Browns’ QB picks have been good, bad
Thursday, July 20, 2006
<TABLE cellSpacing=0 cellPadding=0 width="100%" border=0><TBODY><TR><TD>
[FONT=Verdana, Times New Roman, arial, helvetica, sans-serif]By Steve Doerschuk repository sports wRITER [/FONT]
</TD></TR></TBODY></TABLE>
Historically, ironically — and certainly not counting former No. 4 overall draft pick Otto Graham — the Browns have been better off with quarterbacks whose draft history parallels Charlie Frye’s.
The Browns are taking a chance that Frye can outplay his status as 2005’s No. 67 pick.
The franchise went backward with Milt Plum, who was No. 17 in 1957. The peach was Plum’s successor, Frank Ryan, originally a No. 55 pick of the Rams.
Ryan led the Browns to NFL championship games in 1964 and ’65.
Jim Brown, who took handoffs from both Plum and Ryan, touched on Ryan’s intangibles in his 1989 book, “Out of Bounds,” and talked to The Repository about the prospect of Frye becoming a latter-day Ryan.
Drafted in 1962 by Paul Brown, Ryan didn’t emerge until after Brown was fired and Blanton Collier opened up the offense, according to Brown.
“Blanton brought in Dub Jones to help revamp the offense,” Brown said in his book. “Dub and Blanton were big hits with the guys on offense. They would consult us ... let us participate in devising plays.
“Frank began to emerge as a passer. He had always been long on brains and courage, but he’d been dealt a rough hand. We were a running team. I dominated the press. Frank was always overlooked. Wounded pride can hurt.
“Under Paul, when Frank threw at all, it was often third-and-long, and Frank got roughed up.”
Brown, now a Browns consultant, said that Frye has “all the ability to be a star.”
“I like his attitude, his ability, his calmness, his feet. ... I just like him,” Brown said.
The quarterback who followed Ryan, Bill Nelsen, had been a former No. 136 overall pick of the Steelers. Known for bad knees and good leadership, Nelsen helped the Browns reach the 1968 and ’69 NFL title games.
Then there was Mike Phipps, who still makes some Browns fans cry. Art Modell traded Ohio icon Paul Warfield, a future Hall of Famer, for the right to spend a No. 3 overall pick on Phipps in 1970. In Phipps’ final two years as a starter, the Browns went 7-21.
Brian Sipe, who had been a No. 330 pick in 1972, replaced Phipps. Sipe was NFL MVP in 1980 for an 11-5 team Cleveland fans adored, and he was in Cleveland through 1983, when the team went 9-7.
Sipe still owns franchise records for career passing yards (23,713) and touchdowns (154). He still brings a smile to Sam Rutigliano, who was Sipe’s head coach then and watches Frye closely now.
Sipe was smallish and had an average arm. He compensated with grit, smarts and a system that accented his keen touch and timing.
“There are certain things people can’t know at draft time,” Rutigliano said during a recent stop at the team complex. “You have to see immeasurables to be sure about a guy, but there’s no X-ray machine for that.”
Rutigliano joined the Browns in 1977, after a period when Phipps was failing and Sipe was trying to prove he was a better option.
“The first time I met Brian,” Rutigliano said, “He told me, ‘Get me a system. Get me some smart guys. Get some condominiums (offensive linemen) up front.’ ”
Rutigliano senses shades of Sipe in Frye, who was 2-3 in his 2005 starts as a rookie third-round pick.
“I saw immeasurables in Charlie last year, based on the things he did without a full deck,” Rutigliano said.
His view is shaped by periodic conversation with Lee Owens, who coached Frye for four years in college.
“What Charlie accomplished at Akron was impressive,” Rutigliano said. “I’m not sure the guy from Marshall, Byron Leftwich, or the guy from Miami, Ben Roethlisberger, could have done at Akron what Charlie did.
“The biggest unknown about Charlie is, now .... now ... he’s the No. 1 quarterback, and everybody knows it. That’s a lot of pressure.”
Rutigliano recalls coaching a well-hyped youngster who couldn’t handle pressure.
“He swallowed a grapefruit,” Rutigliano said. “I don’t see Charlie doing that.
“There’s another key now, and that is, until they prove they have five condominiums, it ain’t gonna get done.
“For Charlie to succeed, they have to protect him. Reuben Droughns has to come through. Kellen Winslow and Braylon Edwards have to begin reaching their potential.
“They’ve made enough moves. Now, instead of Antonio Bryant at receiver, you have Joe Jurevicius. You’ve got Winslow and Edwards. These are impact players who help quarterbacks.
“They have enough things now where they’re not dreaming.”
Bernie Kosar was the only Browns quarterback since Sipe to enjoy more than spot success. Kosar left the University of Miami early and was taken by the 1985 Browns in a supplemental draft. He might have been a 1986 first-round pick, even though he had a third-round arm.
“Ideally, in Cleveland, you probably want a quarterback with a big arm,” said Marty Schottenheimer, Kosar’s head coach then and now with the Chargers. “Bernie didn’t have the big arm, but he had a great head for the game.
“His timing was impeccable. He could really make that comeback throw.”
Vinny Testaverde, a former No. 1 pick, helped the 1994 Browns to the playoffs but was reviled as the man who pushed out Kosar. Testaverde also is associated with the doomed 1995 season in which the team went 5-11 and skipped town.
The next primary quarterback, in 1999, was another No. 1 pick, Tim Couch. He wasn’t good enough to offset an expansion team’s supporting cast.
Now, the Browns enter a fifth straight season with a different projected No. 1 quarterback.
In 2002, it was Couch.
Then it was two former undrafted players, Kelly Holcomb in 2003 and Jeff Garcia in 2004. In 2005, it was former first-round choice Trent Dilfer.
Now, the Browns are hoping real hard that the third round is a charm. It’s Charlie Frye’s ball in 2006.
Reach Repository sports writer Steve Doerschuk at (330) 580-8347 or e-mail
[email protected]
Part five of a five-part series
Round three quarterbacks: THE SEARCH FOR JOE MONTANA
With the Charlie Frye era officially under way in Cleveland, The Repository’s Steve Doerschuk has examined quarterbacks selected in the third round of the NFL Draft — and Browns fans may shudder at what he spells out in a five-part series that concludes today: Not since the 49ers struck gold with eventual Pro Football Hall of Famer Joe Montana in 1979 has a great NFL QB come from the third round.
SUNDAY Charlie Frye will get the chance to prove if he’s a third-round boon or bust.
MONDAY A rather uninspiring cast fills the list of third-rounders since Montana.
TUESDAY Some had doubts about Montana in 1979 draft. Boy, were they wrong.
WEDNESDAY Tom Brady is one example of a recent QB find late in the NFL Draft. TODAY The Browns have hit — and missed, big-time — with QB picks.