Since the BCS era (starting with the 1998 regular season) Pitt has played for the mighty Big East Conference, which has a losing BCS record. Three Big Least schools have won a BCS game, while Cincinnati (0-2), Connecticut (0-1), Syracuse (0-1), Virginia Tech (0-1) and - Pittsburgh (0-1) have been skunked.
Pitt's one and only venture into BCS waters was when they faced Urban Meyer and his non-BCS conference Utah Utes in the 2005 Fiesta Bowl. "What's a Ute?" the Judge said in My Cousin Vinnie. Well, they are the team that sodomized Pitt 35-7 in Pitt's only BCS appearance.
I don't know about what would impress "May-Day", but what would impress me is not hearing about "it's only Akron" from a guy who comes from a program that is as completely irrelevant as Akron.