• New here? Register here now for access to all the forums, download game torrents, private messages, polls, Sportsbook, etc. Plus, stay connected and follow BP on Instagram @buckeyeplanet and Facebook.

For you parents, did I overreact?

holybuckeye33

Hall of Fame
So last night my son has a sleep over for his 10th birthday. Him plus 5 other kids, all in the same grade. We took them to a minor league baseball game then game home, had cake and ice cream and said you guys can stay up as late as you want as long as you are quiet. Gave them options of numerous "pre-approved" dvds to watch.

Around 1:00 my wife and I go to bed, they are all still up watching dvds. Awake at 5:15 this morning with a thud. One child is standing at the top of our steps with a plush ball and trying to hit another as he runs past the bottom of the steps. My wife goes out and tells them to stop. Moments later we hear voices downstairs so I go down to check out what's going on. I discover that my son and another boy (probably his best friend out of the bunch) were asleep and the other 4 had marked (with black permanent marker on their face, back and arms) the two of them.

Needless to say we were very upset, because our son has very sensitive skil. The explanation given as to why was that they were the first to fall asleep. We told the boys involved that we were very disappointed in them and expected more out of them. We also told them that if it wasn't 5:30 in the morning their parents would be getting a call to come pick them up.

So when the parents do eventually come to pick them up, naturally one by one, asked, "Did they behave?" Now I understand boys will be boys, and I considered myself a very mellow and laid back person but I was not about to lie to their parents when something like that had occurred, so my wife and I were honest and said that we didn't know to which extent each kid was involved, but that we suspected that all four of them played a part. We have since learned this to be true.

My son is very close to all of these kids and each has spent the night at our house countless time, so I'm not sure what prompted this on this occasion. In fact 3 of the 4 involved and my son had a sleep over last week.

Anyway, the reason for this long post is that obviously these parents did not take it very well. One mother called crying and apologizing, another father called to apologized and informed that he may hold his son out of baseball allstars for this. My wife and I get along with all the parents really well, as do the kids, and I don't want this to come between either our relationship with the parents or my son's relationship with the boys.

The rationale for telling the parents is that we didn't want the same kids to go to a sleep over at another kids house and do the same thing and say "Well we got away with it at Mr. Such and Such's house (and no I don't know Maurice Clarett)." Then we get an angry phone call from another parent asking why we let the kids write all over each other with markers.

BTW, all of the parents said that they would have been more upset if we didn't tell them and that they would've done the same things as us if the situation were reversed, I just wanted to get an idea of how other people would have handled it.

Also, if you post on jjhuddle, you might have seen this already. I got the feeling that I was getting a lot of teenage type responders and wanted to try and get a more mature point of view.
 
I'm not a parent, but I don't think you overreacted at all.

I'm guessing one or more of the kids may have seen drunk 'shame-ing' on CollegeHumor.com, or some such website and thought it was funny/appropriate. I never though 'shame-ing' was particularly funny. And no, it's never happened to me :p I always locked my door when I passed out. :wink:
 
Upvote 0
I don't think you over reacted at all. It's not like you spanked the kids for doing it or something like that. I think I would be upset too if it had happened to my kids. I would like to know if they were at a sleepover (not old enough yet) and did something like that or had it happen to them. How did your son reacted when he woke up and found out what happened? Did he go along with it or was he upset that it happened? How did the parents of the other kid that had marker put on him react? You can't control how the other parents punish their kids so I wouldn't worry too much about that part.
 
Upvote 0
I AM a parent... and I think you did OK.. I can also relate because my 13 year old is always having or doing sleepovers... and I just assume I see the worst when they are here... things can easily get out of hand...

I suspect I would not have been as rationale as you were... I might have either told all the boys--- "it's 5 AM, go call your parents and tell them to come get you and tell them why" and watched the fear of death come on their faces... or might have carried it out... dunno.. I might have done it..

but absolutely you needed to tell the parents...
 
Upvote 0
My kids are not that age yet, but I hope to handle a situation in a similar manner if it ever happens, and I am sure it will. Telling the parents the truth was correct and it is now up to them to handle the discipline in whatever manner is appropriate. I know I would be upset if I found out from a source other than the host parents that one of my kids had pulled something like that.
 
Upvote 0
yeah i mean i dont know if the kid should be held outta his baseball thing, but as long as he knows that he screwed up, it should be good enough. maybe some kinda punishment but it could have been alot worse. someone could have gotten hurt, or damaged something expensive or whatever. but im not a parent so i cant really say that i am experianced in any of that.
 
Upvote 0
Just my 2 cents.

For 10 year olds, you reacted appropriate. Kids at that age can be really sensitive.

Now if it happens when he is about 16, feel free just to laugh at your son. By then it's pretty funny. Of course, at that age, it probably involves alcohol...so you still may need to get angry. Once it happens after 18 it is total humor. Just hope he doesn't have friends like the ones I had in college. I was never a victim, but there are worse things that can be done with someone passed out (no, nothing illegal...just more creative and way more embarrasing).

Let's just say if this is the worst thing that happens consider yourself a lucky parent.
 
Upvote 0
LoKyBuckeye said:
How did your son reacted when he woke up and found out what happened? Did he go along with it or was he upset that it happened? How did the parents of the other kid that had marker put on him react?
At 5:00 this morning, he was pretty upset, I mean this was his birthday party and these were his best friends. By the time the last kid left around 12:00, I think he had decided to let it go. Truth is so were we, but we thought the other parents should be aware of it. Luckily the other boy's parents are really really close friends and their son only got one dot on his nose and two markings on his back before we caught them. They were not upset at all and we actually called his parents this morning and explained the situation and drove him home ourselves so that we could explain everything to them and him again. We both agreed that it was a good thing that it was our sons that were sleeping because I'm positive that if the situations were reversed, our sons would've been right there. Too much peer pressure at that age.

I'll tell you what it was a whole hell of a lot easier to explain to the parents that something had happened to our kid than I would imagine it would have been to explain to them that our kid had done something to theirs.
 
Upvote 0
NJ-Buckeye said:
I AM a parent... and I think you did OK.. I can also relate because my 13 year old is always having or doing sleepovers... and I just assume I see the worst when they are here... things can easily get out of hand...

I suspect I would not have been as rationale as you were... I might have either told all the boys--- "it's 5 AM, go call your parents and tell them to come get you and tell them why" and watched the fear of death come on their faces... or might have carried it out... dunno.. I might have done it..

but absolutely you needed to tell the parents...
I too am a parent -- and man what a kick-ass suggestion you've got there NJ.

Nothing like instilling a little fear of pending parental reprisal in the young 'uns to get them back in line. :wink2:

Hey, all you non-parents one day it may be you - don't knock this until you've had to ponder doing it!

As for the original scenario as played out by holybuckeye -- no problemo, you already have your neighbors approval -- Well Done, Well Played. Add mine to your list.
 
Upvote 0
You showed much more restraint than I would have. Permanent marker, their parents would have gotten an immediate call from me to come pick them up. While I'm a firm believer in boys will be boys, that is beyond a childish prank. They were guests in your home, as such they needed to show respect. I don't think this prank makes them bad, but if the were allowed to get away with it what kind of message would that have sent them.
 
Upvote 0
Sounds to me like some of the other parents overreacted, not you.

KillSlashBurn said:
You showed much more restraint than I would have. Permanent marker, their parents would have gotten an immediate call from me to come pick them up. While I'm a firm believer in boys will be boys, that is beyond a childish prank. They were guests in your home, as such they needed to show respect. I don't think this prank makes them bad, but if the were allowed to get away with it what kind of message would that have sent them.
I disagree.
That is a very childish prank, and they are children.
No one died, they were out drinking or doing drugs, they played a prank on their friend.
I personally, would have been pissed to all hell to get a call at 5am just because my kid drew on another kid.
He acted completely appropriately in telling them when they came to pick up their children.
 
Upvote 0
So it would be okay with you for your children to be misbehaving while guests in somebody's home? That type of behavior is disrespectfull. If they did something like put peanut butter in their hair, or put their hands in warm water, or some other nondestructive prank I probably wouldn't even mention it. But the fact of the matter is using permanent marker on their host's face is not funny. Had I pulled a stunt like that when I was a child my mother or dad would have been over there in a heartbeat and would have been tanning my ass before I made it to the car.
 
Upvote 0
10-year-old kids don't know how much a pain to remove that permanent markers can be. It also sounds like a typical pre-teen prank, with no real malice intended. You reacted just fine...no where near over-reacting. You had every right, in fact had an obligation, to tell the parents what their sons did. Now, what the parents decided to do to their sons as punishment is their call...do NOT punish yourself mentally for "tattling on them". I liked NJ-Buckeye's suggestion of threatening to make them call their parents to pick them up early and why...that would really get their attention as to what they did. Bottom line, you did not over-react.
 
Upvote 0
Back
Top