TheIronColonel
Hall of Fame
I've gotta be honest, I'd take Rey over James at middle linebacker. James makes a lot of tackles, but I'd like to see him right off blocks a little better (he was better last year than his sophomore year, but could still get better). Rey has the pure mass and strength to punish lead blockers and clog the middle of the line. James seems a little more comfortable playing in space, and diagnosing then running down plays (which he excels at). It's certainly not a criticism of James, it's just my opinion of his play style.
To his credit, I think James has one of the very few skills that AJ Hawk needs to develop more: man coverage. I'm a huge Packer fan (so I see all the games - thanks NFL Sunday Ticket), but I dread watching Hawk try to cover guys like Antonio Gates and Jason Witten. He's got the speed, but doesn't quite seem to have the coverage skills yet. James, on the other hand, seems to be quite good in coverage. I haven't seen him play outside linebacker yet (and yeah, there's a big difference between middle and outside - not all guys who are good in the middle are good on the outside), but I think he could be a real stud at outside linebacker on an NFL level.
I still think James wins the Nagurski award and is an All American again. If he does, he's easily the most decorated defender OSU has ever produced, and arguably the best. I think Hawk edges him a little bit (and Hawk got cheated out of a few awards, so there's that), but James is right in the conversation.
I'm really excited to see Freeman; he seemed to get a bit bigger and stronger in the offseason, and hopefully that will improve his game against the run. If so, offenses won't be able to key a lead blocker on James for every inside run - they'll have to respect Freeman a lot more. That could really help boost James production.
To his credit, I think James has one of the very few skills that AJ Hawk needs to develop more: man coverage. I'm a huge Packer fan (so I see all the games - thanks NFL Sunday Ticket), but I dread watching Hawk try to cover guys like Antonio Gates and Jason Witten. He's got the speed, but doesn't quite seem to have the coverage skills yet. James, on the other hand, seems to be quite good in coverage. I haven't seen him play outside linebacker yet (and yeah, there's a big difference between middle and outside - not all guys who are good in the middle are good on the outside), but I think he could be a real stud at outside linebacker on an NFL level.
I still think James wins the Nagurski award and is an All American again. If he does, he's easily the most decorated defender OSU has ever produced, and arguably the best. I think Hawk edges him a little bit (and Hawk got cheated out of a few awards, so there's that), but James is right in the conversation.
I'm really excited to see Freeman; he seemed to get a bit bigger and stronger in the offseason, and hopefully that will improve his game against the run. If so, offenses won't be able to key a lead blocker on James for every inside run - they'll have to respect Freeman a lot more. That could really help boost James production.
Upvote
0