated? Freddies a turd and everyone but Freddie knows it.

Again, WOODSON STINKS !!!!